So far, the people answering you missed it lol
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Apple Working on Haptic Buttons for iPhone, iPad, Apple Watch
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
An excellent move by Apple. Though the negative Apple doesn't know what they're doing conclusions are predictable.
They also make the best trackpads in the industry. Solid-state haptic trackpads. You'd think making the little buttons on an iPhone solid-state would be easy by comparison!
Apparently you've never used any of Apple's haptic buttons. The Home Button on the last few iPhones that had them, or the trackpad on MacBooks, are some of the most impressive haptic buttons you will ever find. You'd have a hard time convincing someone that they weren't real buttons at all with the way they feel.
stolid
/ˈstɒlɪd/
adjective
- calm, dependable, and showing little emotion or animation.
"a stolid bourgeois gent"
Agree 100% about the trackpad. I recall the haptic home buttons on iPhone not being that great, though? They definitely felt quite different to the earlier mechanical home buttons.
Sad that Apple key features in the last two iterations have been buttons, and it seems it won’t stop…..
Im down for this on the ipads and iphones...but the crown on the watch and airpods max...i dont see how they are going to make that solid state...that doesn't make any sense what so ever.
In fact, id love if they added the crown to the actual iphone and ipads...unnessary yes, but the idea of an actual scroll wheel to scroll though text on the ipads...if done right, i really like that idea!
I often wonder why the ipads never got a haptic motor in the first place? that and NFC chips as well. I never understood why those lack those core features in every iphone!
In fact, id love if they added the crown to the actual iphone and ipads...unnessary yes, but the idea of an actual scroll wheel to scroll though text on the ipads...if done right, i really like that idea!
I often wonder why the ipads never got a haptic motor in the first place? that and NFC chips as well. I never understood why those lack those core features in every iphone!
Yup, and when I grab my phone I apply a certain pressure. It’s never going to be foolproof and consistent.
This 'feature' isn't even on my top 1,000 list for the iPhone. I want iOS to better recognize what I'm typing and make speech to text work better.
Thinner, more cameras, vibrating buttons, etc... were more important pre-AI. Not anymore.
Thinner, more cameras, vibrating buttons, etc... were more important pre-AI. Not anymore.
I also wonder how this would work in my pocket.
I routinely press the volume buttons while the iPhone is in my pocket, and that's done by just pressing the button from the side (no device "squeezing").
I wonder what the end game is here, because it can't just be about making the buttons more reliable or improving waterproofing, because the current design is great in both regards.
It has to be about more than just the buttons, such as them wanting to change the design of the phone's frame in a way that can't be done if the current button design is used (like, to choose a terrifying example, making it out of glass).
It has to be about more than just the buttons, such as them wanting to change the design of the phone's frame in a way that can't be done if the current button design is used (like, to choose a terrifying example, making it out of glass).
Unless I’m mistaken they’re never actually completely “off” (unless the battery is completely drained).
Say nice things. Make it feel wanted.
My cousin works as an hardware engineer at Apple. There are different R&D projects running classified in different levels. Each department gets it yearly budget which they NEED to use for their products to improve or innovate in some ways. This solid state button has been worked on for three years now, it derived from the vibration module in iPhone and the now finished Macbook Trackpad. Even though it seems burning cash, it is an essential part of yearly budgets given departments at Apple.
So yes, most obvious innovations are worked on but the tech is not there yet, hence the slow progress on their products.
So yes, most obvious innovations are worked on but the tech is not there yet, hence the slow progress on their products.
A point of ingress is removed. Fewer moving parts. Simplified assembly. Fewer total parts.
Last edited:
And the one on the iPhone 8 Plus was amazing, FAR superior to the physical button on the iPhone 6s Plus.
The iPhone 8 Plus’s solid state home button worked fine for me with gloves and when my hands were wet, and it’s a safe bet that the tech has progressed a long way since then.
All in yur mind Yu just need t adjust! Less unnecessary characters! I remember Andy Rney cmmenting some 25 years ag that he never used punctuatin at end f sentences, and instead just used three spaces t signify a sentence stopping Its a feature
Thanks. Although the phone's hard to use with gloves anyway, it's often useful to be able to use the buttons regardless.
My macbook has a fantastic "haptic" trackpad, but won't work with gloves. This isn't an issue, of course, as I've never needed to use my laptop while wearing thick gloves.
Well I honestly don’t notice that I have a haptic button. So I guess they work just as well as real buttons.
Although that doesn’t mean we need them. Presumably they take up less space and less prone to failure than mechanical, but I don’t know if that’s true.