Can someone convince me it's safe to buy a MBP with non-replaceable hard drive?

Wolfpup

macrumors 68030
Original poster
Sep 7, 2006
2,768
75
ARGH! This new model is about perfect (other than the still terrible GPU), but...it still dosen't have a user replacable hard drive.

I'm worried about needing to send the system in for service, but having no way to swap the hard drive out first so no one can get hold of my personal info :(
 

shecky

Guest
May 24, 2003
2,580
3
Obviously you're not a golfer.
Wolfpup said:
ARGH! This new model is about perfect (other than the still terrible GPU), but...it still dosen't have a user replacable hard drive.
i know you are probably correct, but have we 100% confirmed this yet? i am waiting for the tech. overview PDF to be posted on apple's site.
 

Butthead

macrumors 6502
Jan 10, 2006
440
19
shecky said:
i know you are probably correct, but have we 100% confirmed this yet? i am waiting for the tech. overview PDF to be posted on apple's site.
I'm not waiting for tech overview. Apple did absolutely nothing much more than slam a C2D into the existing case, the couldn't even be bothered to upgrade the ATI x1600 GPU to it's slightly higher performing replacement that dissipates the same amount of power (no additional thermal issues).

No new engineering (unless you claim that for the MBP15in, which was rushed to market, while with time the MBP17in got the necessary additional support chip to use FW800, now that chip has been added to the MBP15in, no big engineering feat, lol) is on the minor speed bumped C2D MBPs.

Anyone who can wait, should wait for the Santa Rosa/Merom combination that is rumored to be on schedule for delivery H1 2007 (Spring, perhaps as soon as March). Expect a number of useful performance enhancments that will make the current C2D owners green with envy. No telling whether or not the HD bay will be more accessable, or even less on the Santa Rosa platform :(
 

katie ta achoo

macrumors G3
May 2, 2005
9,167
2
Wolfpup said:
I'm worried about needing to send the system in for service, but having no way to swap the hard drive out first so no one can get hold of my personal info :(
I think the tech guys have better things to do than to rifle through your hard drive.
That would also be an insane invasion of privacy, so they wouldn't do it.
Methinks you're a little too paranoid. :)
 

Sesshi

macrumors G3
Jun 3, 2006
8,113
1
One Nation Under Gordon
Butthead said:
Anyone who can wait, should wait for the Santa Rosa/Merom combination that is rumored to be on schedule for delivery H1 2007 (Spring, perhaps as soon as March). Expect a number of useful performance enhancments that will make the current C2D owners green with envy. No telling whether or not the HD bay will be more accessable, or even less on the Santa Rosa platform :(
ROFL
 

extraextra

macrumors 68000
Jun 29, 2006
1,758
0
California
Wolfpup said:
I'm worried about needing to send the system in for service, but having no way to swap the hard drive out first so no one can get hold of my personal info :(

I'm pretty sure they don't sift through your HD when they have other computers to fix.

Unless, you have files that look suspiciously like pornos. Lol. They might take a peek then. ;)
 

matperk

macrumors 6502
May 6, 2004
443
0
Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Butthead said:
Anyone who can wait, should wait for the Santa Rosa/Merom combination that is rumored to be on schedule for delivery H1 2007 (Spring, perhaps as soon as March). Expect a number of useful performance enhancments that will make the current C2D owners green with envy. No telling whether or not the HD bay will be more accessable, or even less on the Santa Rosa platform :(
And it begins again.
 

ZooWall

macrumors newbie
Oct 19, 2006
5
0
OKC
Get an external.

Why don't you just get an external hard drive for any info you want to keep safe?
 

Russ-ST24

macrumors newbie
Oct 24, 2006
1
0
Hi,
I just upgraded my internal HD on my MBP to 160GB. I know it is "not user upgradable" but it was really easy when I watched the video on the internet of someone doing it.

http://media.macsales.com/medres.html

You only need one special screwdriver which is cheap.
Also during the whole thing there is no way apple would know I have been inside as there are no warranty seals to break. So the way I look at it that should I need service under applecare I will just put my original 80Gb back in with a clean OSX install and send it off.
The whole HD swap only took about 45 mins and that was being VERY carefull.
I must say that without the above video I dont think I would have been brave enough!
But now I have 20GB for Windows XP and the rest for OSX! Nice. 80Gb was a little low to be honest with iTunes and video etc all together.

Hope this helps.

Russ
 

Wolfpup

macrumors 68030
Original poster
Sep 7, 2006
2,768
75
ZooWall said:
Why don't you just get an external hard drive for any info you want to keep safe?
Sort of an option, except stuff could still be cached on your internal drive...hmm, I guess technically I could use my old iPod for stuff...

Here's some more questions-

-Does OS X support encrypting your home files? I thought that was a feature that got added some time. If it does, is it risky? Does it hurt performance, and would it actually protect your stuff from prying techs?

-Is there method of doing a "secure wipe" on an entire hard drive on a Macbook Pro? Of course that assumes the system is working well enough to run the wipe...
 

Wolfpup

macrumors 68030
Original poster
Sep 7, 2006
2,768
75
Russ-ST24 said:
Hi,
I just upgraded my internal HD on my MBP to 160GB. I know it is "not user upgradable" but it was really easy when I watched the video on the internet of someone doing it.

http://media.macsales.com/medres.html

You only need one special screwdriver which is cheap.
Also during the whole thing there is no way apple would know I have been inside as there are no warranty seals to break. So the way I look at it that should I need service under applecare I will just put my original 80Gb back in with a clean OSX install and send it off.
The whole HD swap only took about 45 mins and that was being VERY carefull.
I must say that without the above video I dont think I would have been brave enough!
But now I have 20GB for Windows XP and the rest for OSX! Nice. 80Gb was a little low to be honest with iTunes and video etc all together.

Hope this helps.

Russ
Thanks for the video. Unfortunatly it looks like a little too much of an art than a science for my taste. (I don't think I have a torx screwdriver either, though I suppose they sell them somewhere.)
 

Sayer

macrumors 6502a
Jan 4, 2002
981
0
Austin, TX
If you dont want someone to see your collection of PORN then use FileVault.

Oftentimes the techs wipe the HD anyway, so I don't think they will care what is on your HD if you actually have to "send it in."
 

gnasher729

Suspended
Nov 25, 2005
16,844
3,678
Wolfpup said:
-Does OS X support encrypting your home files? I thought that was a feature that got added some time. If it does, is it risky? Does it hurt performance, and would it actually protect your stuff from prying techs?

-Is there method of doing a "secure wipe" on an entire hard drive on a Macbook Pro? Of course that assumes the system is working well enough to run the wipe...
Have you ever used MacOS X?
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.