Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
The issue I see is that to make a foldable screen, you either have to forgo the use of a glass screen altogether, or create a plastic covered hinge section where the fold can happen. And regardless of whether it's all plastic or just a plastic covered hinge section, that area of the hinge is going to subject to potential clouding and wear due to the folding and unfolding. I don't think there is any plastic that has been developed that can take that kind of abuse without degradation.
 
Why?

As some others have said, there's little advantage to this, and lots of disadvantages.
 
Foldable iPhone? This doesn't sound like the Apple I know. Of all the manufacturers, Apple would be the last company, if that, who I'd think of developing a foldable phone. Is there even a market for this?

Yes, phones are moving rapidly towards hubs for other devices, CarPlay, Apple Watch, Network Hubs, Siri, etc. I have noticed that my use of the phone screen time declining as the above mentioned devices become more relivent. Then there is the time when one needs the phone to be like a tablet, larger screen features. Would it not be nice to have the Plus size phone 1/2 the size when working as a hub, then open up to full size for screen applications. The phone will get thicker when folded, depending on how Apple can manage the size problem may just be the deciding factor if this is a valid option. Conceptually a foldable device attractive, as was the flip phone. Really liked my old flip phone. Plus built in screen protector!:)
 
Last edited:
A lot of Debbie Downers here on MR......where is your vision? Why the cynicism? More choices for us, the consumer. It could be neat, or it could be not. Who knows? People complain about Apple not being "innovative" and when something like this comes out, everyone scoffs at it like is a pie in the sky....

Or people with engineering experience who see how ridiculous this is:

  1. Making a folded device feel rigid/solid when it's unfolded.
  2. Making a screen that can be folded thousands of times and not have a visible crease/line at the fold.
  3. Making a screen that has the exact same response to touch over the entire screen (no change where it folds).
  4. Making a foldable device that can somehow keep out dust/moisture at the hinge.
  5. Making a flexible screen that has the same characteristics as a laminated display.

The one I see the most problem with is #2. I just don't believe such a device can be made where you won't be able to see where it folds. And I don't think consumers are going to pay flagship prices for a device with an obvious "crease" right smack in the middle of your display and all your content you want to view.
 
Pretty annoying to have to view a notification. I always feel sorry for my friends who have those phone cases with the cover on them, hearing a ping, pulling out the phone, flipping open the cover, seeing its not important, flipping it shut, back in the pocket...

Foldable phone would be the same thing.
Apple Watch :)
 
It’s interesting technology and we know Samsung has been allegedly experimenting with that. But I do not see Apple ever going to a bendable phone. It just doesn’t seem like that would be something they would consider. I expect by 2020 Apple will incorporate Micro LED into their iPhone displays, which will be a huge step forward.
 
I would think Apple would develop this technology for some kind of new product where folding made sense, although it's hard for me to imagine that. Like a display built into something else that extended out or something.

Or, like an iPad where the lower half became a keyboard while the upper half became a display as it folded into a laptop config. (although that sounds terrible to me)
 
  • Like
Reactions: ravenstar
I'd rather see something that folds down the long edge, which can be used like a normal iPhone today while folded and can be unfolded to add twice the screen real estate. Folding on the short edge doesn't really seem to have any advantages other than maybe protecting the screen from things in your pocket...

So if the screen is on the outside... then the screen is always exposed. No more cases. Thus no laying your phone on the table without fear of scratches.

ZTE tried this. Granted they're using two separate screens. But the issues are the same.

5qDXcVw.jpg


However... if there was a normal-sized screen on the outside... and another bigger foldable screen on the inside... that might make some sense.

But the last time I checked... glass doesn't bend.

So the inside screen would have a crappy plasticky covering? That doesn't sound good either.

I forget... what problem are we trying to solve with this? :p
 
oh, samsung hasnt even announced a date for their foldable phone (its not coming in 2018 it seems), and apple already copies them... is that how it works? ;D

Oh but the responses would be sooooo different if it were Samsung, HTC, etc that announced a foldable phone !
samsung has already announced one for quite some time, and they had a foldable phone prototype in 2011.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jamesrick80
Or people with engineering experience who see how ridiculous this is:

  1. Making a folded device feel rigid/solid when it's unfolded.
  2. Making a screen that can be folded thousands of times and not have a visible crease/line at the fold.
  3. Making a screen that has the exact same response to touch over the entire screen (no change where it folds).
  4. Making a foldable device that can somehow keep out dust/moisture at the hinge.
  5. Making a flexible screen that has the same characteristics as a laminated display.

The one I see the most problem with is #2. I just don't believe such a device can be made where you won't be able to see where it folds. And I don't think consumers are going to pay flagship prices for a device with an obvious "crease" right smack in the middle of your display and all your content you want to view.

The water glass perspective, half full or half empty. Apple does a good job of focusing on the glass being half full. ;)
 
If these gimmick phones ARE such a good idea, then please do tell us where all the curved phones are, the trend that LG tried to start? Oh, you don't remember them? Case closed.
 
I can't believe this will happen in the next 10 years, let alone 2. If it does, however, I will have it. An iPhone X sized device that folds out into an iPad Mini-sized tablet? Take my money-I have no regard for cost-make it a limited run, $2,000 iPhone for all I care
 
Please tell me why they'd do it with the iPhone? If anything will be foldable, it will be another product. Why do we want a foldable iPhone?
 
I really don't see this happening anytime soon. The challenges that would have to overcome to allow a high end display to stretch and contract (which it would have to do to bend) ... I just don't see it.
 
What benefit is there to folding a phone? That makes it thicker, and adds a step to checking your screen.

From an engineering perspective, making something foldable means making it ugly in a phone form-factor.
 
Not sure if I am even interested in a folding phone. Samsung will probably beat Apple to it. They have been rumored to come out with one for a few years now. Apple will wait and see what the Samsung pros and cons are and then improve it.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.