The criticism is a bit funny. This is oriented towards content consumption. I use my iPads for that. So I got one, as a way of staying up to date in software without killing my existing Air 5 and to replace my now significantly incompatible 9.7-inch iPad Pro. iOS 12 is now too much trouble for me after using it since Apple forcibly updated it from iOS 9 back in 2019.
I use my iPads for web browsing, a little light gaming, and content watching on stuff like Netflix. I want battery life, and compatibility. This is perfect.
Are you somebody running external displays or FCP? Not for you.
I now have the latest iOS version without killing my Air 5 and with a significantly (though yet to be determined) better battery life. I don’t need to spend three times as much to buy a 7th-gen iPad Pro as a second iPad for… web browsing, a little gaming, and TV shows and sports. This is okay for that.