Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

oldoneeye

macrumors regular
Sep 23, 2014
134
418
How are the 3rd party RAM compared to Apple's? Aside from the Apple charging a premium, any notable difference in performance, quality, or overall stability?

There are only three significant DRAM vendors left. Samsung, Hynix and Micron. Neither Samsung nor Hynix sell DIMMs directly to end users, but do sell to OEMs like Apple. Crucial however are a branch of Micron - you get their expertise in PCB layout and their DRAM. So long as you spec correctly, then any vendor's performance will be comparable, but margins &quality may differ.
 

oldoneeye

macrumors regular
Sep 23, 2014
134
418
Apple doesn't make RAM, so there's no difference. All RAM is "third party" in that sense.

True, but Apple won't buy from small module houses either however - they'll deal as a tier 1 customer from the major DRAM manufacturers - who will have stringent quality controls
 

opeter

macrumors 68030
Aug 5, 2007
2,680
1,602
Slovenia
How are the 3rd party RAM compared to Apple's? Aside from the Apple charging a premium, any notable difference in performance, quality, or overall stability?

Why would there be any difference? RAM is RAM. Speed is the same, memory type is same ...
Buy the one, that is the cheapest.

I've got myselft Transcend RAM modules for my Mac mini 2018.
 

TheShadowKnows!

macrumors 6502a
Sep 30, 2014
861
1,739
National Capital Region
These promotions are great. They cut into the retailer margins, not Apple’s margins.

Dude you brought a wide smile to my face -- thanks!

[This because these are not "rogue" discounts offered by third-tier resellers, but all these are Apple-approved and -subsidized.]

[By the way, I thought you had gone into hiding/s]
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Ener Ji

lovehateapple

macrumors 6502a
Oct 15, 2015
597
883
USA
Thats a huge rip on the mini. They make it sound like you're getting a deal but note they installed the ram. Which is less than half of what apple is charging. Then they are jacking the base price to match apples price for the ram they installed. Then "discounted" it to a price that is still higher if you bought the same config and put the ram in yourself.


I don't care if Expercom makes a bigger profit. Apple warranty stays intact and I get more RAM (than if I bought from Apple) at a lower price. Sounds like a win-win to me. What more could you want?
 

archer75

macrumors 68040
Jan 26, 2005
3,116
1,746
Oregon
I don't care if Expercom makes a bigger profit. Apple warranty stays intact and I get more RAM (than if I bought from Apple) at a lower price. Sounds like a win-win to me. What more could you want?
And that's fine. My complaint is their shady advertising.

Even if you install it yourself the warranty on the mini is still good. In either case the ram itself won't be warrantied by apple.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FairlyKors

Baymowe335

Suspended
Oct 6, 2017
6,640
12,451
Dude you brought a wide smile to my face -- thanks!

[This because these are not "rogue" discounts offered by third-tier resellers, but all these are Apple-approved and -subsidized.]

[By the way, I thought you had gone into hiding/s]
Show me data that proves they are subsidized. Apple has consistent gross margins of 38.5% so these promotions haven't eroding Apple's margins before despite seeing MANY like it from carriers and brick and mortar.

Why would I go into hiding? Because stocks fluctuate in value? I'm so scared. You know the average stock trades within a 50% range from its high to low in a 52wk period?
 

thekev

macrumors 604
Aug 5, 2010
7,005
3,343
That’s a big difference. And Apple’s RAM premium is substantial, but at least you know you’re getting quality parts. (Plus, a 256GB SSD is piddling these days, and not upgradeable.)

Personally I’d rather take advantage of OWC’s discount/rebate promotion, saving about as much, and install the RAM myself.

There's nothing that great about OWC, and I personally avoid them entirely.

You can find the same thing elsewhere for less without the nonsense marketing. You should also keep your original ram. If you ever need to test whether a stick has gone bad, you will need it. If you want to send it in for warranty service, you should also replace the upgraded sticks with the original ones. This facilitates service testing of the unit as it was shipped.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kabeyun

brofkand

macrumors 65816
Jun 11, 2006
1,302
3,238
True, but Apple won't buy from small module houses either however - they'll deal as a tier 1 customer from the major DRAM manufacturers - who will have stringent quality controls

Don't spread FUD. There are only 3 DRAM manufacturers and they all have stringent quality controls. It's not like there's knockoff RAM floating around.

There is no such thing as premium RAM. Paying more for faster speeds, better timings and lower latency sure, but other than ECC or RDIMM memory, which the Mac mini doesn't support anyway, I'm not aware of premium RAM so I don't know how the memory Apple puts in is any different than the memory this company installs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FairlyKors

Kabeyun

macrumors 68040
Mar 27, 2004
3,412
6,350
Eastern USA
There's nothing that great about OWC, and I personally avoid them entirely.

You can find the same thing elsewhere for less without the nonsense marketing. You should also keep your original ram. If you ever need to test whether a stick has gone bad, you will need it. If you want to send it in for warranty service, you should also replace the upgraded sticks with the original ones. This facilitates service testing of the unit as it was shipped.
Over many years I’ve actually had only very good experiences with them, and I pay no attention to the nonsense marketing. Good suggestion on the original RAM though, thanks.
 
  • Like
Reactions: thekev

Ener Ji

macrumors 6502
Apr 10, 2010
474
342
These promotions are great. They cut into the retailer margins, not Apple’s margins.

Show me data that proves they are subsidized. Apple has consistent gross margins of 38.5% so these promotions haven't eroding Apple's margins before despite seeing MANY like it from carriers and brick and mortar.

It's simply the way business works. Retailers generally don't have the margins to create large discounts without manufacturer support. Every quarter, manufacturers assess how much certain products are selling and how "full of product" is the inventory channel, and then decide whether to offer promotions to help push certain products.

I have no insight into Apple promotions in general, but for other companies they take various forms with varying levels of generosity, but manufacturers are almost always involved when an authorized reseller initiates a sale.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FairlyKors

Caiwyn

macrumors member
Jan 24, 2005
84
0
This is the first thing I noticed. Everyone knows Apple charges a huge premium for their pre-installed RAM. For a company to install their own off the shelf RAM, list Apple's price for that much RAM, then offer a "discount" back to the normal price for a lower end spec Mac mini + off the shelf RAM is shady to say the least. It probably works fine, but there is no actual discount.

This is incorrect. They're selling the Mini at $50 off the base price across the board -- that includes the 6-core i7 3.2Ghz model. Not a huge discount, but still better than nothing. Even if you stick with the base 8GB from Apple and don't buy Expercom's RAM, they're giving you that discount. So yes, it really is a (small) deal.

And yes, they're selling their own RAM, which admittedly is not as cheap as you can get elsewhere, but is still MUCH cheaper than Apple's price. For 32 GB they're charging $359, which is roughly $100 more than you would pay from, say, Crucial, but still $241 less than Apple charges. And because they're an authorized reseller, buying their "off-the-shelf" RAM won't violate AppleCare. Buying your own RAM and installing it yourself will.

Additionally, if you live outside of Utah, Expercom won't charge you sales tax. Depending on how much you're maxxing out your Mini, this could potentially make up for their RAM prices. This is the ONLY outlet I've seen selling the 3.2Ghz 6-core i7 model with an actual ship date aside from Apple themselves. B&H Photo has the model listed for "preorder" with no indication of how long it will take to ship. Adorama lists it as "on backorder." Expercom lists 8-12 business days for delivery.

I REALLY wish I'd known about this deal in advance. I ordered my Mini from Apple two days ago thinking there weren't going to be any better deals today. I got a 3.2 Ghz i7 6-core processor with a 1 TB SSD. I ordered 32 GB of Crucial RAM from Amazon. I saved $100 on the RAM, sure, but I paid $50 more for the Mini and another $150 on sales tax.

If I'd bought from Expercom today, I'd have saved myself $100 and I'd still be eligible for AppleCare coverage. I'm kicking myself right now.
 

greytmom

macrumors 68040
Jun 23, 2010
3,566
1,002
Fantastic... appreciate the head’s up. I was planning on ordering from Apple today, but got it from B&H instead, saved $500.
[doublepost=1543278567][/doublepost]
I REALLY wish I'd known about this deal in advance. I ordered my Mini from Apple two days ago thinking there weren't going to be any better deals today. I got a 3.2 Ghz i7 6-core processor with a 1 TB SSD. I ordered 32 GB of Crucial RAM from Amazon. I saved $100 on the RAM, sure, but I paid $50 more for the Mini and another $150 on sales tax.

If I'd bought from Expercom today, I'd have saved myself $100 and I'd still be eligible for AppleCare coverage. I'm kicking myself right now.

Can’t you kill the Apple order, or return it? Same with Amazon?
 

brofkand

macrumors 65816
Jun 11, 2006
1,302
3,238
This is incorrect. They're selling the Mini at $50 off the base price across the board -- that includes the 6-core i7 3.2Ghz model. Not a huge discount, but still better than nothing. Even if you stick with the base 8GB from Apple and don't buy Expercom's RAM, they're giving you that discount. So yes, it really is a (small) deal.

And yes, they're selling their own RAM, which admittedly is not as cheap as you can get elsewhere, but is still MUCH cheaper than Apple's price. For 32 GB they're charging $359, which is roughly $100 more than you would pay from, say, Crucial, but still $241 less than Apple charges. And because they're an authorized reseller, buying their "off-the-shelf" RAM won't violate AppleCare. Buying your own RAM and installing it yourself will.

Additionally, if you live outside of Utah, Expercom won't charge you sales tax. Depending on how much you're maxxing out your Mini, this could potentially make up for their RAM prices. This is the ONLY outlet I've seen selling the 3.2Ghz 6-core i7 model with an actual ship date aside from Apple themselves. B&H Photo has the model listed for "preorder" with no indication of how long it will take to ship. Adorama lists it as "on backorder." Expercom lists 8-12 business days for delivery.

I REALLY wish I'd known about this deal in advance. I ordered my Mini from Apple two days ago thinking there weren't going to be any better deals today. I got a 3.2 Ghz i7 6-core processor with a 1 TB SSD. I ordered 32 GB of Crucial RAM from Amazon. I saved $100 on the RAM, sure, but I paid $50 more for the Mini and another $150 on sales tax.

If I'd bought from Expercom today, I'd have saved myself $100 and I'd still be eligible for AppleCare coverage. I'm kicking myself right now.

AppleCare is not voided by third party RAM.
 
  • Like
Reactions: awer25

falainber

macrumors 68040
Mar 16, 2016
3,429
4,000
Wild West
These promotions are great. They cut into the retailer margins, not Apple’s margins.
If that was the case why are Apple so stupid to require higher regular prices? Lower the prices, sell way more stuff and, if the profit margin is the same (as you suggest), make way more profits.
 

lovehateapple

macrumors 6502a
Oct 15, 2015
597
883
USA
And that's fine. My complaint is their shady advertising.

Even if you install it yourself the warranty on the mini is still good. In either case the ram itself won't be warrantied by apple.

I checked directly with Apple a couple of days ago and was told if I install additional RAM in a mac mini myself, the warranty would be voided. I ordered a mini from Expercom this morning and had the option of buying it with Apple RAM or Expercom RAM.
 

thekev

macrumors 604
Aug 5, 2010
7,005
3,343
If I'd bought from Expercom today, I'd have saved myself $100 and I'd still be eligible for AppleCare coverage. I'm kicking myself right now.

Expercom's ram installation doesn't impact your warranty any more than user installed ram. Some shops are also authorized repair centers, so they may cover this case by dealing with warranty service in house. You should still be eligible for Applecare. Save your original ram sticks. If you ever need warranty service, put the original ones back in. This way there is no question as to whether your issues are due to a bad dimm which was supplied by a third party.

Some third parties used to have good deals on Applecare, which could be obtained after purchase within the first year. I'm not sure if that's still the case.
 

FairlyKors

macrumors regular
Jun 21, 2018
179
187
Staines, East London
And still to expensive.

I don’t know who Apple is selling all these $3,000 laptops to— presumably people who’re too cool to actually dig into the specs and look at the actual hardware Apple is selling?

This isn’t an anti-Apple, Pro-PC issue I bring up, not at all, but PC laptop manufacturers provide a good look at the levels to ehich Apple is marking up hardware.

The “best value” in the entire MBP lineup is the stock 2018 MBP 15” at $2,399 (or on sale for, say, $2,150). As of November 2018, you can find a laptop running Windows 10 with the same* specs (see below) for $1,000 less. For just over $1,000 you get the exact same CPU thats in this MBP, the same level of NVMe SSD storage, same amount of RAM, and a graphics card (GTX 1060/1070) that’s significantly faster than anything that’s ever been put into a MBP or iMac before. The display is highly likely to be below Mac standards, but external displays (for final proofing, or whatever) are incredibly cheap now.

Of course this isn’t an “apples to apples” comparison. The intangibles that make the Mac worth more are indeed a long list. But—how much are these intangibles worth?

The $3,500 MBP (or the $4,000 MBP with a Vega 20 GPU) really force a long hard look at how indispensable that long list of intangibles truly is.

To think that the (kinda weak) MBP 13” starts at $1,800 and the (not strong) MBP 15” starts at $2,400... that’s worrisome, because I’d got with a MBP over a PC laptop any day... well, until the day I feel like a complete sucker for not spitting out the Apple pacifier and just buying the tool I need to get the job done.
 

brofkand

macrumors 65816
Jun 11, 2006
1,302
3,238
It's simply the way business works. Retailers generally don't have the margins to create large discounts without manufacturer support. Every quarter, manufacturers assess how much certain products are selling and how "full of product" is the inventory channel, and then decide whether to offer promotions to help push certain products.

I have no insight into Apple promotions in general, but for other companies they take various forms with varying levels of generosity, but manufacturers are almost always involved when an authorized reseller initiates a sale.

Apple almost certainly has MAP agreements in place with their retailers, meaning any discounts must be approved by Apple. The question is, is Apple offering rebates to retailers to replace the discount's lost revenue? I would assume they are.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.