Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Candyshell or Otterbox Defender?

A

AdventurousJosh

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Aug 11, 2008
300
19
Hey guys,
Just bought an iPhone 4 and dont know what case to buy. I'm having a hard time choosing between the white Candyshell speck case or the black/white Otterbox defender.
Which do you guys prefer?

Also I've read about dust getting inside the botterbox case and then causing it to scratch the screen. If you recommend the otterbox, do you recommend I use a screen protecter under the case? or will the screen be too unresponsive?

Thanks,


Josh

http://www.amazon.com/Speck-Products-CandyShell-Moonsicle-Charcoal/dp/B003TO53WY

http://www.otterbox.com/iPhone-4-De...XX_color=20&start=1&cgid=apple-iphone-4-cases
 
As an Amazon Associate, MacRumors earns a commission from qualifying purchases made through links in this post.
Kusuri said:
Hey guys,
Just bought an iPhone 4 and dont know what case to buy. I'm having a hard time choosing between the white Candyshell speck case or the black/white Otterbox defender.
Which do you guys prefer?

Also I've read about dust getting inside the botterbox case and then causing it to scratch the screen. If you recommend the otterbox, do you recommend I use a screen protecter under the case? or will the screen be too unresponsive?

Thanks,


Josh

http://www.amazon.com/Speck-Products-CandyShell-Moonsicle-Charcoal/dp/B003TO53WY

http://www.otterbox.com/iPhone-4-De...XX_color=20&start=1&cgid=apple-iphone-4-cases
Click to expand...

The recommendation with the Otterbox is to pop out their membrane/screen protector and use your own screen protector. And yes, the dust getting underneath and scratching the screen is true. I have an iPhone 4 with so-called Gorilla Glass. The pit/scratch is small, but noticeable. Also, the retina display is severely hindered by the protector, but if you need the protection, its hard to beat.
 
As an Amazon Associate, MacRumors earns a commission from qualifying purchases made through links in this post.
jbachandouris said:
The recommendation with the Otterbox is to pop out their membrane/screen protector and use your own screen protector. And yes, the dust getting underneath and scratching the screen is true. I have an iPhone 4 with so-called Gorilla Glass. The pit/scratch is small, but noticeable. Also, the retina display is severely hindered by the protector, but if you need the protection, its hard to beat.
Click to expand...

Could I put the Otterbox's screen protector with my current screen protector under it? I also have a PS Crystal on the back so it might be a tight fit? I would hate that cause I want everything to fit right and not put pressure on the phone.
 
in0va3 said:
Could I put the Otterbox's screen protector with my current screen protector under it? I also have a PS Crystal on the back so it might be a tight fit? I would hate that cause I want everything to fit right and not put pressure on the phone.
Click to expand...

The fit would be good, but you probably will lose the beauty of the retina display. Protection-wise that would be excellent.
 
Jonathan360 said:
What are you talking about? I know it was your opinion, I was agreeing with you ;)
Click to expand...
I know. But you said it was "really personal preference" after I put IMO. I was just confused. :)

My friend has a CandyShell for his iPT, it looks pretty good. Not much more thickness, pretty good looking, but the dock piece is breaking off. I'm not sure if that's all the cases or his fault though.
 
Candyshell any day. Looks great, has a good level of protection and its stylish. I have both too. I ended up taking off the built in screen shield on the Defender, and now its like 10x better since the screen looks as it should and you don't have to worry about dust getting between the screen and membrane.
 
Kusuri said:
Thats good news.
I know both cases are thick, but how much thinner is the candyshell over the otterbox? noticeably or barely?
Click to expand...

Honestly man probably not by much but the candyshell will get the job done in style. Otterbox is just a huge bulky case IMO. If you really want an otterbox case, go with the commuter, it would be my
Second choice after the candyshell.
 
I have the Candyshell with the Otterbox Defender on its way. The Candyshell is pretty good in terms of protection. It's probably a little thicker than most of the silicone/slim cases out there but nothing I would call overly bulky. Overall it's a great case however taking the phone in/out of the Candyshell can be quite a pain. Currently I'm using a bumper with the Candyshell as backup, as well as Seidio case and another bumper as backups for my backup. The OB Defender will primarily be used for whenever I'm traveling or need that extra little bit of protection for my phone. I think you're good to go either way but if you want good protection with not too much bulk, the Candyshell or an OB Impact might be what you want to look into.
 
totally guys, I like the handyshell I'm just a bit concerned how my phone will look after my first real drop, you know? and I have a problem with otterbox cause I really dont want to have to bust out the screen protector on it to decrease the chances of scratches.

hmmm
 
Kusuri said:
totally guys, I like the handyshell I'm just a bit concerned how my phone will look after my first real drop, you know? and I have a problem with otterbox cause I really dont want to have to bust out the screen protector on it to decrease the chances of scratches.

hmmm
Click to expand...

You may also want to take a look at the Otterbox Commuter which is a nice medium between the Candyshell & Defender.
 
Otterbox is hideous. Only reason I would rock it is for pure necessity - like if I worked at a construction site or spend a lot of time trekking the outdoors.
 
Kusuri said:
Ugh i still cant decide!
Will the cadyshell protect it will if I drop my iPhone 4?
Click to expand...
It should. The silicone and plastic mix should help absorb shock, and so should the silicone on every edge.
mrkjsn said:
Otterbox is hideous. Only reason I would rock it is for pure necessity - like if I worked at a construction site or spend a lot of time trekking the outdoors.
Click to expand...
That's what this is for! :D

3183.jpg

Kusuri said:
totally guys, I like the handyshell I'm just a bit concerned how my phone will look after my first real drop, you know? and I have a problem with otterbox cause I really dont want to have to bust out the screen protector on it to decrease the chances of scratches.

hmmm
Click to expand...
It should be fine. It actually should absorb shock more than the Otterbox, actually.
 
Otterbox .. you can get one off ebay for chump change now. :D Aweome case though, very purpose built
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back