Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Exactly. The other providers in the U.S. must still be kicking themselves for being so short-sighted as to the iPhone's demand.

I would think Apple holds all the cards in any upcoming negotiations.



Verizon consistently does as well or better than AT&T without the iphone. Sure they would like to have it, but they are gaining customers without changing their business strategy and not paying ridiculous subsidies.


Apple is in a strong position but they dont hold all the cards. It's not like Apple will suddenly go to a smaller carrier like TMobile and if they were to move to Verizon they would most certainly have to make some concessions.
 
ateslik,
Back it up a little. Try comparing apples to apples rather than run off on an AT&T bash rant. The only data plan that T-Mobile offers is related to Blackberry and that's $40 a month. The iPhone and data go hand in hand whether you like it or not. Sure you can unlock and throw it on T-Mobile but you are not using data unless in a free wifi area. So you "have" to consider a data plan in your calculation. Comparatively, I have family that suffer with T-Mobile service in our area compared to the rest of the family with AT&T service. And when i say service, I'm talking specifically about voice. Couple that with the fact that the data and voice map of AT&T is considerably larger than T-Mobile, there isn't much comparison. Did you know that T-Mobile piggybacks off of AT&T towers? Do you know who gets priority? Also, compare phone prices and selections to AT&T. Can't compare.

Please don't think this is a praise AT&T rant to combat your T-Mobile rant. Verizon actually has THEE best voice service in the country. I've used each in my travels over the years across the entire country. Verizon is EVERYWHERE. Data is a different story and that's the way the world is moving.

I've got a 550 family plan with a 3G ($30 data) and a 1st gen iPhone ($20 data) and I pay about $130 a month (It's those TAXES..geez). Both phones primary focus is on data though and we use very little minutes. We maybe use 100 minutes a month considering most calls are too in-network phones at no cost.

This is surprising to me. My friend gave me his iPhone 3G (he likes his blackberry better). So, I checked into the rates at ATT. What an ***** rip.

Right now I'm on an 8 year old contract with T-Mobile. It is an 850 minute Family plan. My wife and I are the only ones on it. It costs us $69.99 plus taxes, surcharges, etc. and usually comes out to about $90/mo.

ATT only offers a 700 and 1400 minute plan. The 700 plan is $69.99 plus $30.00 for data, $99.99 total. Same price as my current T-Mobile plan for 150 less minutes a month..., and a 42% extra charge for data? Um, huh? Okay... but we really need more than 700 minutes. The 1400 minute plan is $89.99 plus $30.00 for data, $119.99 total. A little less than DOUBLE what we're paying now... just for data on an iPhone? And thats BEFORE the taxes, surcharges, etc. I'm not doing that.

Since we've been with T-Mobile for 8 years, I decided to go check them out. They still offer our current plan for $69.99/mo... but now with 1000 minutes instead of 850.

Sorry ATT. Wake the F up. I can jailbreak this thing and save a bunch of money. Oh no, I'll miss visual voicemail. Up the 700 minute plan to 1000 minutes and mabye we can talk (although 42% extra for data is a RIP).
 
But How Many...

How many were Firmware upgrades, phone replacements, 1st-gen to 2nd-gen upgrades etc? (Existing customers rather than new customers) Remember, your phone needs to be activated every time each one of those happens.
Hell, my phone reactivated after my last sync with iTunes (just a sync, not a firmware update).
 
Exactly. The other providers in the U.S. must still be kicking themselves for being so short-sighted as to the iPhone's demand.

Well yes and no. Much of the world is on the GSM standard IIRC. So it was in Apple's interest to focus in on that, as opposed to Verizon and Sprint being on the CDMA network.

I would think Apple holds all the cards in any upcoming negotiations.

You may be right; but we as consumers will pay the price of those negotiations in the end. Hopefully Apple will look at the potential of the Verizon network. 85M subscribers for Verizon verses 77m for ATT.

I know many Verizon people that want to switch to the iPhone; but for many reasons will not switch from Verizon. The trouble for Apple is how to simplify the iPhone product line, hence their working only on GSM so far.

We can only hope/dream that the next iPhone will be dual band at least.

Agreed. I'd be really surprised if they let it go, but this could mean better features to AT&T users if Apple negotiates to force their network to be faster, or offer additional features.

"We'll stick with you if you do x, y, and z." Not that simple, obviously, but Apple could be in a leveraged position to help the consumers.

I see your point; but better/more features is not what we need in this current economy. More choices in cost of services is the key right now; and competition is key to that.

Perhaps, but Verizon (and Sprint) had the added hurdle of getting apple to make a CDMA version.

Think the decision to go GSM on Apple's part was to meet demand for worldwide use first. Again, hopefully the 3rd generation of the iPhone will be at least a dual band phone. Will give any provider the ability to add network roaming between the two networks at additional cost.

This is surprising to me. My friend gave me his iPhone 3G (he likes his blackberry better). So, I checked into the rates at ATT. What an ***** rip.

Right now I'm on an 8 year old contract with T-Mobile. It is an 850 minute Family plan. My wife and I are the only ones on it. It costs us $69.99 plus taxes, surcharges, etc. and usually comes out to about $90/mo.

ATT only offers a 700 and 1400 minute plan. The 700 plan is $69.99 plus $30.00 for data, $99.99 total. Same price as my current T-Mobile plan for 150 less minutes a month..., and a 42% extra charge for data? Um, huh? Okay... but we really need more than 700 minutes. The 1400 minute plan is $89.99 plus $30.00 for data, $119.99 total. A little less than DOUBLE what we're paying now... just for data on an iPhone? And thats BEFORE the taxes, surcharges, etc. I'm not doing that.

Since we've been with T-Mobile for 8 years, I decided to go check them out. They still offer our current plan for $69.99/mo... but now with 1000 minutes instead of 850.

Sorry ATT. Wake the F up. I can jailbreak this thing and save a bunch of money. Oh no, I'll miss visual voicemail. Up the 700 minute plan to 1000 minutes and mabye we can talk (although 42% extra for data is a RIP).

Not sure where you live, but for me the 3G offers voice plans starting at $40 for 450 minutes. Your milage may vary; but I have a nice bank of rollover minutes; for those times I am not talking to someone on the same network.

My issue is the extra charges for text messages. Before the iPhone I was never much in to them. Add to that my circle of friends are more in to sending text messages then to leave a voice mail :(

Could most of the other 60% be existing iPhone 3g owners who automatically activated during a ‘restore’ operation in iTunes after the phone broke or when installing the 3 different betas in the first quarter. It says iPhone activated each time...

Noooo... AT&T wouldn't do that to investors. After all they treat their customers like gold, right?!

Good point; but I think profit reports tell the truth. We can only hope that "activations" are for totally new iPhones - which I think is the case.

Verizon consistently does as well or better than AT&T without the iphone. Sure they would like to have it, but they are gaining customers without changing their business strategy and not paying ridiculous subsidies.

Apple is in a strong position but they dont hold all the cards. It's not like Apple will suddenly go to a smaller carrier like TMobile and if they were to move to Verizon they would most certainly have to make some concessions.

Good points there... in the end it is about who will blink first - Apple or Verizon. If even 2 to 5% of current subscribers to Verizon switch to the iPhone gains another 1.7 to 4.5M iPhones sold. Never mind those of us that might switch. Apple only has to look at the units sold; carriers have to look at the profit bringing a phone in.

The big issue between Apple and Verizon is who will control the user interface.
 
How many were Firmware upgrades, phone replacements, 1st-gen to 2nd-gen upgrades etc? (Existing customers rather than new customers) Remember, your phone needs to be activated every time each one of those happens.
Hell, my phone reactivated after my last sync with iTunes (just a sync, not a firmware update).

Thats not an activation, that is unbricking the phone. An iPhone activation (iPhone AT&T activation )occurs when either a subscriber (customer)upgrades their phone to a 1st generation iPhone or upgrade to iPhone 3G.
 
This is surprising to me. My friend gave me his iPhone 3G (he likes his blackberry better). So, I checked into the rates at ATT. What an ***** rip.

Right now I'm on an 8 year old contract with T-Mobile. It is an 850 minute Family plan. My wife and I are the only ones on it. It costs us $69.99 plus taxes, surcharges, etc. and usually comes out to about $90/mo.

ATT only offers a 700 and 1400 minute plan. The 700 plan is $69.99 plus $30.00 for data, $99.99 total. Same price as my current T-Mobile plan for 150 less minutes a month..., and a 42% extra charge for data? Um, huh? Okay... but we really need more than 700 minutes. The 1400 minute plan is $89.99 plus $30.00 for data, $119.99 total. A little less than DOUBLE what we're paying now... just for data on an iPhone? And thats BEFORE the taxes, surcharges, etc. I'm not doing that.

Since we've been with T-Mobile for 8 years, I decided to go check them out. They still offer our current plan for $69.99/mo... but now with 1000 minutes instead of 850.

Sorry ATT. Wake the F up. I can jailbreak this thing and save a bunch of money. Oh no, I'll miss visual voicemail. Up the 700 minute plan to 1000 minutes and mabye we can talk (although 42% extra for data is a RIP).

Ditto, I'm with T-mobile 1000 anytime min, 400 txt msg, unlimited 3g data. Total cost before taxes $65.00... That would cost over 100 dollars at ATT.. I don't understand why people want to pay ATT's fees...
 
I think this is the time Apple turns the table around. So far, AT&T pretty much dictates what the iPhone firmware apps can do or not. Oh, and Apple, could you simply sell the iPhone unlocked, just like how you do in other countries already?
 
This is surprising to me. My friend gave me his iPhone 3G (he likes his blackberry better). So, I checked into the rates at ATT. What an ***** rip.

Right now I'm on an 8 year old contract with T-Mobile. It is an 850 minute Family plan. My wife and I are the only ones on it. It costs us $69.99 plus taxes, surcharges, etc. and usually comes out to about $90/mo.

ATT only offers a 700 and 1400 minute plan. The 700 plan is $69.99 plus $30.00 for data, $99.99 total. Same price as my current T-Mobile plan for 150 less minutes a month..., and a 42% extra charge for data? Um, huh? Okay... but we really need more than 700 minutes. The 1400 minute plan is $89.99 plus $30.00 for data, $119.99 total. A little less than DOUBLE what we're paying now... just for data on an iPhone? And thats BEFORE the taxes, surcharges, etc. I'm not doing that.

Since we've been with T-Mobile for 8 years, I decided to go check them out. They still offer our current plan for $69.99/mo... but now with 1000 minutes instead of 850.

Sorry ATT. Wake the F up. I can jailbreak this thing and save a bunch of money. Oh no, I'll miss visual voicemail. Up the 700 minute plan to 1000 minutes and mabye we can talk (although 42% extra for data is a RIP).

Sounds like you are the one getting ripped off :( 90 bucks a month without any 3G so for $10 more a month you could have an iPhone with internet anywhere and you think that is a rip off?? HAHAAHAHA

While I do agree that AT&T is ripping people off :mad: (but you are already getting ripped off).

:cool: I get 1500 "anytime", UNLIMITED "nights and weekends" starting at 7:00 pm, UNLIMITED "call me", and UNLIMITED "in-network" calling for $50 mo., about $60 after taxes and such. :D unlimited text is only $5 more

p.s. if you have been on the same plan for 8 years you should probably ask for a discount :rolleyes:
 
Ditto, I'm with T-mobile 1000 anytime min, 400 txt msg, unlimited 3g data. Total cost before taxes $65.00... That would cost over 100 dollars at ATT.. I don't understand why people want to pay ATT's fees...

Some of you guys are gettting such a great deal on your plans because they are older. AT&T at one time had cheaper rates as well as other carriers but they've gone up now, same with Verizon. Verizon plans and AT&T plans are almost identical.
 
If that isn't motivation for Verizon to roll out LTE sooner than they had expected, I don't know what is. Apple won't make a CDMA version of the iPhone, but they could make a universal LTE phone that would work on AT&T and Verizon. I have Verizon and would like the iPhone, but I absolutely hate AT&T's service where I live. So many dropped calls, unclear voice, etc. Bad network here, so I won't switch from Verizon (unless it drastically improves). Verizon is slated to roll out LTE in 2010, AT&T in 2011.. What sucks is my contract with Verizon is out in August.. I can go without a contract, but I want a new phone.. If I resign I'll be stuck until 2011, or I can wait and see what happens.. But, I'm hoping that AT&T's trend makes verizon wake up and say "we need to roll this out sooner than we planned, if we want to get an upper hand"
 
Some of you guys are gettting such a great deal on your plans because they are older. AT&T at one time had cheaper rates as well as other carriers but they've gone up now, same with Verizon. Verizon plans and AT&T plans are almost identical.

That is true...But they do have good or better current plans:

Incorrect link...
 
How to correctly do comparisons!

Sorry ATT. Wake the F up. I can jailbreak this thing and save a bunch of money. Oh no, I'll miss visual voicemail. Up the 700 minute plan to 1000 minutes and mabye we can talk (although 42% extra for data is a RIP).[/QUOTE] :rolleyes:

I'm sure that the usage of the Iphone 3G on your network would be lots of fun due to the lack of 3G coverage. :p
You see, you have actually to compare the benefits before you talk about prices. There is a reason why T-Mobile data plans are so cheap!
Maybe T-Mobile should "wake the F up" too seen that you pay each month for 1000 minutes and at the end they keep whatever you didn't use! :)

Talking about greediness, check out the T-mobile plans in Germany for the iPhone. More expensive, less minutes (although incoming calls are free) and a data cap after a certain amount of traffic.
And they own the exclusive rights for the iPhone, G1 AND the coming Pre. :eek:
They could run their network for free here in the States and still make enough money! :confused:
 
If that isn't motivation for Verizon to roll out LTE sooner than they had expected, I don't know what is. Apple won't make a CDMA version of the iPhone, but they could make a universal LTE phone that would work on AT&T and Verizon. I have Verizon and would like the iPhone, but I absolutely hate AT&T's service where I live. So many dropped calls, unclear voice, etc. Bad network here, so I won't switch from Verizon (unless it drastically improves). Verizon is slated to roll out LTE in 2010, AT&T in 2011.. What sucks is my contract with Verizon is out in August.. I can go without a contract, but I want a new phone.. If I resign I'll be stuck until 2011, or I can wait and see what happens.. But, I'm hoping that AT&T's trend makes verizon wake up and say "we need to roll this out sooner than we planned, if we want to get an upper hand"

Sounds like LTE may be the future for Apple as the hardware provider....
 
With all of this new revenue from the iPhone, especially with a contract that runs out, one would think that ATT would spend money on getting it's existing system in better shape. I fear that talks of a sexy new 4G or whatever will lead to service even spotier than it is now.

Amen. I have little need for a theoretical gigabit speeds when I go outside a 3G area. Blanket more areas in 3G before worrying about 4G.
 
Sorry ATT. Wake the F up. I can jailbreak this thing and save a bunch of money. Oh no, I'll miss visual voicemail. Up the 700 minute plan to 1000 minutes and mabye we can talk (although 42% extra for data is a RIP).
:rolleyes:

I'm sure that the usage of the Iphone 3G on your network would be lots of fun due to the lack of 3G coverage. :p
You see, you have actually to compare the benefits before you talk about prices. There is a reason why T-Mobile data plans are so cheap!
Maybe T-Mobile should "wake the F up" too seen that you pay each month for 1000 minutes and at the end they keep whatever you didn't use! :)

Talking about greediness, check out the T-mobile plans in Germany for the iPhone. More expensive, less minutes (although incoming calls are free) and a data cap after a certain amount of traffic.
And they own the exclusive rights for the iPhone, G1 AND the coming Pre. :eek:
They could run their network for free here in the States and still make enough money! :confused:[/QUOTE]

Maybe we need to look at how we use our phones to decide what plan is best.

As of now I have over 2400 rollover minutes; never come close my Nights/Weekend minutes. And as I find more friends that are ATT - the mobile to mobile calls don;t count.

I have always loved the European concept of incoming calls being free. Would save me from calls I get that I don;t want....
 
Perhaps, but Verizon (and Sprint) had the added hurdle of getting apple to make a CDMA version.

When has Apple ever made anything in "versions". The CDMA technology would have caused Apple to create a different manufacturing process for GSM for international sales. I know they may have approached Verizon first, but this arrangement is more cost effective.
 
When has Apple ever made anything in "versions". The CDMA technology would have caused Apple to create a different manufacturing process for GSM for international sales. I know they may have approached Verizon first, but this arrangement is more cost effective.

Much like I was saying.... :)
 
http://poweredbysteam.com/2009/01/iphone-sales-by-quarter/

First quarter Iphone sales where 4.6 million so how can only 1.6 million have been activated?

Is the site I checked incorrect?

I hope not. According to powestream 11.5 million Iphones in 2008, with Q1 sales being almost double that of 2008. If that is the case than I could definetely see them selling at least 15 million Iphones in 09, bad economy be damned.


Dude Thats Sold This Is Is Activated By At&t You Know Canada Doesnt Have AT&T And Other Countries So Thats Just States Activated
 
When has Apple ever made anything in "versions". The CDMA technology would have caused Apple to create a different manufacturing process for GSM for international sales.

I take it you mean they don't do multiple versions at the same time?

They've already made two versions, the second one adding WCDMA to get 3G, requiring updated factory training.

A third and perhaps fourth version can't be far behind. They could certainly make two versions at the same time if they wished.
 
ATT lost 400,000 iPhone accounts...WOW!!! :eek:

1.6M phones activated yet only had a net gain of 1.2M accounts.

Surprised no one else caught that.
 
ATT lost 400,000 iPhone accounts...WOW!!! :eek:

1.6M phones activated yet only had a net gain of 1.2M accounts.

Surprised no one else caught that.

They're separate items. From memory (corrections welcome):

Overall, they added 1.2M accounts. Probably mostly ex-Sprint users. That's users of ALL phones they sell.

They activated 1.6M iPhones, of which 40% (640K) were new customers. The other 1M were already ATT customers.
 
I really do not think that AT&Ts rates are that bad, at least not the way we have it worked out.

Family plan with 1,100 minutes $60/month.
Add 3 lines at $9/month each.
Add 2 3G Data plans $30/month each.
Add unlimited texting for family $30/month.

Grand total + tax last month was $183.xx last month.

Seeing as we have free nights and weekends and free talk to each other + 2,000 roll over minutes from before we added the 4th line, seems pretty reasonable for 4 phones - two of which are iPhones with 3G.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.