Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
What would even be the point of this? I have thought long and hard about these foldable phones/tablets and I do not see how it helps anyone other than a niche group of people.
A lot of people currently use big-screened phones for the utility, and such a phone would be more portable if it could fold. Separately, I think those people should find something better to do while outside, but oh well.
[automerge]1592284723[/automerge]
Haven’t LG and Microsoft done something like this already?
[automerge]1592255051[/automerge]

I’d rather have the crease than two displays put together with a hinge in the middle. If it’s anything like Microsoft’s efforts it just comes across as clunky. I also don’t really see it as a foldable display. It’s just putting two displays together and putting a bridge in between them which allows the device to fold.
It's like the Nintendo DS, which worked great.
 
Last edited:
inst that an iPad Mini? duh
[automerge]1592263571[/automerge]


then buy an iphone 11 pro max or a smaller tablet.
That means you have to carry around multiple devices. I currently have to carry around my 11 pro max and iPad mini. However I’d prefer one device like the galaxy fold. Folded it’s a smartphone and unfolded it’s a tablet and it fits nicely in my pocket.
[automerge]1592290636[/automerge]
Exactly! I’ve seen this before.
 
Gotta say, I love the consistency of these curmudgeon forum replies. They are almost identical in substance to the opinions on the first scroll wheel iPod when it was released😂😂😂
 
  • Like
Reactions: Johns12 and bobob
Apple, like the innovative company they are, have long figured out that you cant bend a screen which is not designed to bend. So they made 2 instead, foldable, until there is a screen which can actually bend without suffering damage.

EXACTLY! Leave it to Apple to do it correctly. This is exactly the design I’d expect from them. They got a lot of things wrong, but they know what they’re doing on so many fronts.
 
I remember many many moons ago, I got the first Galaxy Note with its at the time massive screen!! lots of folks here stated who would want such a monstrosity, nobody would buy or have a need for such a monster, Boy was everyone proved wrong as Apple finally COPIED the screen size,
I would love a folding phone, Apple bring it on,
 
With a thicker, heavier, less durable device.
Well, it does need to evolve over generations.

I personally don’t understand what’s not to like. IMO if you say a folding phone doesn’t need to exist, you’re saying a tablet doesn’t need to exist.
 
LOL why doesn't apple just buy the Huawei one and rebrand it apple and sell us that? It's amazing and the best I've seen. 2 Screens with a hinge? Please.
 
  • Disagree
Reactions: JBGoode
I remember many many moons ago, I got the first Galaxy Note with its at the time massive screen!! lots of folks here stated who would want such a monstrosity, nobody would buy or have a need for such a monster, Boy was everyone proved wrong as Apple finally COPIED the screen size,
I would love a folding phone, Apple bring it on,
I also had the first galaxy note. I remember my dad laughing at me and saying it looked ridiculous. Switch forward some years and he got the galaxy note 4 and now has the note 8. He said the same about my first Apple Watch. It was silly and he didn’t see the point. Now he has a Samsung galaxy watch.
 
Sadly I can't find my photoshopped image from about 2009... but I swear it looked just like the above, except using 2 x 3GS... :)
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Shanghaichica
I own an iphone 11 pro max. I also own an iPad mini. There’s room for a device that has the size of the former but can be unfolded to something like the size of the latter.
[automerge]1592265794[/automerge]


Very insightful critique of a non-product that you’ve never seen

I did not see you write any assessment of the Courier concept. I take it you're not aware of it and have never heard about it.
 
I work for a cell phone carrier and at first I wasn’t sure about a folding phone, but after playing with one all the time I am ready to buy one from Apple. You don’t have to open the phone every time to use the Fold, and its really nice to have all that screen real estate once you do.
 
I’d rather see an iPad Pro turned into a folding screen device. You could use it in laptop mode where one screen is the keyboard, or fold it open completely and get the full 12.9” screen (as one example).
Making a tablet foldable was certainly my thought. Much more sensible than expanding the smaller device screen to be a tablet size and then try to shrink it down again, i.e. fold. And that would satisfy...
You are more productive with two screens. If you just use the phone for chatting or taking pictures, two screens is not important, however there are other workflows like having an email on the left and a document on the right, video call on one screen and takes notes on the other. As MS said, two screens makes you more productive that is the reason the Duo exists, current phones are focused on cameras, Surface Duo is trying something else with a purpose.
 
Here's hoping this is the new iPad Mini Pro! I have been railing for a couple of years now that folding screens are still not ready for prime time, and may not be for 2-3 more years. This is a sensible solution to giving us a larger iPhone in a more compact package. If anyone could do it, Apple would design a hinge mechanism with sufficient overlap to make the two screens appear to be one. Add in Pencil 2 support and you have the perfect moleskin replacement.
 
  • Like
Reactions: newyorksole
But this has been done already. Apple aren’t the first.

When is Apple really the first to bring certain technologies to market? Lol. That doesn’t matter.

Smartphones weren’t mainstream until Apple. MP3 players, tablets etc weren’t mainstream until Apple.

Idk what’s going to happen with this foldable display, but there will be much more noise about foldable displays if Apple releases one and its sleek/smooth/powerful.
 
For people that don't understand folding phones, the idea is pretty simple.

You get a bigger screen in a smaller form factor. It's extremely inefficient to scale up the body of an iPhone just to match the display size.
Stop making it sound like there are no downsides.

”Bigger screen in a smaller form factor” leaves out important details like weight, thickness, usability issues, durability issues, etc.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jmgregory1
Since I am working in the same industry I highly do not recommend to buy such products since this is still so primitive solution based on flex pcb just between two PCB boards. Reliability will be always a problem in such design. The true flex smartphone require flex display and all boards on flex. Even that we need to decrease size and technology of most of electronic components which is impossible now so they need to be laser cutted on flex to minimize a solder joint crack.
 
In order to really make a fold-able phone "work" it's going to require rethinking and redesigning the basic concept of a phone.

Right now we're in an in-between phase, where we have fold-able screens, but which are otherwise still attached to solid and separate objects. Meaning, the case and all the other parts and components like circuit board, battery, etc. Most of these would have to be printing inside the screen itself.

I could imagine a future phone actually being something like a small slender tube where you simply roll the screen out.
 
Agreed. It’s one thing when you’re typing on a screen that fits in your hand, but going larger and not having any kind of feeback or differentiation between keys makes it just feel cheap and wrong to me. It kind of reminds me of my first computer in the late ‘70’s - an Atari with the plastic keyboard that wasn’t really a keyboard. I hated it. It was even worse that typing on glass because you had to push on the “keys” hard enough to get the button sensor below the plastic cover to click for it to register your input. Back then I had learned basic typing first on a non-electric typewriter, so it wasn’t so out of place to have to push hard on each key, but without having any movement like you do with a typewriter, it was just so unnatural in how it worked (or didn’t).

It’s funny how there is this subset of computer users today using new “old” mechanical keyboards, that have tons of key travel and the clickety clack sound to them. I dig the throwback appeal, but given the number of times I need to multi-task while on conference calls, I really don’t want everyone to hear me type on the call.

Yeah I always hated those membrane type keyboards! I think you might be a tiny bit older than me as I learned to type in high school on an electric typewriter, but we still had to manually white out typos lol. That was state of the art!!
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.