I've tried a moto 360 and two AW, while I liked notifications , I found I used the phone to reply.
For me it's like using desktop sites and mobile version of sites, I find desktop more intuitive and easier to use.
Frankly I was after an excesise accessory, and I like my watch, AW is not a very good exercise accessory, there are better bands out there.
I really wanted to like it , bought it twice , thought went for my mechanical watch most days.
Not to mention in am older now and a classy mechanical watch is much more elegant than a phone accessory ....smart watches remind me of the calculator watches...