Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

kabunaru

Guest
Jan 28, 2008
3,226
5
Is the 4800x2 really the best video card for any task right now?

If so, awesome but it sucks that Apple would not get it. Oh well, the 4870 and 4850 should be good enough for most people.
 

Firefly2002

macrumors 65816
Jan 9, 2008
1,220
0
Definitely good news. The 4870 is a lot cheaper than the GeForce cards that are on its performance level, will run Mac OS X Core apps faster, and are about 2x faster than the 3870's gaming performance (and smoke 8800 GTs).

A 4850 will be a great deal, since they're so cheap :)
 

belunos

macrumors member
Aug 10, 2008
72
0
This is perfect. I ordered a refurb 06 mac pro about a week ago, and it should be here tomorrow. I was going to get a 3870 for it, but now I'll wait and see if the 4x will work with that model. Gaming was the only thing I was worried about giving up in my PC->Mac switch, and it's sounding like it won't be an issue at all!
 

JayMan8081

macrumors regular
Feb 20, 2007
115
0
Dayton, OH
It's always good to see new video cards being released for the Mac platform. Hopefully they'll keep releasing newer cards at a more reasonable rate.
 

winterspan

macrumors 65816
Jun 12, 2007
1,008
0
Is the 4800x2 really the best video card for any task right now?
If so, awesome but it sucks that Apple would not get it. Oh well, the 4870 and 4850 should be good enough for most people.

That's too much of a generalization. First of all, the 4870X2 cards are single-PCB, dual GPU boards. They use an internal Crossfire bridge and crossfire driver model, just like if you had two separate 4000-series cards running in parallel. Because of this, the driver has to be optimized for each and every application in order to divide the processing among both on-board GPUs; if you use an application the driver doesn't recognize, you'll tend to see performance almost identical to a standard 1-GPU 4870 card.

Due to the complexities of the one-board Crossfire model, and the fact that the current drivers on OSX don't support two-card parallel crossfire mode,
I don't think it will be easy to get the 4870X2 running with good performance on the Mac, and hence the reason it probably isn't going to be available.

Secondly, speaking more generally, there is a big difference between platforms. On the Mac, the ATI cards have a much better driver for Core Image processing, Whereas nVidia cards have a slight advantage for OpenGL task. On Windows at least, It appears that Nvidia cripples the OpenGL performance of their Geforce (consumer) line versus their more expensive professional Quadro cards which are used for 3D modeling/animation/CAD applications (OpenGL). Also, on windows, Nvidia's Quadro line has dominated the pro 3D range, while new ATI pro cards based on the RV770 should help them catch up.


This is perfect. I ordered a refurb 06 mac pro about a week ago, and it should be here tomorrow. I was going to get a 3870 for it, but now I'll wait and see if the 4x will work with that model. Gaming was the only thing I was worried about giving up in my PC->Mac switch, and it's sounding like it won't be an issue at all!

Yea, definitely wait. The 4870 is much faster (2x or more) than the 3870! It's really an excellent card.


It's always good to see new video cards being released for the Mac platform. Hopefully they'll keep releasing newer cards at a more reasonable rate.

Agreed. I was hoping the Mac Pros were going to get at least the 4850, and I'm more than happy to see the 4870. I hope this trend continues now that the Mac is getting a significant marketshare!
 

OS X Dude

macrumors 65816
Jun 30, 2007
1,132
614
UK
I don't think Apple side with either graphics vendor - they just flitter between the two (first MBP use ATi X1900, current one use nVidia 8600MGT and new Mac Pro will use ATi 4850/4870) depending on who is top at the time.
 

Maxxamillian

macrumors 6502
Nov 16, 2004
359
0
Utah
4870 already in MP '08

Already running a 4870 in my MP for Windows gaming and love it. Have it next to my 2600XT--which is still serving me very well for core image processing.
For those of you thinking multiple 4870s can exist in the same MP you would do well to see what the power requirements are vs. available power connections on the MP motherboard...you'll quickly notice a lack of connectors. Each 4870 requires two additional connections to satisfy power needs. (There are only two on the motherboard.) I guess if you're savvy / brave enough you probably could route some additional power down from the optical drive bays.
At any rate, pleased to see these video cards come aboard :D
 

SuperGrobi

macrumors member
Feb 16, 2008
97
0
So when will ATi actually ship the 4870 cards? I mean, it is great to get the cards for the Mac Pro but I am worried that it will be a candidate for a christmas gift ... if not 2009 :p
 

Heraklitus

macrumors member
May 30, 2008
35
0
El Cerrito, CA
Too bad--ATI's latest cards have been having serious driver and compatibility issues with Windows. I hope they do better with MacOS, but I won't hold my breath.

They should have gone with Nvidia.
 

chrisS

macrumors member
Sep 21, 2007
31
0
Last thing I read for the 4850/70 was Q4 2008. Has anyone heard of anything more specific ?

Also will these run on 1st gen MacPros ?

I currently use a X1900XT to play WoW, and from what I've put together (comparing X1900 to 3870, and then 3870 to 4870 in UT3), it looks like I can expect something around double the frame rate.
 

kaiwai

macrumors 6502a
Oct 21, 2007
709
0
Christchurch
Yes there is. It's the 4850 Mobility. It was demoed over a month ago and is set for a fall release.

The only question regarding MBP placement is whether or not Apple gets first dibs on them, which have done with other parts in the past.

IMHO they should move to them and better still, for those with failing Nvidia graphics, to replace them with boards that have ATI chips on them.
 

m1stake

macrumors 68000
Jan 17, 2008
1,518
3
Philly
It's yet to be seen if the 4870X2's internal-crossfire model is going to be something that is easily and efficiently ported over to the OSX version of their drivers.

I wrote software but I meant hardware. The 4870X2 will run it's on card Crossfire without any board support for dual GPUs. :p

IMHO they should move to them and better still, for those with failing Nvidia graphics, to replace them with boards that have ATI chips on them.

It's nowhere near that simple.
 

diamond.g

macrumors G4
Mar 20, 2007
11,171
2,484
OBX
I wrote software but I meant hardware. The 4870X2 will run it's on card Crossfire without any board support for dual GPUs. :p



It's nowhere near that simple.

The way the 4870X2 is designed, it should only show up as one card. That should further simplify getting the card to work in OS X as the cards firmware handles the splitting behind the scenes.
 

hajime

macrumors 604
Jul 23, 2007
7,832
1,266
Does that mean a slight update in MP will be available very soon?

If so, do you expect the update will be out within two weeks?
 

chewietobbacca

macrumors 6502
Jun 18, 2007
428
0
The 4870 actually delivers more FLOPS than the GTX280 does (heck, the 4850 does as well) so whenever they get OpenCL up and running, the 4870 will be a beast of card.

Truts me, I'm using a 4870x2 (soon to be under water) and that thing is blazing fast, even on 2560x1600. Once the 4870 and 4850's are out on the Mac Pro, it'll be beastly!
 

Og Oggilby

macrumors regular
Aug 27, 2005
101
0
Boston Area
They are probably waiting for the 5870 (or whatever) to come out on the PC side before they release 4870 Mac cards. For some reason the Mac graphic cards are always a generation or two behind :mad:
 

grue

macrumors 65816
Nov 14, 2003
1,233
37
Somewhere.
Insofar as I'm able to tell, this is an unsubstantiated rumour from one site. Maybe it'll ship at the same time as Duke Nukem Forever :rolleyes:
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.