Had another look at that selfies clip thinking I might have missed something the first time. But I honestly can't say that I think they're horrible. Sure they aren't professional quality shots with optimum lighting conditions etc., but to me they seem passable for the use they're intended for.As a non-professional who couldn't tell an okay shot from a good shot or a good shot from a great shot... these are terrible. They have a disconcerting quality that makes your eye tell your brain that, "Hey bud, there's something not quite right about what I'm lookin' at here. You wanna analyze it?" Then when your brain finds the mistakes you just can't unsee them. The software definitely needs more time in the oven.
Apple should really find out what the good folks over at Focos are doing with image processing.
Can and will 'Portrait Lighting' be refined in future software releases? Undoubtedly.