Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Thanks for all the (polite/useful) replies. Great advice. And I will try Ubuntu...

I guess the real reason I ask the question is that I love my MBP and I adore OSX - but I also love the idea of learning more about computers and what better way to learn than to build myself a desktop (that I don't think I'd use all that much). However, I never want to go back to Windows. At all. I've even vowed not to install ANY Microsoft software on my MBP.

So, I originally asked cos I can't exactly build a Mac, so I'd like to build a computer and load OSX onto it.

But maybe Linux is the answer (shame it won't then fully sync with my MBP).

I think Linux is a great OS to start learning about computers because you can do anything you want with it and tweak it however you want. You can even make it look like Mac OS X if you'd like. 😛 I enjoy using Ubuntu just as much as I love using Mac OS X. They're both great operating systems. I only use Windows now for my games.
 
My PC with it experiences no bugs whatsoever, and it takes 20 minutes to install just like a real mac. 5 for loading the disc, 15 for installing the OS. I only have to edit the networking kext to change a device ID so I can get internet working, that takes like 15 seconds through terminal. You can install official updates without fear thanks to PC_EFI on Core 2 Duo machines. Totally stable, and gets better benchmark scores than every mac besides mac pro's and the Extreme imac.

The mac mini is not a solution for everyone. It is cheap, infact it is cheaper than the machine I have OSX86 on, but it does not meet my needs. I had a mac mini before, its lame and only for casual computer use. I needed an affordable gaming PC, it costed me around $650. The imac would make a pathetic gaming machine as well and it cant be upgraded which is a complete deal breaker for gamers.


I will only get mac laptops but Apple didnt have what I needed in a desktop, so I went elsewhere.

Your last line doesn't give you the rights or reason to install Mac OS X on your generic hardware in any way shape or form. Also you really shouldn't be promoting the fact that you did any of this as if it's a perfectly viable solution because it's not. Don't make it sound like it's as simple as shoving the Leopard disc in and wah lah OS X's installed! There are a lot more headaches behind it, the hackintosh website certainly has a lot of posters in tears trying to do the wrong thing. You are helping no one in preaching your success story.
 
The question should have been is it possible. Hell yes its possible
but

HERE IS THE PROBLEM!

When you do this you are more than likely to be LOCKED into the current version you can find, and it's not just stick in the disk and it loads up you have to do command line commands to setup things ala Linux/Unix but once done it should run 98% of the things you want..

Than when apple updates things, its possible it will break things. I do not want my sensative data on questionable hardware.


I tried this for a while and gave up, bout an iMAC and love it.. Really was hoping for a 2.8ghz Mini with at least a 256 3d card in it!! Come on Apple you can do this today and GROW the userbase even more!
 
Your last line doesn't give you the rights or reason to install Mac OS X on your generic hardware in any way shape or form.
Oh well, dont lose sleep over my actions, I sure dont. Some people dont consider it wrong to do what they want with the stuff they buy.
Also you really shouldn't be promoting the fact that you did any of this as if it's a perfectly viable solution because it's not. Don't make it sound like it's as simple as shoving the Leopard disc in and wah lah OS X's installed! There are a lot more headaches behind it, the hackintosh website certainly has a lot of posters in tears trying to do the wrong thing. You are helping no one in preaching your success story.
I did my research before buying the computer and made sure all the parts would give minimal hassle. So for me and everyone else who has the right components it is just popping in the disc and "wah lah leopard is installed". Anyone with common hardware can easily find instructions online, then its just a matter of following those instructions.
 
totally unreasonable statement. crap tin box? w/o OSX, macs are just same as those "crap tin box"
Sorry to disagree .. 🙁

e.g.
you cant compare the case for a Mac pro with any case you can get for a PC
IMO Mac hardware (including the case) is way better than the pc equivalent.
It's not just the OS that makes Mac's superior ... 😎
 
Your last line doesn't give you the rights or reason to install Mac OS X on your generic hardware in any way shape or form.

I didn't ask for right nor reason - I asked if it is possible.

Also you really shouldn't be promoting the fact that you did any of this as if it's a perfectly viable solution because it's not.

It sounds like a viable solution to me.

You are helping no one in preaching your success story.

They're helping me.

To stainlessliquid - thanks for sharing your experiences. And you're right, the Mac Mini isn't right for me as I can't expand it and the Mac Pro is just far too much cash!
 
That is why I said it was breach of contract...

Installing Mac OS X on a PC is not illegal though. There is no law in any country that specifically forbids it.

In fact there are laws that specifically allow reverse engineering for compatibility purposes and most EULA's are not worth the paper they are printed on depending on the laws of the country you are in and there are clauses in all of the EULA's that tell you this your local rights are preserved not matter what the EULA says. That said it is extremely easy to build a PC that will run OSX without any major problems you just want to choose your hardware carefully for compatibility. I did it it works well and my legally purchased copy of Leopard runs just fine on it plus I saved a **** load of money doing it.
 
Woah I never thought this was actually possible - I thought there was some special "bit" of a Mac computer's hardware that told the OS that it was actually a Macintosh. Haha but does that mean that internally there is nothing different between what's in a Mac and what's in a PC (external cosmetics notwithstanding)?
 
Woah I never thought this was actually possible - I thought there was some special "bit" of a Mac computer's hardware that told the OS that it was actually a Macintosh. Haha but does that mean that internally there is nothing different between what's in a Mac and what's in a PC (external cosmetics notwithstanding)?

Well there is it is called the EFI firmware that is used in a Mac but that is easily bypassed by the EFI bootloader that is installed which emulates the system calls from BIOS to EFI when booting then a .kext called dsmos loads that takes over when OSX is running other than that it is a pretty simple process to have it working, the components are basically the same in a Intel Mac machine vs PC and are interchangeable most times other than the logic boards/motherboards for a PC.
 
I'll do it....

I hate all the endless opinionated bickering that happens on many forums, not just this one. On a car care forum I once followed an almost endless thread about the best car wax. I bought a can of the leading contenders, applied them to different areas of different cars, kept records of ease of application, durability, and ease of maintenance. It didn’t take much money or time and I knew what wax worked best for me on my car. Knowledge trumps opinion every time!

I have a self-built PC sitting here unused.
Intel D975XBX2 motherboard
C2D E6700 CPU
4GB RAM
Western Digital Raptor and Caviar hard drives
eVGA GeForce 8800 GTS video card

If stainlessliquid will point me in the right direction (I understand that links of this sort shouldn’t be posted here), then I will do an OS X installation on my unused box - - keeping accurate and unbiased records of each step. I’ll then post a hopefully unbiased report on the experience. I’ll respond to questions for a week or so before removing OS X from the non-Apple hardware.

I have the Tiger disc that came with my Mac mini and the Leopard disk that I purchased. By buying and using these disks I’ve agreed with the limitations of Apple’s SLA. I feel morally bound to be a person of my word and comply with the SLA, however I also believe that bending the rules (and apparently also my morals) in the furtherance of knowledge brings good karma.

Knowledge is freedom!
 
I think it is fun to do it, though I have not got the chance. It cost less money, and you can even get a faster computer with osx (for example, you can use a better video card).

It is true that apple make good looking computers, but if you are willing to spend the same amount of money, you can get a nice looking pc too.
 
I tried this for a while and gave up, bout an iMAC and love it.. Really was hoping for a 2.8ghz Mini with at least a 256 3d card in it!! Come on Apple you can do this today and GROW the userbase even more!

I'd love to see you attempt something like that. At the same time, Apple will release the iGrill to place on the top of the Mini to cook on from the extra heat in such a small space.
 
Just as a sidenote for people that want to 'try' this out...

You can't just slap your OSX dvd in your PC and expect it to work. In addition to that, the online updates usually don't work and alot of the features will not work either.

Back when I looked into it when it first came out 'sound' didn't work. Heh. Anyway, there's no 'quick-fix' to get a cheap OSX computer except buying a second hand one. Yes, it's possible to load it on a custom PC (I think I stopped at 10.1.x or something) but it's not for novices. It's really for people who like to dabble, read a TON of forums, and so on.

It was too much of a pain keeping up on stuff, so I ended up snagging a new mac mini single core 1.5 from Compusa when they closed down for 300 bucks a year or two ago.

There's no free lunch.

--rob
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.