Toggle sidebar Toggle sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Best laptop for daughter @ college?

Tig Bitties

Tig Bitties

macrumors 603
Original poster
My daughter starts College this Fall, and she needs a laptop. We're big custom gaming PC desktop people here, I build all their high-end computers for them, we don't own any laptops, so not too familiar with them.

My daughter said Apple Macbook's are recommended per the college. iOS or whatever OS they use will be unfamiliar territory for my daughter as the whole family uses Google Pixel phones and Windows 11 Pro desktops, but she's open to trying an Apple device.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hovscorpion12 and LanerJ
Start with 1tb hard drive. From there get all the ram you're willing to pay for.

The more you have of each thing the longer the laptop will function smoothly.

I got 16gb/1tb on my Mac mini in 2020 and only in early 2025 did it start to run into memory pressure issues.

MacBook Air 32gb/1tb will likely go the length of the typical 4yr college.

Set the charging limit to 80% (can be done direct in the OS now) and battery should be a non-issue as well.

Then start budgeting for adding iPhones and iPads lol
 
  • Like
  • Haha
  • Love
Reactions: BotchQue, Harddrive, schnaps and 6 others
I would say to look for used MacBook Pro/Air M1/M2. If you aren't comfortable shopping used: MacBook Neo. If she isn't doing anything heavy and is willing to use safari, 8GB is probably fine; if she must use Chrome then maybe look for 16GB. I wouldn't suggest going over 512GB storage, even 256GB is probably fine; the school likely provides free cloud sync with Google Drive or OneDrive which should be incentivised to use in case—heaven forbid—the laptop takes a bath. Finally, don't be oversold on a big screen, everyone I know that got a 16" in school said they should have gotten the 13"-14".

Avoid plastic shells for these laptops and instead get a nice padded laptop bag. The shells trap crud inside and scratch up the laptop.

For reference, I got my IT degree in uni with a 2020 MBP with 8GB RAM and 256GB of storage. I was able to run VMs with UTM, edit huge documents, compile programs, etc. I even helped a friend edit a video in Final Cut and made some tunes in Logic (we miss you Pro Apps Bundle for Education😢). OneDrive was a savior both for saving space and collaborating and I avoided Chrome and Firefox since they are RAM hogs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Alameda, Parowdy, Brian33 and 1 other person
The school should offer guidence on what the students need.
For instance, my daughter is an engineering major, and they were very clear that you need a windows machine, not a mac, and they provided the specifications that should fit the bill.

Look at what the school says before making any decisions. Given you wrote they're recommending Macs, see what exactly does that mean, MBAs, MBPs?

My daughter found that anything larger the 14" is too big to carry, and use in class, obviously YMMV
 
  • Like
Reactions: Harddrive, keksikuningas, jchap and 4 others
danpass said:
Start with 1tb hard drive. From there get all the ram you're willing to pay for.

The more you have of each thing the longer the laptop will function smoothly.

I got 16gb/1tb on my Mac mini in 2020 and only in early 2025 did it start to run into memory pressure issues.

MacBook Air 32gb/1tb will likely go the length of the typical 4yr college.

Set the charging limit to 80% (can be done direct in the OS now) and battery should be a non-issue as well.

Then start budgeting for adding iPhones and iPads lol
Click to expand...
It depends on the major, but I think 32gb/1tb is overkill for most college students. I would look for good deals on the base MacBook Air (16/512), since the big box and online stores tend to have a larger inventory of the base configuration. You should have no problem getting through 4 years of college with the base MBA. All of my kids took MBAs to university, and never had an issue with the base units at 8gb/256gb configurations.

Of course, there are some majors that need more power under the hood, but then you should consider getting the MacBook Pro.

Side note: As for gaming, I would configure a college laptop for university requirements and not for gaming. If you want to bring a desktop gaming rig to college, I suppose you can do that, but I would recommend against it. It will take up room in the a crowded dorm and be a distraction during a time when you will be meeting new people, having a new experiences, and learning new things. My son had a roommate that brought a gaming rig to school. This roommate would be up all hours playing on line. School suffered. Socialization suffered. Health suffered. It just seemed like a huge waste of a great time in a young person's life to be holed-up in a dorm room alone paying games.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Alameda, neuropsychguy, BotchQue and 10 others
danpass said:
Start with 1tb hard drive. From there get all the ram you're willing to pay for.

The more you have of each thing the longer the laptop will function smoothly.

I got 16gb/1tb on my Mac mini in 2020 and only in early 2025 did it start to run into memory pressure issues.

MacBook Air 32gb/1tb will likely go the length of the typical 4yr college.

Set the charging limit to 80% (can be done direct in the OS now) and battery should be a non-issue as well.

Then start budgeting for adding iPhones and iPads lol
Click to expand...
This is all overkill. At 16/512 the specs of the base model Air are quite sufficient for general computing of all kinds.

You also don’t need to pre-emptively gimp your battery. It will work fine without cutting off 20% of its capacity. The Apple Silicon Macs have such light battery consumption that you end up putting way fewer charge cycles on them over time.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Ruggy, ifxf, Jumpthesnark and 8 others
danpass said:
The moment the daughter discovers stock market trading programs is the moment she'll want that 32/1tb.

-
Click to expand...
The percentage of debt ridden cash strapped college student that should be spending their time day trading stocks rather than attending class and studying is infinitesimally small. And, it should not form the basis of a tech recommendation for a typical college student.
 
  • Like
Reactions: someoneoutthere, ifxf, Jumpthesnark and 9 others
I agree with what danpass wrote in reply 2:
"MacBook Air 32gb/1tb will likely go the length of the typical 4yr college."

Alternates (will cost more money):
MacBook Pro (m4) with similar specs.
or
MacBook Pro (m5) with similar specs.

Note that I did not say "m4pro" or "m5pro".
She won't need that.

She can probably get an educational discount through her school.
Don't pass this up if available.
 
  • Like
Reactions: brilliantthings
Tig Bitties said:
she needs a laptop
Click to expand...

My advice: be sure to check the general computer recommendations of the university and the specific hardware + software requirements of the academic department or program before making any moves. If you decide to buy a new machine, be sure to compare the prices offered by the university to those at off-campus retailers.

Also, Apple is improving its Mac hardware security beginning with the M5 processors. The feature is called Memory Integrity Enforcement (it's already in the A19 and A19 Pro). If you are technical, Apple has a blogpost about it here:
security.apple.com

Memory Integrity Enforcement: A complete vision for memory safety in Apple devices - Apple Security Research​

Memory Integrity Enforcement (MIE) is the culmination of an unprecedented design and engineering effort spanning half a decade that combines the unique strengths of Apple silicon hardware with our advanced operating system security to provide industry-first, always-on memory safety protection...
security.apple.com
security.apple.com

For everybody else, MIE is a feature that is considered a must-have by many security professionals.
 
  • Love
  • Like
Reactions: Jumpthesnark and Tig Bitties
Mac tech at a local public university for the last 16 years. Any modern day m series Mac laptop will fit the bill for 4+ years of college especially since they come with 16 gigs of ram now a days except the Neo. 2 biggest issues we see at the college is students laptops run of of storage space or they bought a Mac but the classes they take require windows software. Depending on the major and software required a MBA with 16/512 will be more than enough for 4 years of college. If you are buying it from apple be sure to get the education discount and save a few bucks and buy it during the back to school promotion to get some free AirPods or gift card.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Alameda, someoneoutthere, surfzen21 and 11 others
15 in air/boom.

The big screen and portability all in one. Its still light at 3lbs but great for multiple windows for research purposes. That should last her 4 yrs or more.
 
danpass said:
The moment the daughter discovers stock market trading programs is the moment she'll want that 32/1tb.

-
Click to expand...
I trade stocks/options for a living and get along fine with a MBA 16/512, until 3 months ago it was a MBP with intel and 8 gig 256. obviously you can go over board I've seen people with multiple monitors big dollar computer etc but not needed in my opinion.
 
  • Like
Reactions: surfzen21, ignatius345, ElPaso and 1 other person
RUGERMAN said:
I trade stocks/options for a living and get along fine with a MBA 16/512, until 3 months ago it was a MBP with intel and 8 gig 256. obviously you can go over board I've seen people with multiple monitors big dollar computer etc but not needed in my opinion.
Click to expand...
Agreed.

Besides, how many starving students spend their days trading stocks? Classes during the day. Homework at night. Part time job at the dinning commons to help pay tuition they can’t afford. How many students can sit in front of a computer screen during trading hours trying to time the market placing bets with money they don’t have? Zero. None. Zilch.
 
  • Like
  • Sad
Reactions: jchap, ignatius345 and boswald
Depending on the courses and software involved, you could probably get away with a 13" MacBook Air or 14" Pro, if she doesn't want to lug around a bigger laptop. They have all kinds of configurations, but I would definitely pick up more storage (1TB) and at least 16GB of RAM. I went with 24 for longevity, but even that might become obsolete before you know it. I would ask the college what their requirements are and go with that!
 
Last edited:
15! using to programs nearly the same size side by side. Actualy researching, and reading for essays (if kids even do essays without AI but that's another topic). I love my 15. I use it for work (work from home 2x/week), and my side business and I constantly have two windows open viewing them side by side.
 
  • Love
Reactions: Tig Bitties
Tig Bitties said:
My daughter starts College this Fall, and she needs a laptop. We're big custom gaming PC desktop people here, I build all their high-end computers for them, we don't own any laptops, so not too familiar with them.

My daughter said Apple Macbook's are recommended per the college. iOS or whatever OS they use will be unfamiliar territory for my daughter as the whole family uses Google Pixel phones and Windows 11 Pro desktops, but she's open to trying an Apple device.
Click to expand...
This will depend entirely on your course software requirements. .

The college might recommend Macbooks but you can get loads of battery efficient Windows 11 laptops now that largely do the exact same thing. If your daughter is pursuing a photography or videography course then a Mac is a better option because Final Cut is the industry standard in video editing.

If the course is Architecture then core software like Autodesk Revit doesn't have a Mac port and AutoCAD has a much better UI on Windows. If all she is doing is mashing out essays and experiments then stick to what you know.
 
The school should have the right answer for her major. Probably the the 13‑inch MacBook Air with the M5 chip because it's light and poratble, good battery life, quite, and very capable. She will be better off if it has no games on it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ifxf
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back