Back on AppleInsider, I felt that, for the first year, fewer than 10 million sales would be a failure, 10 million to 14 million would be disappointing, 15-19 million would be good, and 20 million or more would be excellent.
The fact that Tim Cook has not once hinted at sales figures is, in itself, a bad sign. The excuse that he doesn't want to help the competition is lame; if sales were brilliant, he would have trumpeted them from the rooftops.
I predicted that the Apple Watch would flop from the start. So it is proving. It represents Tim Cook's first new product since the death of the great Steve Jobs, and is proof that Apple have lost it under him. As such, his days as CEO should be over. He should return to his position as COO and let someone with passion for Apple products lead the way. I would suggest Craig Federighi as a prime candidate.
I want to see Apple become great once again. It won't happen under Tim Cook.
Disagree. Tim is doing a great job. Don't blame him for the lack of innovation in the industry in general. We're in a technology plateau. There are a lot of exciting technologies in the early stages of development that will be exciting in the future and lead to amazing new products. But they are years away. People need to stop expecting a showstopper every year. It's unrealistic to the point of being ridiculous.
Tim is doing exactly what we need him to do. He's running a well oiled machine. He's selling tons of the bread and butter product (iPhone). Craig the used car salesman doesn't strike me as CEO material.
The watch is a bomb. Like you said, if sales were strong, he'd be throwing out numbers every chance he got. But that alone doesn't make him a bad CEO.