Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
In theory these products sound so amazing, but I'm curious to see how they look and would work in the real world. Rendering by rtr1985 is amazing.
 
1740513372174.png
 
I don’t know what this means.
Smart doorbells have a battery of some kind, have for years.
Not mine. I have a Ubiquiti G4 doorbell camera that gets its power from the doorbell transformer. It also only stores video on my own local Cloud Key's HD, so even if the vendor wanted to share video with the cops or feds (ala Ring and others), they couldn't.
 
Hardwired power and ethernet or no sale. Ideally PoE. WiFi is a no go as it is too easily defeated. Needing to charge the doorbell is just stoopid.

All I want is a poe powered doorbell that uses Ethernet and connects to my doorbell wiring to trigger my bell. Secure as possible so Ethernet instead of WiFi.

Doesn't the Ring Video Doorbell Elite do what you're asking for?
 
Ideally you would charge it off the voltage from the doorbell wires right? I have never had to charge my ring doorbell because the house keeps it topped up. As long as the doorbell isn't pulling more power than the wall can provide it's fine. Im a little worried Apple is going to do some weird proprietary thing that doesn't work with standard house wiring.
 
Very possible. Expecting this next year after the launch of Home device this year. As for MagSafe, not so sure whether there is a need for it on a doorbell.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mganu
Some ‘smart’ doorbells have 9V battery contacts as backup in a full mains+internal battery outage.

It would be more convenient to temporarily power an Apple doorbell with reverse MagSafe charging from your iPhone in such a scenario, or power your phone from the doorbell if you’ve run the phone battery down beyond Express mode availability.
Yeah, this is it - it’s to charge your phone so you can get in your house when your phone dies.
 
Doesn't the Ring Video Doorbell Elite do what you're asking for?
It does but I will not buy Amazon products unifi g4 does most of it but the option is either a dumb add on brick that converts Poe to usb-c or you have to have an Ethernet connected chime not the end of the world and right now leaning toward it. The chime would easily install where my transformer is housed now.
 
I have a question :) Just wondering. Does Macrumors get payed by Mark Gurman when his name is mentioned? And is that a monthly fee? Or does he pay for everytime his name is mentioned?? Im guessing its the last? :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: wyliej
Apple would likely tout the privacy and security benefits of its own smart home doorbell. Apple already offers a HomeKit Secure Video service with end-to-end encryption for storing footage in iCloud, and the doorbell could have a Secure Enclave.

Not in the UK. In the UK the government will ask for a 'back door' so they can see everyone video feeds.
 
Seriously what type of shady neighbourhood are people living in. Security cameras, smart everything, blah blah blah seems like paranoia overload to me plus add many social media apps and then people wonder why mental health conditions are on the rise.
It's actually the opposite. Criminals go to nice neighborhoods to steal stuff. Not the shady ones. But, I guess if you live in shady one, you don't need cameras or understand.

Also, why would having a smart lock that recognizes you and unlocks the door paranoia overload? Some people like to go for a run and not have to carry keys. Nice to just come home and get in without needing to drag keys around. It's a convenience.

Funny how you mention social media apps and mental health as you burn time making comments on web sites.

I'm not saying I'd buy this. But, I see that some people would.
 
A ring wired doorbell pro doesn’t have an internal battery. It’s hardwired from house electricity. And even lots of chime wired doorbells don’t have a battery.

(search for battery please... again, the act of pressing the button cuts the power you're referring to so, yes they do ALL have batteries to my knowledge)
 

(search for battery please... again, the act of pressing the button cuts the power you're referring to so, yes they do ALL have batteries to my knowledge)
They make 2 versions. A battery operated one, and a hardwired one. The hardwired one is only powered from the transformer and existing doorbell wiring from your house. There is no battery inside.

And to prove my point, you can’t even connect a traditional mechanical chime to the wired version of the Ring. People have tried, but it’s physically impossible because it’s missing the required internal parts. But you can connect a mechanical chime to their battery operated doorbell. And this works for the reason you stated, about circuits being broken.

The wired Ring video doorbell connects wirelessly over the internet to chimes you plug in your house. So when you press the doorbell, it doesn’t complete a circuit. It just sends an alert over the internet to your chimes and smartphone. It’s completely different than a regular doorbell.
 
Last edited:
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.