Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Yeah basically. If you give them access.

And btw... Apple wouldn't know it... Because once your app is reviewed in the store you could just flip the switch on the server to enable the part of your code that actually uploads your photos library.

Apple doesn't review your source code at that level of detail.
Glad I made a video on this last night for YouTube. That's scary. I never allow Photos or Contacts permission. There are too many messed up scenarios where devs will steal that info.
 
For me, Apple are doing all the right things these days. Fantastic products, great software and the best personal security and privacy I can reasonably expect. I’m fully invested in them and I cannot see that changing in the immediate future :)
 
Didn’t read article yet, but is there really any effective way of broadly enforcing this?

Would seem to me it would be difficult for Apple to know who is doing what with contact data after they capture it.

And for someone who’s business model is “get the data and sell it”, getting banned from the store after the fact doesn’t seem like much (esp if they can create another dev account and start over under a proxy.)

My thought is that Apple needs more granular contact info release controls in the privacy settings.
 
Agreed, I just checked and I have only given six apps this permission:
  • One of them being Apple's own Airport Utility
  • Two being calendar apps (I guess one usage is when auto-completeing an entry based on names in ones address book)
  • Two of them being 'social media', Skype & Signal, for both of which having access to the contacts list is essential when you want to contact somebody else by starting with their name only
  • An app to create a map where the locations of a group people are marked.
None of them would need to upload any data from my address book to function but Skype probably does so.

Skype is.... remember Snowden?
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.