Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Thanks goodness they protected the user for those damn speakers by a slab of non perforated aluminum.

Only now does that design decision - which we all dismissed as yet another case of fashion over function - makes perfect sense!
 
Nothing wrong with Apple's response to the issue. They're handling it well and quick and yes, it won't cost anything to the user.

But still sucks that something this potentially catastrophic made it through QA

Agreed, but catastrophic implies loss of life or not being unable to use the machine altogether, neither which is the case here. Creatives who are buying these machines to make a living, aren't relying on the internal speakers for audio output, let alone wouldn't be using Bootcamp on a Mac. I'm surprised we haven't seen this issue pop up on the forums yet (I could be wrong, someone can link that thread here if I'm missing it).
 
I work for one of Apple's competitors and I know for sure we wouldn't have handled this even at Apple's level. Then again, you wouldn't even hear this much about the issue if we had it, because we're not Apple.

So, so true. The amount of documented problems from other OEMs are swept under the rug or not addressed because they're not as in the spotlight as Apple, or because they keep manufacturing a thousand different models every month and the laptop you just bought is EOL in no time at all.
 
People are criticizing Apple for not catching this but when you think about it, not every tiny bug can be found in the QC process. It takes the product being released for them to be revealed. Most of these bugs are being fixed really fast and anyone affected is being treated right by Apple. I have no regrets buying the new 13" MacBook Pro. Its a pretty awesome machine!
 
People are criticizing Apple for not catching this but when you think about it, not every tiny bug can be found in the QC process. It takes the product being released for them to be revealed. Most of these bugs are being fixed really fast and anyone affected is being treated right by Apple. I have no regrets buying the new 13" MacBook Pro. Its a pretty awesome machine!

Yep, QA teams won't always find every last bug. The average QA/QC team is a tiny fraction of the size of any installed user base. While no bugs is the goal, it shouldn't be a surprise that things slip through the cracks once you have a large base of users "testing" your product.
 
The "genius" guy is of no help. I took in yesterday and he was clueless about this. At some point even acted like it was my fault for installing windows, that it was the windows software that messed it up and he didn't get the point that Apple provides the drivers. In the end, I have to wait 2 weeks before I can send my computer in for repair, in which case the will send it to a repair center and get it fixed, and then take up to 2 weeks to get it back in my hands. Very poor service for a flagship, $3000 computer that barely 2 weeks old.
 
Great now can we get a fix for the large file transfer issue? All this hype about thunderbolt 3/usb c speeds and everything I transfer larger files exceeding 200GB the system crashes.
 
You're all mocking Apple, but its Realtek who makes the Windows drivers - and only in Windows could a faulty driver cause your speakers to receive speaker blowing spikes.,
Apple is the one bundling the drivers with BootCamp.

It's Apple's job to test the drivers to see if they work properly.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Xi Xone
Agreed, but catastrophic implies loss of life or not being unable to use the machine altogether, neither which is the case here. Creatives who are buying these machines to make a living, aren't relying on the internal speakers for audio output, let alone wouldn't be using Bootcamp on a Mac. I'm surprised we haven't seen this issue pop up on the forums yet (I could be wrong, someone can link that thread here if I'm missing it).

ITS still a non-recoverable hardware failure.

I know if I just spent $3000+ on a brand new computer, and within 1 week, the OEM's own software physically broke the hardware, I'd be very very frustrated. sure, it's not a "priority 1" situation that prevents usage of the device complately. But it's still a high priority item that is impacting the device in a way that I cannot use all functionality that I have paid for.
 
wired-pray-apple-1997-article-front-cover.png


We're getting back to this. So sad to see.

Time for you to go Tim... and you too Jony.
 
Replacing the entire computer to fix a couple of speakers? Me thinks it is something that gets blown on the motherboard. Maybe the bad Windows driver causes a high DC offset that blows an under rated output capacitor?

Current Apple computers are designed to be disposable. 'Reduce, Reuse, Recycle' has been changed to 'If anything breaks throw it and your money away and buy another one'. The hypocrisy of Apple being 'environmentally conscious' is blatant.

Creatives who are buying these machines to make a living, aren't relying on the internal speakers for audio output, let alone wouldn't be using Bootcamp on a Mac.

I see this all the time. What type of 'creatives' are you talking about?
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.