I think this one has merit because AT&T should not have the right to withhold an unlock code from someone who has finished their contract or someone who bought a device that is out of contract. AT&T and Apple have already made their money by then. The phone is that person's, free and clear. Issue the unlock code just like you do for every other phone on the market.
EXACTLY!!!
I purchased a phone at full price and theyre still trying to tie me to AT&T! completely unfair