Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I love(or loved, more on that later) my Bose QC2s, they sound amazing to me. I'm in no way an "audiophile," I order cables from monoprice, I like my JL w7 subs, and have a Philips 5.1 surround system; so I might not have the "best" ears but whatever. The noise cancelation is what makes them amazing IMO, I can't listen to other headphones now.

But I recently somehow broke them, and am out of warranty. I don't know what I did to them but thy cut out every half second for a fraction of a second so they're unusable. Tried a new cord, battery, source; same problem. Anyway, a new pair will be $150. Are there any over the ear headphones out there that have better noise cancelation then the Bose, say in the sub-$400 range. It would be tough paying more than $150 because of how much I loved my Bose, but if they're a good amount better I'd have to start thinking things out.
 
How do the B&W P5's handle compared to stuff of a similar price point from Sennheiser, AKG, or Grado?
 
I love(or loved, more on that later) my Bose QC2s, they sound amazing to me. I'm in no way an "audiophile," I order cables from monoprice, I like my JL w7 subs, and have a Philips 5.1 surround system; so I might not have the "best" ears but whatever. The noise cancelation is what makes them amazing IMO, I can't listen to other headphones now.

But I recently somehow broke them, and am out of warranty. I don't know what I did to them but thy cut out every half second for a fraction of a second so they're unusable. Tried a new cord, battery, source; same problem. Anyway, a new pair will be $150. Are there any over the ear headphones out there that have better noise cancelation then the Bose, say in the sub-$400 range. It would be tough paying more than $150 because of how much I loved my Bose, but if they're a good amount better I'd have to start thinking things out.

Sennheiser PCX 450, if they break, you can order replacement parts for Sennheisers, you don't just throw them out.
 
Sennheiser PCX 450, if they break, you can order replacement parts for Sennheisers, you don't just throw them out.

I purchased PCX 450 a couple of weeks ago and have to say, I have nothing but superlatives for them..

I've been lucky to have all bunch of friends who have different types of h/phones which I tried on over an extended period of time and for me, for the price range I looked for, PCX 450 really were the best both in sound quality and the comfort..

Although, like mouses, the headphones are such a personal thing. I spent 6 years in an infantry mortar platoon so my hearing is probably not the same as the young gen-yers these days... :)
 
I purchased PCX 450 a couple of weeks ago and have to say, I have nothing but superlatives for them..

I've been lucky to have all bunch of friends who have different types of h/phones and for me, for the price range I looked for, PCX 450 really were the best..

Although, like mouses, the headphones are such a personal thing. I spent 6 years in an infantry mortar platoon so my hearing is probably not the same as the young gen-yers these days... :)

I don't actually own a pair but i work with a guy that does, I tried them on with very low expectations given that Sennheiser is mainly known for their open ear cans which tend to always be better than closed.

Tried them for a while, and compared to well set up HD650s they are a bit behind, but compared to Sennheiser HD595s (which are also excellent) they are actually a step above quality wise, but the active noise cancelling is remarkably effective.

HD650s are Sennheiser's former flagship, so its not surprising that they don't quite come to that level (its a very different sound) but they are VERY good for the cost.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.