Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
If anybody is curious and has an XS, I'll sell you a conversion kit that will allow you to emulate the XR camera.

View attachment 799367

$59.99 + shipping

I know this is a joke, but it's important to state that this actually does not enable XR camera functionality. Currently iOS requires* the XS to use the telephoto lens during portrait modes or >= 2x zoom. So if you prefer only using the wide angle lens for these shots, you HAVE to get an XR.

*This may change with future iOS updates, but I wouldn't count on it
 
Having seen these photos side by side, I am very grateful that I decided to upgrade to iPhone XR (from 6s). :)
Did you look at full resolution on a zoomed in photo?
[doublepost=1540866449][/doublepost]No mention of the OLED screen Dan...
 
If you have an XS or Max and want to take someone’s picture in low light, dont forget that you have the option of not choosing portrait mode so that the phone uses the brighter wide angle lens.
Interesting that Apple missed this. The XS should always be better or the same at everything. Not using Portrait mode is more of a workaround. Hopefully they'll fix it in the next updates.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rhartford
Why even include the first two photos? Completely different focus and distance.

Like comparing a photo of paris from space vs a photo standing next to the eiffel tower:rolleyes:
 
Did my own comparison at the apple store between the XS and XR and I immediately noticed the difference, the XR is just not as sharp as the XS or even the X. The whole device just feels very off , the display doesnt go edge to edge or close like the XS/X that also just threw me off , if it was priced at $599 no biggie, but at $749 .... NOPE
 
Woah. Is that Squires Castle in some of those shots?!



The iPhone XR and the iPhone XS models share many similarities, but one major difference is the rear camera setup. While the iPhone XS features a dual-lens camera system with both wide-angle and telephoto lenses, the iPhone XR has a single wide-angle camera lens.

In our latest YouTube video, we compared the cameras of the iPhone XR and the iPhone XS Max to see how much of a difference you're really going to see with the single lens camera vs. the dual-lens camera.


Though the iPhone XR doesn't have two lenses to work with, it still has many of the same features that are available in the iPhone XS, enabled through a bit of software magic.

Smart HDR, the feature that combines multiple images to bring out more detail in the shadows and highlights of photographs, is available on both the iPhone XS and iPhone XR, as are Portrait Mode, Portrait Lighting, and Depth Control, which is an option that lets you adjust the amount of background blur in an image.

iphonexrxsportraitmode-800x450.jpg

iPhone XR vs. iPhone XS Portrait Mode
On the iPhone XR, Portrait Mode, which blurs the background of an image while keeping the foreground sharp, only works when a person is in the frame. That means you can't get Portrait Mode shots of pets, flowers, food, or other objects.

You can do non-person Portrait Mode photos on the iPhone XS and iPhone XS Max because two cameras are used together to calculate depth information. The single camera on the iPhone XR provides less detailed depth information for photographs, so it needs to use person detection to separate the foreground from the background.

On the plus side, because the iPhone XR exclusively uses the f/1.8 wide-angle lens for Portrait Mode photos and does not need to rely on the smaller aperture f/2.4 telephoto lens that's in the iPhone XS, Portrait Mode images taken in low light can turn out better than Portrait Mode photos on the XS because the wider lens lets in more ambient light.

iphonexrxslowlightportrait-800x450.jpg

iPhone XR vs. iPhone XS Portrait Mode in low light
With Portrait Mode photos, the iPhone XR struggles a bit with edge detection and the images can be softer than those captured with the iPhone XS due to the lack of a telephoto lens and less depth information to work with. Portrait Mode photos on both devices can be edited with different Depth Control and Portrait Lighting features, though there are two less Portrait Lighting options on the XR.

When taking standard non-Portrait Mode photos, there are few differences between the iPhone XS models and the iPhone XR because the two smartphones are both using the same f/1.8 wide-angle lens. Images taken in standard zoom mode, for example, look the same.

iphonexrxslandscape-800x450.jpg

You will, however, see some differences using the iPhone XS telephoto lens for 2x optical zoom in conditions where lighting is good, because this feature isn't available on the iPhone XR. With no second lens, the iPhone XR ls limited to digital zoom that maxes out at 5x. The iPhone XS can do 2x optical zoom and up to 10x digital zoom, but it's only going to be using the optical zoom in ideal lighting conditions.

iphonexrxscomparisonarch-800x450.jpg

If you take a 2x photo in a low lighting situation on the iPhone XS, there's a good chance it will look identical to the same photo taken on the iPhone XR because the iPhone XS defaults to digital zoom over optical zoom when the wider lens will produce a better picture. If you take a 2x photo with bright lighting on the iPhone XS, it's going to be sharper than the same 2x photo on the iPhone XR because of the difference between true optical zoom and digital zoom.

iphonexrxsflower-800x450.jpg

4K video using the wide-angle lens looks identical on both the iPhone XS and the iPhone XR, and both phones feature the same video capabilities like 1080p 240fps slo-mo, optical image stabilization, and stereo sound recording. You are, however, limited to 3x digital zoom on the iPhone XR vs. 2x optical zoom or 6x digital zoom on the iPhone XS.

iphonexrxscastle-800x450.jpg

When it comes to the front-facing camera, you won't see differences between the iPhone XR and the iPhone XS models because all three of the smartphones use the same TrueDepth camera system with a 7-megapixel front-facing camera and full support for Portrait Mode images, Portrait Lighting, Depth Control, Memoji, and Animoji.

iphonexsiphonexrfrontfacingportrait-800x450.jpg

Front-facing camera on iPhone XR and iPhone XS
All in all, when it comes to camera performance, unless you're someone who takes a lot of Portrait Mode photos or often uses the optical zoom feature on the iPhone, you may not notice much of a difference if you choose the iPhone XR over the iPhone XS.

To get a clearer look at the camera quality of the iPhone XR compared to the iPhone XS Max, make sure to check out our Imgur album, which features full-resolution versions of the photographs that we shared in this article and in the video above.

What do you think of the iPhone XR camera? Do you prefer the iPhone XS camera? Let us know your thoughts on the comparison images in the comments.

Article Link: Camera Comparison: iPhone XR vs. iPhone XS Max
 
Based upon the photos in this article, the XR is the winner. XS photos seem overly smooth.
 
However it doesn't. Posts like this shows agenda does exist...like when people thought pixel 3 took certain pics in a test and people got wrong as it was shot on a XS.
I don’t get why people are trying to make out the Xr is better it is not. Say that the Xs isn’t worth the extra money that’s fine. Say that you aren’t bothered about the OLED display of higher resolution. Fine. Say that the Xr is better value for money. Fine. However it’s not a better phone.
[doublepost=1540884931][/doublepost]
It's very odd that the portrait mode feature with the single lens isn't included on the Xs. I know obviously they want you to use the telephoto lens for that mode but you can't deny how much better the lower light performance is with the wide angle.
The low light picture on the Xr didn’t blur out the background at all. So really it would have been the same as taking the shot on the Xs with the wide angle and not taking a portrait.
 
  • Like
Reactions: roncron
I can't believe they didn't include links to larger pictures, you can judge a **** on such tiny pictures - completely useless
 
  • Like
Reactions: roncron
The first and last pair of photos look like the opposite of the rest of the pairs in this article.
 
I guess this article is about quality; are the two phones capable of the same images. But no one discusses this about the two phones -

Having two optical lenses (on the S); one roughly 26mm (35mm camera equivalent) and one 52mm, regardless of how that impacts portrait mode, is great for that very fact - you have two focal lengths with you rather than one. Forgot digital zoom as that is always a poorer quality. Two physical lenses means more options for creativity.

As a photographer, (and no the iPhone is not used for my commercial work; a 100mp camera is my work camera), the very fact the iPhone Xs models have two optical lenses is why I would choose the S over the R.
 
The main problem with the telephoto lens on the Xs is the sensor.
In good light I often use 2x, the smart HDR stuff works on it as well and it is the best way to capture something distant or to make a portrait, even without the fake blur. If the light isn't great I only seldom use 2x, it has OIS so you can still have a good shot but the new sensor on the wide lens is way better. In low light no 2x at all, it is useless.

I think I'll keep my Xs for 2 years, so I hope they'll improve the 2x sensor by 2020 and make it similar to the wide lens one to capture more light. If they keep having two lenses on the higher priced iPhones they ought to put a great 2x camera there, so you have a really compelling reason to go for the premium model.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.