Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I feel like I use my iPhone a lot. Since 2008, I have only used about 5gigs of cell data TOTAL in the close to 4 years of having an iPhone.

I have unlimited and can't see how people use even 2 gigs a month
 
At&T can go straight to hell!
They are double dipping. I pay to download items from iTunes and maybe a bunch of stuff will exceed a download cap. But so what.Why the hell should I spend an additional amount to satisfy them folks at att? This is a travesty.
I'm calling the head of the FCC. This ain't right.
 
I don't know how anyone can go over 2gigs a month unless they are internet addicts or pirating. And you idiots complaining about how Asia has this and that well move there if you don't like it here.
 
I don't know how anyone can go over 2gigs a month unless they are internet addicts or pirating. And you idiots complaining about how Asia has this and that well move there if you don't like it here.
I don't know how anyone can still defend wireless carriers like AT&T. The corporate fanboyism here is truly mind boggling. I guess wanting our nation to have better wireless service is considered idiotic by people like you.
 
Not True about throttling in October

In October, I bought my new iPhone 4S (Upgraded from my iPhone 4). I used 20gig in data in October, in November, I used 15 gig and in December, I used 14 gig. In January when I hit the 2 gig I was dropped from 4-5 mbps down to 150 kbps.

I can no longer watch Netflix, whom I called and said they either make Netflix stream at 150 kbps or I am cancelling my account with them. I am not going to pay $8 a month to stream 2 movies.

Then we have Apple.... they came out with Siri and iMessaging. If you cancell your Text Messaging Plan (unlimited, family unlimited) and use iMessaging, AT&T loses income. Many of my friends did just that.
 
To all my AT&T friends still left,

Please remember, the only way to fight these repulsive charges is with your wallet, and anything else is futile. AT&T, along with the other top 3 companies, have clearly shown that they couldn't care less about you.
That works if there are true competition on the market. Problem is, there isn't. Everybody is offering similar services with same pricing. Nobody is trying to outdo the others. Even worse, each carrier uses 3G bands that are incompatible with each other. Until provider locking is banned (eg. I can buy AT&T iPhone 4S and use it on Verizon/Sprint, and vice versa), this is just going to get worse. My only hope now is for either Apple to release a penta-band iPhone 5 with AWS support, and/or T-Mobile to activate their 1900 band.
 
If you cancell your Text Messaging Plan (unlimited, family unlimited) and use iMessaging, AT&T loses income. Many of my friends did just that.

I wonder if they care... I called to cancel a line that no one is using that was costing me 9.95 a month. ATT told me that if I keep the line, they would give me free unlimited texting. Bizarre... but I took it.
 
Last edited:
In October, I bought my new iPhone 4S (Upgraded from my iPhone 4). I used 20gig in data in October, in November, I used 15 gig and in December, I used 14 gig. In January when I hit the 2 gig I was dropped from 4-5 mbps down to 150 kbps.

I can no longer watch Netflix, whom I called and said they either make Netflix stream at 150 kbps or I am cancelling my account with them. I am not going to pay $8 a month to stream 2 movies.

Then we have Apple.... they came out with Siri and iMessaging. If you cancell your Text Messaging Plan (unlimited, family unlimited) and use iMessaging, AT&T loses income. Many of my friends did just that.

Not to mention iTunes Match, which "works" over the 3G, and is meant to download your music as needed.
 
A new interpretation of unlimited: 2 Gb.

Another example that you can't trust cell phone providers. Just like banks, they change their rules on a whim and whatever serves them best.

And to hell with the customer.

(I don't have an unlimited data plan. I'm, fortunately, not even a customer of AT&T - I was, when they called themselves "Cingular". Which was just as bad an experience as people have with them today. But it's ugly to see how easy corporations break their rules and contracts).
 
I don't know how anyone can go over 2gigs a month unless they are internet addicts or pirating. And you idiots complaining about how Asia has this and that well move there if you don't like it here.

Pirating?? Wtf?

You are a lost soul.
 
Good luck suing them.

Between the arbitration clause and the ruling they got last year from the Supreme Court, we're completely screwed: forget about suing them: you CAN'T, it's part of the contract you signed. State consumer protection laws can't even apply, not even when there is definitive intent to deceive like here.

Yes, you can vote with your money and get another carrier, but they're all the same scam artists. I find it very interesting that all these price increases come in the wake of their failed attempt at takeover of T-Mobile: this is the price of their business arrogance, outrageous salaries for CEO and top brass, cost of lobbying and buying out politicians.

At the same time, this is what happened in France: they were stuck for years with the same 3 legacy carriers (Orange, SFR and Bouygues) plus a handful of MVNOs who offered pretty much all the same contracts at high prices (similar to ours).
Enter Free.fr, who had already revolutionized the ISP market in France a decade ago (unlimited broadband + unlimited international calling to 100 countries + 180 TV channels, including HD, for €30). They only offer two plans, both without commitment: 60 minutes + 60 SMS for €2/month (overage minutes and SMS are extremely reasonably priced, too, not the outrageous $0.40/minute we're being charged here), or unlimited calling (to 40 countries), unlimited texting, and unlimited data with throttling after 3GB... for €20/month. The throttling is not systematic and depends on the current load and system conditions; at worst it's still much better than Edge.

Bottom line, we're being fleeced by the operators, who are charging us this much money simply because they can get away with it. With their insane profits, they pay ridiculous salaries and bonuses to their executives, finance lobbyists and payoff politicians to lock out competition, and they have it all stitched up.

But as long as you're going to have morons like I see here, who keep defending A&T and their exorbitant prices, we're not going to get very far.
 
I have an iPhone 4S and iPad (1st Gen) both with unlimited data plans. Until seeing these threads I hadn't really thought about my usage. Unlimited is unlimited, right? Apparently not. Deciding to see how much usage I have been using, I checked went online and checked. Looks like I'm not a super user at least not on the iPhone. I am often on WiFi.

As of yet, I'm not quite sure how to check the iPad's usage but I've never received a message saying that I'm over or will be throttled.
 

Attachments

  • Capture.PNG
    Capture.PNG
    17.7 KB · Views: 70
I've got the perfect solution. Tell everyone you know on AT&T to use as much data as they can. Stream movies, stream music, whatever. Organize a flash mob around it.

Let's boost the average to about 8 GB. Then that top 5% will be way up there.
 
I don't know how anyone can go over 2gigs a month unless they are internet addicts or pirating. And you idiots complaining about how Asia has this and that well move there if you don't like it here.

Streaming 128K/s audio (the bandwidth required by SiriusXM) uses up 46MB per hour, so a little more than 40 hours of audio streaming will reach the 2GB streaming. That's 2 hours of internet radio per working day, in other words, pretty much what a commuter would use. That's hardly a mad bit torrenter tethering his phone and gobbling up bandwidth like crazy to pirate movies.

No, what's happening is that AT&T is dividing to conquer, by redirecting the ire of their customers who are getting lousy service towards legitimate paying users making legitimate use of a service they actually pay for (quite dearly) instead of accepting the blame and improving the service.

Maybe you should try THINKING next time.

----------

I've never received a message saying that I'm over or will be throttled.
You will. Here in San Jose I started getting their warning message at 1.5GB.

I'm furious, and this is what I'm doing about it:

1) filing a complaint with the California Public Utilities Commission

2) Filing a complaint with the FCC

3) Contacting my senators and representatives and filing an official complaint with them.

And finally, I will be ditching AT&T as soon as my contract is out. I will not give the bastards the joy of fleecing me of even more money with an early termination fee. Sadly, the competition is really not much better.

----------

Tell everyone you know on AT&T to use as much data as they can.

Good luck doing that at below-EDGE speeds, but I like your thinking.
 
Wirelessly posted (Mozilla/5.0 (iPhone; CPU iPhone OS 5_0 like Mac OS X) AppleWebKit/534.46 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/5.1 Mobile/9A334 Safari/7534.48.3)

Why is cozen upset ? He is free to switch to a pay for what you use plan. People who think AT&T owe people unlimited bandwidth forever are being absurd. They have been amazingly generous so far. Switch to a regular plan and stop crying.
 
Streaming 128K/s audio (the bandwidth required by SiriusXM) uses up 46MB per hour, so a little more than 40 hours of audio streaming will reach the 2GB streaming. That's 2 hours of internet radio per working day, in other words, pretty much what a commuter would use. That's hardly a mad bit torrenter tethering his phone and gobbling up bandwidth like crazy to pirate movies.

No, what's happening is that AT&T is dividing to conquer, by redirecting the ire of their customers who are getting lousy service towards legitimate paying users making legitimate use of a service they actually pay for (quite dearly) instead of accepting the blame and improving the service.

Maybe you should try THINKING next time.


Throw video in there and that 2GB would be lucky to last a week.

Every single cell phone company is just completely ripping off customers. Internet is getting more and more necessary every passing year and these companies realize it so they've decided to milk the cow by trying to get rid of these unlimited plans.

I don't have any data access plans because I'm not willing to pay THAT much for a pathetic 2GB of transfer and have to worry about seeing a $400 charge for going over. When I decide that I need data on my phone I'm definitely taking my business to Sprint..it may be slower but at least I don't have to worry about overages.

Fortunately I usually have Wifi or a computer where I am at to use if I need to use the internet but I would be raging if I was with AT&T and they did this bait and switch crap and I required the internet for work.

It's a joke, anyone believing that people are plugging the servers and this would make the service better is very naive, they make well beyond what is needed for the network to function well. It's funny how UK doesn't have any of these supposed network congestion issues and they pay almost 60% less for unlimited everything.

Its just another way for the CEOs and management to stuff their pockets with overcharges.
 
Wirelessly posted (Mozilla/5.0 (iPhone; CPU iPhone OS 5_0 like Mac OS X) AppleWebKit/534.46 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/5.1 Mobile/9A334 Safari/7534.48.3)

Why is cozen upset ? He is free to switch to a pay for what you use plan. People who think AT&T owe people unlimited bandwidth forever are being absurd. They have been amazingly generous so far. Switch to a regular plan and stop crying.

There are 14 pages that explain to you why there are plenty of reasons to be upset, but if you're too stupid or lazy to read or understand them, let me summarize it for you: they are unilaterally changing the terms of a contract. Unlimited means unlimited. They're using bullying tactics to force users out of contracts they're grandfathered in, into more lucrative ones.
Instead of siding with AT&T like a dimwit, you should start wondering why they're charging so much when carriers in other countries where there is real competition charge much less.
 
welcome to the rest of the world :)

sorry, folks, but this day has been coming for a very long time. to be perfectly honest I'm surprised AT&T let it go for this long.
 
I still have the "unlimited plan" and haven't been throttled yet. I've only gone over 2GB once that I can remember and I am almost always on WiFi. However, this news is quite disenchanting because I have discovered that I can play streaming music from Pandora or CalmRadio or even Netflix from my iPhone to my Alpine car stereo as I drive along. Those apps will override the iPod and play it's sound through my car stereo; really cool!

So now if I want to stream some Internet radio as I drive, I'm going to eat up data and since I live in a mostly rural area, I can see this activity of mine causing me to easily be among the top 5% users, "abusers" in my area when I hit that 2GB mark.

Just as someone else said already, it's not the amount of data that someone uses that causes network problems, its the amount of people using the network at any given time that causes the problem.

These companies have it all wrong and are trying to leverage this perceived "problem" to their advantage and gain more money for doing next to nothing, save upsetting their customers.

ATTUSAGE.png
 
Last edited:
Total Hogwash!

THERE IS NO WAY ON GOD'S GREEN EARTH THAT 2.1 GB OF USAGE IS IN THE TOP 5% IN LOS ANGELES,CA. THE DIGITAL ENTERTAINMENT CAPITAL OF THE WORLD!

AT&T your BS and attempt to make us switch to your tied plan is only going to land you in court! Cant wait for the first class action around this one or lawsuit making them prove there BS

Way to go, your service sucked when the Iphone was new...now thats its almost stable... bite the hand that fed you and stayed loyal!

A prime example of all that is wrong with American Business and the people that run it!
 
Unlimited data means UNLIMITED DATA..... Doesn't mean it has to be fast. Stop trying to twist the meaning of it and read it for what it actual says.

Luckily the court is not so stupid to believe this kind of arguments.
 
"one more thing" ;)

You will. Here in San Jose I started getting their warning message at 1.5GB.

I'm furious, and this is what I'm doing about it:

1) filing a complaint with the California Public Utilities Commission

2) Filing a complaint with the FCC

3) Contacting my senators and representatives and filing an official complaint with them.

4) Send an email to Tim Cook describing your problems with Apple's official partners.

Apple will probably be able to do more, faster, to fix this than any regulatory agency. If Apple believes that AT&T's policies will kill that goose called "Iphone" that's laying the golden egges - Apple may be able to get it fixed.
 
In October, I bought my new iPhone 4S (Upgraded from my iPhone 4). I used 20gig in data in October, in November, I used 15 gig and in December, I used 14 gig. In January when I hit the 2 gig I was dropped from 4-5 mbps down to 150 kbps.

I can no longer watch Netflix, whom I called and said they either make Netflix stream at 150 kbps or I am cancelling my account with them. I am not going to pay $8 a month to stream 2 movies.

Then we have Apple.... they came out with Siri and iMessaging. If you cancell your Text Messaging Plan (unlimited, family unlimited) and use iMessaging, AT&T loses income. Many of my friends did just that.

Your problem is you're refusing to use wifi.
 
I don't think I have ever hit a gig - let alone go over 500mb. I have had unlimited since my 3G.

Here's the problem I see - Unlimited - means UNLIMITED. Unlimited doesn't mean, up to a certain point. If it's NOT unlimited, they need to rename it. Pretty simple really. If AT&T can't handle the bandwith of the smartphones they are selling like crazy, they need to stop selling them or start upgrading infrastructure. Capping people is only delaying the inevitable. The future is here and now and rapidly changing and growing. Data is being consumed more and more and it's not going to stop.

**** or get off the damn pot. Stop ****ing around already. I personally think AT&T's customers need to file a lawsuit about all this crap. I normally don't support stuff like that but I would in this case. If you keep letting them walk all over you, where does it end?

I pay $215 a month - $60 of that is for 2 unlimited plans for iPhones. Eat a dick AT&T. If I want to use 10 gig, I damn well will. I'm paying for it.

Class Action Lawsuit!
 
In October, I bought my new iPhone 4S (Upgraded from my iPhone 4). I used 20gig in data in October, in November, I used 15 gig and in December, I used 14 gig. In January when I hit the 2 gig I was dropped from 4-5 mbps down to 150 kbps.

I can no longer watch Netflix, whom I called and said they either make Netflix stream at 150 kbps or I am cancelling my account with them. I am not going to pay $8 a month to stream 2 movies.

Then we have Apple.... they came out with Siri and iMessaging. If you cancell your Text Messaging Plan (unlimited, family unlimited) and use iMessaging, AT&T loses income. Many of my friends did just that.

I can't cancel my text messaging. I only know two people with iPhones and they are not running 5.0.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.