Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Haha, how should that work ... attack is something not really foreseeable ... that’s the inherent nature of an heart attack.

You wanna have none, live healthy, even then no guarantee
It's magical.
[doublepost=1544113512][/doublepost]
The haters are out in full force today. Just a hint of anything positive for Apple and they come out it droves. How is this feature not a cool thing to have?
I'm not a hater. I want Apple to succeed. I just think they are moving in the wrong direction. Does it make me a hater? I guess it does.

There's a category of people who throw the "hate" word at everyone who disagrees with them.
 
The Watch is so Much more than a notification device anymore, it’s beyond that. The watch is the one product that has the strongest future of all Apple products. I remember before this launched in April 2015, it was deemed a ‘novelty’ item or ‘failure’ from those ‘online analysts’. The reality is, it’s the opposite leading in the health direction to encourage those to stay motivated and a monitor for health indicators. What has my interest piqued, is to see what the Watch offers five years from now, perhaps glucose monitoring would be another considerable feature other than ECG.
 
Literally just measured my heart rate manually (on my neck) and it matches the Apple Watch reading for the same period. I wear my watch quite tight with a sport loop, so perhaps people reporting inaccurate reading should try and wear the watch differently? The cameras need to be able to see your blood flowing in order to provide an accurate reading.
 
Which means we'll have money to pay for education and educators, so Americans will become true intellectuals.
Super win win for all, all because of the EKG function of the Apple watch!!!
Ahaha exactly. Crime will become non existent as well as even the most unfortunate and poor will be vested into a better society for all on equal footing. Our current path is doomed to fail.
 
  • Like
Reactions: yaxomoxay
Solution: Make Apple pay for every unnecessary visit to a doctor because of those crappy functions.
 
The haters are out in full force today. Just a hint of anything positive for Apple and they come out it droves. How is this feature not a cool thing to have?

Apple usually released features when they were ready ... with Watch that pattern is not true anymore. They release just something for the sake of releasing and use some marketing buzz words ... fall dedection per default, deactivated haha!
 
It's magical.
[doublepost=1544113512][/doublepost]
I'm not a hater. I want Apple to succeed. I just think they are moving in the wrong direction. Does it make me a hater? I guess it does.

There's a category of people who throw the "hate" word at everyone who disagrees with them.

Fitness and medical areas are the future.
 
Any negatives other than the Watch’s false positives? Not if it means Apple can milk a few more wavering potential buyers with this ‘load o’ hype’. ECG in this case meaning “E xtremely C lever G uff”. For some people, Apple could say the watch can do ECT as well as ECG therapies and they’d take it as read. Cos Apple said so.

“Yeah like, that’s a scientific fact. OK. There’s no real evidence it can somehow do diagnostic ECGs using just a wrist probe (whereas a true electrocardiogram needs four physical limb and six chest leads to perform a 12 Lead assessment and costs thousands of pounds and years of training), but it IS a scientific fact!”

Electronic Snake Oil Is Here!
 
Literally just measured my heart rate manually (on my neck) and it matches the Apple Watch reading for the same period. I wear my watch quite tight with a sport loop, so perhaps people reporting inaccurate reading should try and wear the watch differently? The cameras need to be able to see your blood flowing in order to provide an accurate reading.
It is inaccurate during the exercise, brisk walk, running, etc. It's usually accurate when you initiate the measurement when you are at rest. However, the Apple Watch also takes its own measurement every 5 minutes or so, and that one is quite often completely off.
[doublepost=1544114744][/doublepost]
Where should they be moving then? Genuinely curious.
I can type up a list here. It doesn't matter, though, because Cook is not listening. I sent him an email the other day. Maybe someone will read it although I doubt it.
 
I can type up a list here. It doesn't matter, though, because Cook is not listening. I sent him an email the other day. Maybe someone will read it although I doubt it.
Hahaha. You just don't want to put your quasi-name on what is likely bad advice.
 
It is inaccurate during the exercise, brisk walk, running, etc. It's usually accurate when you initiate the measurement when you are at rest. However, the Apple Watch also takes its own measurement every 5 minutes or so, and that one is quite often completely off.

Never had an issue with monitoring my heart rate during a workout. I know exactly what my HR should be at intervals and Apple Watch is usually within 2-3 BPM of that at any given interval. Apple never claimed it was 100% precise and I don't rely on it to be.

And if I want an accurate reading during 'normal' activity I open the HR app, rather than go on the last available reading. It's like a single press on the complication to initiate and it's spot on.
 
That more people will finally go to see a cardiologist. Finally. Considering the obesity rate in the US, this is a good thing.
The frequent misconception held by lay commenters is that all cardiac problems are heart attacks and that the patients fit a typical profile of poor diet and lack of exercise. Thus, they think this new feature is detecting heart attacks. Actually, it's detecting abnormal heart rhythms, which are usually not fatal in themselves, but can result in a fatal stroke if left untreated for too long. To simplify things: in atrial fibrillation, the upper and lower chambers of the heart (atria and ventricles respectively) are not working in sync, so the ventricles are not fully filled up before they pump the blood out. The heart is working less efficiently, so your exercise tolerance is reduced; and there can be blood pooling in the chambers instead of being pumped out. That can clot and cause a stroke.

The case described in the Time article is a pretty typical example of what the device and app really can do. Persistent atrial fibrillation isn't easy to diagnose without an ECG: you might feel less fit than usual, or be vaguely aware of your heart. In my case, I probably went a week before seeing my doctor. In the case in the article, the app was able to point out immediately that there was a problem. The patient saw his doctor, who confirmed the AF, probably put the patient on an anticoagulant medication to prevent clotting, and probably had a cardioversion, an RF ablation or other procedure to get the heart back into normal sinus rhythm and keep it there.

Once you know you have a history of AF, you can use the watch (or in my case a Kardia device) to monitor your rate and rhythm. I've subsequently had two AF episodes since my first one, both detected within minutes with the Kardia, and
it also helped my cardiologist and me figure out that some chest pain I was having was a side effect of my medication rather than another heart problem. Because I could check my ECG at any time and because we had a good management plan for any AF recurrence, I was able to discontinue the medication, which is all the better for maintaining my normal activity and exercise.
 
Never had an issue with monitoring my heart rate during a workout. I know exactly what my HR should be at intervals and Apple Watch is usually within 2-3 BPM of that at any given interval. Apple never claimed it was 100% precise and I don't rely on it to be.

And if I want an accurate reading during 'normal' activity I open the HR app, rather than go on the last available reading. It's like a single press on the complication to initiate and it's spot on.
Say what you want. It's also different for different people. In my household, two people have been wearing Apple watches for three years now. Heart rate monitor is the weakest feature for us. When my wife and I go for a walk, the heart-rate monitor gets stuck on a low number and doesn't provide real numbers for either one of us. Maybe it's humidity. Maybe it's skin type. Who knows.

When I do strength training, Apple Watch can't measure my heart rate either. At rest, it's pretty accurate when manually initiated.

I don't have a Series 4 watch yet. I decided to stay with Series 3. I doubt that Series 4 heart monitor is improved compared to Series 3. At least, I haven't seen any information to that effect.
 
Say what you want. It's also different for different people. In my household, two people have been wearing Apple watches for three years now. Heart rate monitor is the weakest feature for us. When my wife and I go for a walk, the heart-rate monitor gets stuck on a low number and doesn't provide real numbers for either one of us. Maybe it's humidity. Maybe it's skin type. Who knows.

When I do strength training, Apple Watch can't measure my heart rate either. At rest, it's pretty accurate when manually initiated.

Open a support call then. That's the normal route to follow when you feel your device is not behaving as expected.
 
As someone that had open heart surgery, I strongly resent this statement. Is the AW going to be THE main check-up tool? No. But it provides a level of flexibility and continuous availability that was not possible before - at least not without some "unnatural" intrusion such as a band. This is just a watch with an important functionality added.
And heck, I'd rather bother my doctor with a few false positives than risk missing an important true positive. You know, I pay him and he accepts the payment, which will include this type of services.


"I'd rather bother my doctor with a few false positives"

I can tell you how your doctor feels about the above statement...
 
The Apple Watch is the first ever wearable device certified by the FDA as a bona fide medical device. Do not forget this.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.