Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I have a 20 gb plan, 4 lines shared, so for me, if I'm understanding this correctly:

Old 20 gb plan, 4 lines shared: $140/month + 4 x $15 = $200/month
New 25gb plan, 4 lines shared: $110/month +4 x $20 = $190/month

If I understand this correctly, I'll get 5 extra gbs, wont have to worry about overage fees, and I'll be saving $10/month.

I think that's right. If you don't come that close to using all 20GB right now, you can save an additional $20.
 
On a promo family plan right now 20GB/$100 month + 4 devices ($15/each line access) = $160. We're not using nearly that, but when you take into account the higher line access charges, we'd have to go with the 10GB plan to be close in price. Also, note that most corporate discounts through AT&T only apply to the data portion and not the line access, so that's another way that this is less of a deal.

That being said, if you are an individual, the smaller plans give you a bit more data for often $5 more, and the calling to Mexico and Canada and usage in Mexico:

New: 3GB = $60 ($40+$20)
Old: 2GB = $55 ($30+$25)

New: 6GB = $80 ($60+$20)
Old: 5GB = $75 ($50+$25)
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: NetMage and soheilk
I can't wait until the DTV Unlimited plans include the ability to use hotspot.
If you're using one of the plans listed here, many of the prices are indeed better and can't complain too much about the loss of overage fees.

Keep dreaming bud. I'm on the old old $30 unlimited data plan and I STILL don't have the ability to hotspot.
 
  • Like
Reactions: vthree
This actually ends up being more expensive in many common scenarios, because the device access fee is now higher. This easily wipes away any savings.

For example:

Old 15GB plan, 4 lines shared: $100 + 4 x $15 = $160/month
New 16GB plan, 4 lines shared: $90 + 4 x $20 = $170/month
Dropping cost of data, but raising line access fees, sneaky weasels.


I think it's time for me to switch to Verizon. Tired of ATT just following. At least for these same prices you get Verizon's network. I for sure thought ATT would beat not match them. Wow.

Old 30GB (double 15GB plan) 8 lines $250
New 30GB 8 lines $295

No thanks!
 
The issue is that overage fees are sneaky: you use 1 byte above your limit, you pay the full fee. And of course AT&T doesn't give you an alert: "you have reached your limit, do you want to pay extra?" With AT & T I often experienced going just a little over the limit, and then paying double for my data. One reason I changed to T-Mobile.

The best way would be that once you reach the limit, you pay per extra byte. But that would be too honest.
Yeah, you would think they should give you a warning when you approach the plans limit so you can either make adjustments to your usage or decide to buy more data.
 
I think the US is in desperate need of some healthy competition in the wireless service provider market.. :)
The US actually has more than a few wireless options that are cheaper than the "Big Four" carriers (i.e. regional carriers and MVNOs), but since MacRumors doesn't post about them often, seem like most non-Americans are unaware of them.

Frankly, I'm curious to see how cheap the European plans of today will remain once the EU forces European carriers to allow free roaming all over Europe.... Roaming all over the US for free is something something the Big Four have offered for over a decade, even to US areas outside of the continental US (like Hawaii, Alaska, Puerto Rico, etc).

Unless American companies are the only companies in the world that operate on a "for profit" concept, I'm thinking the costs incurred by the European carriers for that will eventually be passed along to their customers.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MeFromHere
This actually ends up being more expensive in many common scenarios, because the device access fee is now higher. This easily wipes away any savings.

For example:

Old 15GB plan, 4 lines shared: $100 + 4 x $15 = $160/month
New 16GB plan, 4 lines shared: $90 + 4 x $20 = $170/month
Dropping cost of data, but raising line access fees, sneaky weasels.

wow you are sure right about that. SNEAKY AT&T.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NetMage and soheilk
I'm on promo pricing, so this would cost me more than my current plan.

15GB for $130, promo-doubled to 30GB a month. 24% work discount. So around $100 before taxes/fees.

10 lines, at $15 each + $4.xx taxes/fees, so nearly $20 each, or $200 for all phones.

Current Total: $300 / month for 30GB

New plan:

30GB for $135/month - 24% discount is close to $100 a month before taxes/fees.

10 lines, now at $20, which will probably be around $25 after taxes/fees, so $250 for all phones.

New total: $350 / month for 30GB plus 128 Kbps unlimited...

Let's say I go for the 25GB plan.

25GB for $110/month - 24% discount is close to $85 a month before taxes/fees.

So the total for that would be $335 / month for 25GB plus 128 Kbps unlimited...

Obviously this plan is not for me.

You and me have the same scenario, except I have 8 not 10 lines... same situation here. Just goes to show ATT has lost touch with reality. I've been holding off on migrating to Verizon to see what ATT matched them with, now there's no reason not to switch. With Verizon they're doing the double data promo so you can get the same thing of about 32gb for about $240 a month, and you get the verizon network, which is vastly superior to ATT. LOL
 
  • Like
Reactions: NetMage and soheilk
This actually ends up being more expensive in many common scenarios, because the device access fee is now higher. This easily wipes away any savings.

For example:

Old 15GB plan, 4 lines shared: $100 + 4 x $15 = $160/month
New 16GB plan, 4 lines shared: $90 + 4 x $20 = $170/month
Dropping cost of data, but raising line access fees, sneaky weasels.
Previously for $160/month you could get 15GB, now for $160/month you can get 10GB, what a deal for a family of 4!
 
Well, if they're going to charge my family $170 instead of $160 ($90 + 4 lines), but no overage fees, big mistake by AT&T thinking they could sneak that $10 extra in. We will make that up in one day lol, even if it's at 128kbps.
 
Reduced speed, same as Verizon. I had to turn on Verizon's "safety mode" last month, supposedly slows down to 128kbps. I suffered through a couple days and, it wasn't that bad. I didn't use apps that are image-heavy (e.g. Instagram), but it saved me some cash and I survived.
 
This actually ends up being more expensive in many common scenarios, because the device access fee is now higher. This easily wipes away any savings.

For example:

Old 15GB plan, 4 lines shared: $100 + 4 x $15 = $160/month
New 16GB plan, 4 lines shared: $90 + 4 x $20 = $170/month
Dropping cost of data, but raising line access fees, sneaky weasels.

The funny thing is that they didn't really drop data costs, except for the plans above 15 GB.

AWE4nL2.png
 
wow you are sure right about that. SNEAKY AT&T.
Although the line access fees are lowered by $5 if you are on plans less than 15GB. I will likely be switching my 5GB mobile share plan out for the 3GB option. If I'm doing the math correctly I'll save $20/mo. on my two lines.
 
The Big Two are finally turning a corner. First Verizon introduced their New Plan with rollover data and no overages for higher tier plan holders, now AT&T with this. Hail Tmobile.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KPandian1
Am I the only one that thinks 1GB for $30 is ridiculous?

It's ridiculous to charge 850 bucks for an iPhone (the full price) and then force the minimum access fee to that device to be an addition 30 bucks a month.

It's similar but not quite as bad as Cable charging people $12 just to access the HD channels that they already pay for in their package.
 
I know i cant compare the US with Denmark, because of the size, but in Denmark we pay $15 for 30Gb...
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.