I'm glad they took away the downvote button. You can still criticize, you just can't be lazy about it by hitting a little arrow button. If you disagree with someone, why not say so?
Also, nanny state? Police state? I didn't realize MacRumors was a state. Do we get our own TLD now?
They took away down votes in order to reduce negativity so replying to everyone telling them they are wrong may not be the net win they were looking for. Plus there are a lot of you so it is a little time consuming to reply to each of you.