Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

beats v. bose

J

jedi74

macrumors regular
Original poster
Sep 22, 2012
102
0
which is better? i was going to get the beats by dr dre red edition - the one that doesn't use batteries.....is that just as good as bose?
 
Sound is a highly subjective matter. Listen to both and decide. Many consider both to be overpriced for the performance that you get.
 
Sol Republic Tracks HD produce better sound than the beats. Tracks are also durable and have mic/ipod controls.

If you look up reviews, they are always compared to the beats and most agree that the Tracks HD have better sound and cost about $80 less.
 
takeshi74 said:
Sound is a highly subjective matter. Listen to both and decide. Many consider both to be overpriced for the performance that you get.
Click to expand...

This is probably the most fair appraisal of the situation. Most audiophiles will tell you both companies are far overpriced for the sound they produce.

I am going to agree with the about the above post from Eddiec312, and say SOL Republic Tracks HD/Ultras ($99 and $179 respectively) both produce much better sound than any of the options above.
 
Last edited:
As said before there are way better brands out there (even for the same money).

But if it's just those to I would take the bose
 
Like other's have said, Beat and Bose aren't very good for the money you spend on them. But if you had to choose between the two, go with the Bose. I would rather have a nice looking set of headphones rather than looking like every other tool with ugly Beats around his neck.
 
No Regrets said:
Can you offer some other options that are "way better for the price"?
Click to expand...

I can offer one. That's what I did on my earlier post. I offered a bang for your buck headphones in the Sol Republic Tracks HD.

If you're looking for over the ear headphones that also has a mic and ipod controls all in one, then the Tracks HD are a cheaper alternative to Beats and according to most reviews have better sound quality.

Youtube has several reviews of the tracks HD and most even compare them to the Beats since they are similar.
 
I agree with the majority. Both Beats and Bose are way over priced and their are far better options. I wouldn't recommend either.
 
I've had all kinds of head phones.. For the longest time, I could not fathom spending more than $100 on a set of headphones. I decided a year or so ago to check out the Bose QC-15's. After putting them on in a crowded noisy store and even without music hearing nothing but silence, I decided to get a pair. After using them countless times, I have to say they are by far the best headphones I've ever owned. They have far exceeded my expectations. They sound great, are extrmely comfortable and do an amazing job of cutting out exterior sound. I travel a lot and it's great to be on a plane and not hear anything but the music while not having to crank the sound to drown out ambient noise. Like I said, I could never justify spending that kind of money of a set of headphones.. I am now glad I did.
 
With both Bose and Beats you're paying for the name. Quality wise they're nothing special.

I have a pair of B&W P5's and they're great and worth every penny.
 
http://www.headphones.com/

Seriously check it out. Is it a perfect website? Not at all. But it helped me pick some decent IEM's last year instead of the crap most stores sell.

Edit: Then again we are on an Apple fan website so maybe going with the "recognized" brands is the most important part of headphones. :)
 
Mr.C said:
With both Bose and Beats you're paying for the name. Quality wise they're nothing special.

I have a pair of B&W P5's and they're great and worth every penny.
Click to expand...

+1

I tried several different pairs of headphones before trying the P5s. They have excellent sound quality. I was surprised because I have never been a huge fan of B&W speakers (I'm a Paradigm man) but I love their headphones. I have to admit I will probably order the over the ear headphones from Paradigm Shift when they come out but so far I'm extremely happy with the P5. They not only sound good but are also very comfortable. I wear glasses and finding a decent over the ear headphone that was comfortable too was not easy.
 
I won a Beats headphones from a raffle and I gotta say, I really love it~ Maybe cuz I didn't have to pay $250 for them but gotta say, can definitely tell the difference between this and cheap headphones I've been using.
 
Why are you limiting yourself to the two worst "premium" headphone brands? beats v. bose sounds like Head-Fi troll bait. Get a pair of Sennheiser, Grado, AKG phones... anything else really.
 
As an Amazon Associate, MacRumors earns a commission from qualifying purchases made through links in this post.
As the others have mentioned head-fi.org and headphones.com are good resources. However the best judge are your own ears. Go to BestBuy where they have a variety on display and listen to them. I've been able to hook up my own iPhone to them underneath and listen to my own music.

Beats and Bose are certainly not a good value in terms of price and probably not the best in terms of audio fidelity.

You can get a pair of Grado's for much less. Even the $22 headphones from Monoprice are more well regarded:
http://news.cnet.com/8301-13645_3-57337747-47/how-good-can-$21.59-headphones-be/

I just recently picked up a pair of Phlips Citiscape Uptown headphones for $40 ($150 list) and they sound quite good to me for the money.
http://www.head-fi.org/t/612677/review-philips-citiscape-uptown-updated-sept-18-2012

Again you need to listen to them on your own and not let others decide for you because everyone has different tastes.
 
Mr.C said:
This a good site for reviews and consumer opinions.

http://www.head-fi.org/
Click to expand...

+1


You would definitely be able to get a very good pair of headphones with that kind of budget. Take a look at Ultrasone, Audio Technica's M50, Shure SRH750DJ, Beyerdynamics or Sennheiser. They walk over Bose and Beats easily and at a good price.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back