Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Hopefully it's calibrated well, to not think that if the phone is in a car that's doing legitimate racing/track days, that it won't think hard braking or cornering is a 'crash'. A few years ago OnStar would come on while someone was doing laps in a Corvette at a track and asked if they were OK. 😆
 
  • Like
Reactions: rjw1678
That's for sure a potentially very good feature. But will it be reliable ? I mean that even a small quantity of false alarms will generate such a mess that it needs to be extremely well tested.
I looked up the G forces triggered by car accidents. Typically a 30mph crash will cause at least 30G of force on the items traveling in the car. Much more if there’s no seatbelt. Meaning if you toss your phone onto your bed or fall off a ladder it won’t be enough to trigger this. The new sensor can detect up to 256G of force.
 
It needs new hardware. A high g accelerometer that detects up to 256 Gs of acceleration and a high dynamic range gyroscope that can detect high speed rotation, like when the car, or your body, are spinning or rolling fast.
So a rollercoaster could potentially activate it
 
Uh oh, might want to get your stories straight before you two come back into the room!
Sure, we’re talking about a discrepancy of about half a year. I’ll admit I was wrong in stating the feature launched in 2018. It launched in 2019, but was made available for the pixel 3, which was launched in November 2018. The point being made though is that the person we were quoting was telling us all that they stay with Apple because other phone manufacturers are not bringing innovation to the market. That’s simply not true.
 
So a rollercoaster could potentially activate it
Not really. It uses a combination of sensors including atmospheric pressure to detect air bag deployment, microphones for sounds, etc. Also, no roller coaster gets even close to the extreme accelerations that happen in a car crash. Highest g-force roller coaster in the world is 6.3 g.
 
Sure, we’re talking about a discrepancy of about half a year. I’ll admit I was wrong in stating the feature launched in 2018. It launched in 2019, but was made available for the pixel 3, which was launched in November 2018. The point being made though is that the person we were quoting was telling us all that they stay with Apple because other phone manufacturers are not bringing innovation to the market. That’s simply not true.


Yeah I was mostly being facetious about your comments. I’m glad they have that feature! I wonder how accurate it is though. Apple markets a new accelerometer capable of measuring 256G’s of force. Roller coasters typically weigh in at 6G or so max it seems. Google’s site says it’s possible to trigger it falsely, which makes me think either that’s lawyer-speak or the sensors aren’t as fine tuned as they should be.

Then there’s the 60 second countdown vs 10 seconds. Is that because they’re worried there may be more false alarms triggered? Is there much of a difference to saving someone’s live over 50 extra seconds? Maybe. But then again maybe not.

Either way, I hope both features save lives.
 
I looked up the G forces triggered by car accidents. Typically a 30mph crash will cause at least 30G of force on the items traveling in the car. Much more if there’s no seatbelt. Meaning if you toss your phone onto your bed or fall off a ladder it won’t be enough to trigger this. The new sensor can detect up to 256G of force.
How many G do you get for a phone falling from 1m on a concrete ground ?
 
How many G do you get for a phone falling from 1m on a concrete ground ?
You let me know what you find out
 
You let me know what you find out
disclosure: I used to make micro-machined accelerometers.

You can check here for an example of computation: https://physics.stackexchange.com/q...ulate-gs-seen-by-a-dropped-object-upon-impact . Once you get the result you may be surprised (btw the page that you provide does not directly compute acceleration).
 
disclosure: I used to make micro-machined accelerometers.

You can check here for an example of computation: https://physics.stackexchange.com/q...ulate-gs-seen-by-a-dropped-object-upon-impact . Once you get the result you may be surprised (btw the page that you provide does not directly compute acceleration).
Yeah I saw that google result when I did a quick search. Not entirely scientific in their estimates, since there are so many variables.

Plus I would assume that the phone knew you were traveling at a certain G or speed already and then suddenly stopped, instead of barely moving and then suddenly a jolt from hitting the ground.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.