Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Having good signal strength does not equal good bandwidth, esp in theme parks or crowded areas.
I was at one of my Doctors yesterday, and every time I visit them I am noticing that I have 2-3 bars and sometimes I can reach websites easily and then can't connect for like 2-3 min any website at all. This is on my phone.
Who is your provider?
AT&T... but during the instances in question, it wasn't even a matter of slow performance, the watch simply indicated that it was not using LTE service at all (the Control Center icon wasn't showing the typical green "LTE").
 
AT&T... but during the instances in question, it wasn't even a matter of slow performance, the watch simply indicated that it was not using LTE service at all (the Control Center icon wasn't showing the typical green "LTE").
In those cases, the watch was probably connected to wifi or your phone. I would almost bet $ on the phone. This is what I mentioned earlier. The watch is really aggressive at holding on to the phone if it can. LTE is only used as a last resort. If it's not showing, then some other connection (bluetooth or wifi) was engaged.

I've had that happen lots of times, and the problem for me is almost always that it's holding on to the phone connection but the connection is so faint that it's not usable. I'm guessing that this is what happened to your watch.
 
I use my Ultra2 on cellular just when I went out for running. Used it sometimes also at the beach, when I had to be reachable for calls from residents.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BillGates1969
For me, it would be more than a $10 bump, since I'm on AT&T and would need to move from Prepaid to Postpaid to get Apple Watch support. (plus my current Apple watch isn't a cellular model, but we're talking hypothetically here). Like you, I can't think of a compelling use case for cellular, and like you, $5/month is approximately the price point where I'd opt for it despite the limited use I'd have for it.
Same here. Not giving up $25 per month prepaid ATT service so I can have my cellular AW activated. I have owned many Apple Watches and never activated any of them. I always carry my phone with me so not much need.

You better pray you never need AT&T’s customer service because it plain sucks!
 
In those cases, the watch was probably connected to wifi or your phone. I would almost bet $ on the phone. This is what I mentioned earlier. The watch is really aggressive at holding on to the phone if it can. LTE is only used as a last resort. If it's not showing, then some other connection (bluetooth or wifi) was engaged.
That's a possibility... I think I was far enough away from the phone (plus the phone was encased in a metal locker), but I can't say for certain.
 
i pay around 4$(exchange rate) a month here in turkey 🇹🇷 , on ultra2 a few months ago this was beneficial after an earthquake 6.2 i was unable to get my iphone upstairs before rapidly leaving home due to the aftershocks i spent nearly two days 2km away camped in an open field due to the continuous aftershocks without iPhone nearby or in range, i was fully reachable and able to make calls answer sms etc on watch with cellular plan . on return to home iPhone battery had depleted so awu2 on cellular is a benefit just never know when you might need it . also regularly go for a walking workout without iphone . always reachable
 
  • Like
Reactions: arc of the universe
$10 / month on Visible using VZW.

Love cellular for those times I forget my wallet and phone.

Tap and pay, make calls, send text messages without WiFi.
 
Through the years I've owned several cellular Apple Watches, but I've never activated the service... if it were $5/month, I'd probably do it without giving it much thought, but at $10/month I feel like I have to have a more compelling need for it. At the root of my case for not paying extra for this is the fact that I never leave the house without my phone. If I were a jogger, I could see not bringing my phone, but I go biking instead, and it's not an encumbrance to have my phone on my belt (I don't wear cycling-specific clothing).

I think the only times I've ever found myself thinking "gee, I wish I had cellular service on my watch" are when I'm standing in line at Universal Orlando, where there are metal detectors at the big roller coasters and you have to put your stuff in a locker (including your phone). Similarly, I wouldn't mind having it when at a water park. But both of these instances occur only maybe once every two years or so.

Beyond that, the only other justification I can come up with is for emergencies... being able to still get in touch with people if my phone is lost or stolen, or dies.

Is there any other scenario that I may be missing in which a cellular-activated watch would be useful?
Having Cell on a Apple watch was kool when I had it several years ago but now no longer need it why? There is thing called Wifi Calling such which I use frequently when my phone is left at home....for instance when I connect my watch at the following but I will name a few: Wallmart, Publix (supermarket), the Mall, Panera Bread, Winn Dixie, La Fitness...it basically allows me to connect my watch to their wifi and then it allows me to make calls like I'm using cellular all for free.
 
  • Like
Reactions: drrich2
I ditched cell service on my watch only because of wifi calling...example if I dont have my phone and need to make a call I just walk in any place that has wifi for the public and I just make my call....all free
 
I ditched cell service on my watch only because of wifi calling...example if I dont have my phone and need to make a call I just walk in any place that has wifi for the public and I just make my call....all free
Yes in urban areas, wifi calling works.

But where I go - remote areas and / or high altitude terrain it does not.

I have both an iPad Mini w/ cellular and AW w/ cellular for my flight missions as a small plane private pilot. They are crucial for GPS and in flight use.

For an emergency, my iPhone with satellite plus portable 2 way air band radio and hopefully this year with the new satellite message AW will complete my flight bag.
 
Through the years I've owned several cellular Apple Watches, but I've never activated the service... if it were $5/month, I'd probably do it without giving it much thought, but at $10/month I feel like I have to have a more compelling need for it. At the root of my case for not paying extra for this is the fact that I never leave the house without my phone. If I were a jogger, I could see not bringing my phone, but I go biking instead, and it's not an encumbrance to have my phone on my belt (I don't wear cycling-specific clothing).

I think the only times I've ever found myself thinking "gee, I wish I had cellular service on my watch" are when I'm standing in line at Universal Orlando, where there are metal detectors at the big roller coasters and you have to put your stuff in a locker (including your phone). Similarly, I wouldn't mind having it when at a water park. But both of these instances occur only maybe once every two years or so.

Beyond that, the only other justification I can come up with is for emergencies... being able to still get in touch with people if my phone is lost or stolen, or dies.

Is there any other scenario that I may be missing in which a cellular-activated watch would be useful?
"I've fallen and I can't get up..."
 
I'm on my fourth AW and consider it one of Apple's very best achievements. Thus far I have managed to avoid cellular. I simply can't come up with a good reason to have one, even if it was only $5/month.

On only two occasions over the past 10 years, I've left my phone behind. The second time was a couple of years ago; I learned then that I can use Apple Pay without having my iPhone present. Who knew?

I simply always have it with me. It's not a difficult thing to do.

I suppose if I had a plus size phone, perhaps I'd consider it more of an inconvenience to carry. Maybe.

My preference is to have a readable screen available in case I need to respond with more than a few words to a text or an email. Or look at a map. Or look at a website. And so forth.
Other than going into a restricted area, such as a courthouse, I always have my phone and my watch with me.
 
I'm on my fourth AW and consider it one of Apple's very best achievements. Thus far I have managed to avoid cellular. I simply can't come up with a good reason to have one, even if it was only $5/month.

On only two occasions over the past 10 years, I've left my phone behind. The second time was a couple of years ago; I learned then that I can use Apple Pay without having my iPhone present. Who knew?

I simply always have it with me. It's not a difficult thing to do.

I suppose if I had a plus size phone, perhaps I'd consider it more of an inconvenience to carry. Maybe.

My preference is to have a readable screen available in case I need to respond with more than a few words to a text or an email. Or look at a map. Or look at a website. And so forth.
Other than going into a restricted area, such as a courthouse, I always have my phone and my watch with me.
Yah, I'll bet that if someone took a poll, the vast majority of cellular watch users would be athletes that primarily want the cellular for outdoor activities (running/ swimming/ cycling, hiking, etc), and people who are on call & don't want to carry 2 phones. If I wasn't in the former group, I would probably drop the cellular, but it's so nice to not have to bring my phone running, cycling, or hiking.

I also find that I use it other times, and find that convenient as well, but not convenient enough to pay $16/month for it.
 
i pay around 4$(exchange rate) a month here in turkey 🇹🇷 , on ultra2 a few months ago this was beneficial after an earthquake 6.2 i was unable to get my iphone upstairs before rapidly leaving home due to the aftershocks i spent nearly two days 2km away camped in an open field due to the continuous aftershocks without iPhone nearby or in range, i was fully reachable and able to make calls answer sms etc on watch with cellular plan . on return to home iPhone battery had depleted so awu2 on cellular is a benefit just never know when you might need it . also regularly go for a walking workout without iphone . always reachable
In your case its a good idea to have cellular in my case in central florida I am surrounded with wifi
 
  • Like
Reactions: weather34
yes for me unfortunately its a good option living some 5km from a very active fault line . at less than 4$ a month its a bonus wether i use it regularly or emergencies. i understand its not a cheap option in USA from what i read on this forum.
 
Me too, since changing my EE contract a few months ago (cheaper than my old plan, with better benefits including watch data for no extra cost).

I've had Watches since Series Zero but only tried a cellular model one year, during which I only used the cellular connection once. Now that my cellular plan includes Watch data for no extra charge I'll probably get a Watch with cellular this year though.

I also read that EE seem to have been quietly upgrading their network for 5G RedCap for the past year, so hopefully that will launch along with new Watches which support it...
 
I also read that EE seem to have been quietly upgrading their network for 5G RedCap for the past year, so hopefully that will launch along with new Watches which support it.
I see that AT&T announced nationwide 5G RedCap coverage in the USA in July, which is probably necessary for the Series 11 to support 5G RedCap...
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: mk313
had cellular since I got my S4 SBSS so almost 5 years now and never activated it for the same reasons, always have my iPhone with me when leaving the house.
I have yet to come up with a usage scenario for me ...
and the good news for those in the US (don't remember all the other countries this applies) - you can dial 911 on an unactivated cellular device.

why do you buy the more expensive cellular version if you have no intention of using it?
 
Me too, sapphire glass is a must-have, also the ability of the watch to call emergency services in the event of a crash or hard fall, a feature which works even without an active cellular plan.
I smashed my S0, totally broke the ions and the watch was renedered useless even though the screen was still working, my S3 had quite a few scratches from mountain biking, then started to get sapphire and never a problem anymore.
And yes, the emergency calling feature would have been handy when I crashed mountain biking in 2013 and broke my femur ;)
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.