Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Even with all the privacy violations Facebook has made over the years, I doubt this is intentional. It looks more like someone tried to take a shortcut while creating a feature so the camera would open instantly without any software optimizations, similar to how Facebook was playing audio in the background to keep the app open a few years back. Definitely still creepy and they should have better software qc, but let's not jump to conclusions too quickly.
Hmmm. And I guess you are similarly tolerant of Santa and the Tooth Fairy.
 
I turned off Facebook's access to camera, microphone, location (when not using app) and any other thing I can restrict a long time ago...

Still have the app because there are certain family members who I communicate with on there and they don't use other services.
How about email/phone.... 🤪
 
Kinda the sort of reason why I don’t have the Facebook app on my phone.

But I do have the Instagram app, as it’s the only way to have full functionality. Wonder what it’s doing..
 
You’re gonna have to enlighten me, what is ‘Astro-turfing’? And no Reddit.
From Wikipedia: “Astroturfing is the practice of masking the sponsors of a message or organization … to make it appear as though it originates from and is supported by grassroots participants.”

In the context of these forums, they’re essentially implying that some posters here aren’t actually humans discussing with their own thoughts but rather sham accounts posting specifically on behalf of something greater than them (be it a company or cause).
 
  • Like
Reactions: 44267547
Facebook's app is apparently able to access the camera when the user did not grant permission. That is a security failure. Yeah FB is taking advantage of it but the security failure lies with apple.

No, Apple "forbids" App developers to access camera/speaker/photo's without user consent, that is, if you set those permissions to deny acces, Facebook does, so Facebook is the crook.
 
People want to assign nefarious reasons to this, but given the quality of their software, a bug satisfies Occam's razor.

That said, Settings > Privacy > Camera/Microphone/Location Services/Contacts - rescind permissions from all apps unless absolutely necessary.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jonblatho
No, Apple "forbids" App developers to access camera/speaker/photo's without user consent, that is, if you set those permissions to deny acces, Facebook does, so Facebook is the crook.
Are you saying apps access permissions are enforced by the honour system? And you are ok with this?
 
The bug is that Facebook is letting you know it's always watching and listening.
[automerge]1573592227[/automerge]
People want to assign nefarious reasons to this, but given the quality of their software, a bug satisfies Occam's razor.

That said, Settings > Privacy > Camera/Microphone/Location Services/Contacts - rescind permissions from all apps unless absolutely necessary.

Actually, the simplest explanation is that Facebook is accessing the camera and microphone to watch what you're doing, but it accidentally showed the hidden video view it's using.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.