Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Hard drives

after talking to workers at micro center 2 weeks ago when I was building my own pc they all said seagate was the best. They said western digital is fine but seagate tends to be one of the best. I know apple used seagate drives for the longest time.

Would you be able to recomend any particular models? I had my eye on a WD model that is 1 TB in size. With three of those in my Mac Pro, I would be pretty much comfortable as far as my storage needs went. However, your arguamnt for Seagate has merit. Also, do you mean to imply that Seagate is no longer used by Apple?

G
 
Don't get me wrong, plenty of people can make use of the processor upgrades Apple offer. In my experience though, for most people, especially those who don't know if they actually need it or not, the extra expense can't be justified. But that is for you to calculate, and if you measure your processing in tens of hours a week, every week and your time is valuble it very well may be worth it, but again I would think if that is the case for you, then you'd surely have upgraded when the Mac Pros came out 22 months ago, or at least when the 8 cores came out over a year ago. Not trying to insult you, just trying to get you to think about what you are actually getting for your money.

I have my own film production house, where we make commercials and some documentaries. I came to Mac and Final Cut Pro very cautiously, as this would be a big investment for me. So first a laptop and then the G5, which has more than repaid the investment in trms of money and ease of use over the last four years.

I did not consider a Mac Pro at first, as I prefer to let the first few months of a new product line pass by for a while so that Apple can iron out the bugs. Of late, my G5 has been acting up and I believe I will have to replace the logic board or junk the machine altogether. Hence the Mac Pro - now. Also the need for the maximum processing possible. If the software (in this case, FCP Studio 2)is capable of doing a lot, I believe that it requires the processor to match.

You don't need to buy it all in one go, buy 8GB (4x2GB) and monitor your usage.

That is the way I am veering right now

I wouldn't bother using a RAID card unless you need it for hardware configurtion i.e. RAID 5 or SAS drives. If you do reconsider on the SAS, do bare in mind SAS drives tend to be very noisey.

No, I think I will drop SAS for the moment. large volume SATA looks like the way to go.

I believe you can buy it from other sources, but I doubt it is considerably cheaper, so it is probably best to get it through Apple. I don't know much about Huge drives, but you seem a little unsure on this so just check that you actually need it. How are you currently connecting them to your G5?

Good idea - will try and get through to Huge. My confusion is only because they have been acquired by Ciprico and the website is a little confused.

I personally reccomend WD at the moment, but Seagate are a fine alternative. Go with whatever you feel comfortable with though.[/QUOTE]

At this point, I am just looking for the most stable of the choices. I would like to buy 3 x 1 TB drives and I would be grateful for any recommendation you could make in this area.

Many thanks for taking the time to reply, guys.

G
 
As far as drives and storage I prefer externals to internals (cause I have to travel with my drives) but Venus T5 is a nice external raid enclosure (eSata) that holds 5 drives. On windows people have issues with them but on mac I just plugged it in and used the OS to create the raid :)

Something to think about if you may have to move your stuff around to other machines.
 
Touchdown!!

A quick note to let all of you know that I have just completed my purchase.

This is what I put together:

Mac Pro 3.2 (8-core)
500 Gb 7200 rpm HDD
Additional 3 x 1 TB Hitachi HDDs
16 GB Ram
Nvidia GeForce 8800 graphics card

Mac Book Pro 2.6 Ghz
200 Gb HD
4 Gb Ram

Picked up both systems as refurbished Apple systems from the Apple Store, USA. The money I saved buying refurbished helped to fund the MBP.

Purchased the 1 TB drives and the extra Ram for both systems (both came in with 2 GB of ram each) from OWC and saved a lot of money there.

For all those who took the time to write in -- Thank you very much guys. I could not have made these very informed decisions without your contributions.

Thank you once again.
 
sorry I never answered about the HD's. I stopped following the thread. It looks like you got a godly set up so congrats! Idk what hd's apple uses any more as it could vary from product to product.

They said WD has kinda stepped up their game but seagate has been on top for longer? So take that as you want.

Just out of curiosity what made you go with hitachi?

And yes the guy above me is right. Down the road if you need more power you could upgrade to the ati 3780(have to buy it on their website since apple doesn't sell it). The ati cards right now are better at iLife and final cut.
 
Adaptec 39160

People, I would appreciate some expert advice – from what I have seen, this is the place to find it.

My present Edit setup
, which I use for professional video editing and audio recording:

G5 Dual 2.0 with FCP 4.5 HD.
Video input with an IO
Storage is Huge HMV-900-MAX S.No. 3H334 (First drive)
and HMV 320S-800-M S No. HMV 04L139 (Second drive).
Three Lacie 500 GB drives
Controlled with an Adaptec 39160.

Planned upgrade:

I plan to upgrade my system to a Mac Pro on which I will run the FCP Studio 2. Based on my limited reading, I plan to buy a 3.2 Ghz Quad core system and add the parts separately as that appears to be the most cost-effective way to build a new edit system.

Questions:

I plan to buy Ram from OWC. How much Ram should I buy? 8 GB or 16 GB?

Do I need to buy a Mac Pro Raid Card? Is it only available from apple, or can it be purchased from a seller at a lower price?

Do I need more than one 320 GB internal drive?

What card will I need to acquire to control the Huge drives?

What graphics card do I need? Do I stay with the stock ATI Radeon HD 2600 XT or trade up?

I need to buy this system over the next two weeks, so I would appreciate any help I can get.

My apologies if any of these queries have already been asked.

Many thanks.

George

HI George !

Which driver did you for you're adaptec card to mount the HMV disc on the desktop?

I have bought an HMV 1200 dual max with adaptec 39160 card form e friend of mine to use it on my mac which is same as your,e spec. I thought i use it on my old mac until I get the ATTO card to use it on my new mac. I did download a driver which I found from adaptec website I think it was the 1.2 version but still it won't mount on the desktop.

did you have any problems installing at the beginning ?
Regards
VAlon
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.