Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster


Apple will pay $95 million to settle a proposed class action lawsuit involving Siri spying accusations, reports Reuters. The lawsuit alleges that Apple recorded conversations captured with accidental Siri activations, and then shared information from those conversations with third-party advertisers.

siri-glow.png
 
Last edited:
"After the 2019 scandal about contractors listening to accidental ‌Siri‌ recordings"

accidental. Right. lol.

back in the day when I worked for Leapforce, as a subcontractor for Google, I must have listened to endless thousands of recordings (sometimes brief phrases, sometimes several seconds of dialogue). 100% of those recordings were clearly and obviously when the phone was just in the room. Zero of them were deliberate queries. Interesting how Google escaped a similar scandal when they were doing the same thing.

btw: There was one company (can't recall its name of the top of my head) that recruited "raters" for Apple. They did the same work we did, for the most part.
 
Apple was never secretive about the fact that some ‌Siri‌ recordings were analyzed by humans
.. and still Siri is dumb AF.

My wife and I get ads for things we were talking about all the time, even though we weren't searching for it on our computers. I don't think it's Apple, but Google tracking the tar out of us. They have their hands in so many things it doesn't surprise me.
 
"After the 2019 scandal about contractors listening to accidental ‌Siri‌ recordings"

accidental. Right. lol.

back in the day when I worked for Leapforce, as a subcontractor for Google, I must have listened to endless thousands of recordings (sometimes brief phrases, sometimes several seconds of dialogue). 100% of those recordings were clearly and obviously when the phone was just in the room. Zero of them were deliberate queries. Interesting how Google escaped a similar scandal when they were doing the same thing.
This is a case of being judged by your own standards. Anyone remember the old Red Dwarf episode The Inquisitor?
Apple is Kryten and Lister. Google is Rimmer and the Cat.

With Google there was no scandal as everybody knew Google's MO.
 
How do they know this came from Siri? I think it’s highly unlikely Apple would do this. I’d be more suspicious of Facebook/Insta/Snap, etc having microphone access and being allowed to run in the background. I don’t give any social media apps mic access and I’ve never had any of these weird targeted advertisement moments

Apple would have relatively little to gain and a lot to lose if they did this
 
It was direct Siri recordings. Apps don't have access to that.

But...

Two plaintiffs claimed that after speaking about products like Air Jordan shoes and Olive Garden, their devices showed ads for those products, while another said he received ads for a surgical treatment after discussing it privately with his doctor.

In these types of cases, are we to believe that Siri was accidentally triggered, recorded what was said AND Apple then sold that to advertisers causing ads to be shown? Seems unlikely.

There has been no evidence that Apple ever provided Siri recordings or information from Siri recordings to advertisers, and Apple's privacy policies have long made it clear that any data collected from Siri for the purpose of improving the feature is anonymized and not associated with a specific user.

I believe there is no doubt that Apple provided recordings to third parties for Siri research, but how are we to make the jump to advertisers?

Apps can and do have access to the microphone, were the plaintiffs perhaps mistaken about how their talk of Air Jordans etc were disseminated to advertisers? This is far more likely.
 
The voice recording for ads is everywhere. Meta apps (instagram, facebook, etc) are notorious for it. The mic is constantly on and the AI listens for keywords that then go to your profile and show up in your google ads, youtube ads, amazon recommended, etc.

If apple cared, they would add the "ask next time" or "just this once" dialog box whenever an app asks to use the microphone the same way they ask to use location. So you can set it to "always" or "never" or "ask next time"

Literally nothing in your life is private- anything around you with IO is being used to track and collect data about you and send it back to a server to monetize
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.