My Best Buy pre-order pick up experience went pretty well today. The whole process took almost 2 hours, but the majority of that was just waiting in line. I had a phone set aside with my name, so it wasn't a first come first serve like some had mentioned. The case selection wasn't that great, but they received a box of various Otterbox cases right as I was getting my phone activated.
Also, I upgraded my phone using Verizon's Edge plan. Typically, you have to pay the sales tax on the full price of the phone, which is between $50-60 in my area, when you pick up the phone. However, whatever system Best Buy used to calculate/accept payment of was done, so I didn't get charged the sales tax. I am not sure if this was an issue with all Best Buy stores, or just my local store. Either way, it was nice to save almost $60.
All in all, I was pleased with how things went and would definitely pre-order from my local Best Buy again.