Ughh I am a watch guy like many who have replied. I love timekeeping, and the idea of such a marvel of mechanical engineering right on my wrist that provides not complexity to my life. I will say here that over the years in the pre-smartwatch days my more sporting friends would argue that wearing a watch at all was "complicated", which at some point in the past was likely true. All that said, Iahve worn a wristwatch since I was a wee lad when my grandparents presented me with a Timex Quartz with twist-o-flex band. I have ran the gamut since then and not need get into detail there.
Yes I miss wearing a non-connected watch. The problem is the AW has so much utility and once I mastered the simple test of turning off notifications when I need to concentrate I haven't felt enough need to go back. I have owned every iteration of the AW (not every style) since launch, my AW 4 has lasted the longest on my wrist, ordered at launch and still have it on today.
I love the fitness functions but have always been a fit guy so don't really need them to stay in shape, they are more of a novelty for this guy. I wish the watch faces were open to developers, I like some of them, but really would like a more robust selection. I wish the time would display always even if it was dimmed and similar to nightstand mode, but it doesn't seem like Apple and the masses are interested.
What I like that my mechanical watches lack:
I can actually answer a call and can hear and understand the caller and vice versa
I can load my playlist and audio books on the watch, pair my AirPods and go for a jog in my tightest shorts (drink it in)
I can set a timer while cooking, or any other activity that I need to get back to without my phone out of my pocket
I can map my hike/run, not necessary for a hike, but for a geek like me I used to carry a large GPS for this activity along with my phone.
I can control the camera on my phone for photos/videos when on a little tripod, very handy for a variety of things
Glance at the Moon cycle (yes mechs do this but I never liked those styles)
Weather forecast is a glance away
Sunset/Sunrise is a glance away
Time is always spot on!
I can take my own EKG! WTF that's crazy! I am on the wrong side of 40 so my finite life is on my mind more than when I was 20, so this is another win for me
Last but not least Mickey Mouse calls me PAL!