Haha the irony of it. Mac die hards constantly putting down M Powered iPads with iPad OS 26 “trying to be like a Mac”, and here we have a Macbook trying to be like an iPad
.
Last edited:
You're not touching the screen, you're touching a glass digitizer laid over the screen.Using this would be a pretty bad idea as MacBook screen coatings aren’t engineered for touch and would wear poorly.
He also said iPhone's display wasn't supposed to be bigger than 4" because that's about where your thumb can reach and look at phones now.
It’s all a matter of perspective. For those who grew up without touchscreens the idea of a Mac with touchscreen is repulsive. For those who grew up with iPhones, touch screens, it’s incomprehensible why the screen is not touch. I have lost count how many times i have seen my wife try to use touch screens movements on laptops. My toddler son always tries to touch the screen on MacBook Pro. It feels inevitable that touchscreens will come to mac laptops.In principle, a touch screen on Mac just does not make sense. But if a possible touchscreen Macbook brings with it a coating that's easier to keep free of smudges than the current ones, then I'm willing to welcome it, no matter how hesitantly.
I think the iPad makes sense as a touchscreen device because you can lay it flat or hold it in your hands at a natural writing angle. But you can't do that with a laptop at all (unless, as you say, it folds backwards) which makes it pretty awful to reach up and interact with for any length of time.And still shown being used by a finger with an outstretched arm. If you want your biceps and triceps to get super ripped from resistance training, this would be one way to do it.
I'm still torn on whether a touch screen Mac is a good idea or not, but if it is, it has to fold all the way back. Which is one of the things I don't like about it.
He wasn't wrong about that. The big tell for iPhones getting too big to use one-handed was when they released that corny "reachability" feature that slides the whole display down halfway so you can reach the top.He also said iPhone's display wasn't supposed to be bigger than 4" because that's about where your thumb can reach and look at phones now.
I'm afraid that ship has sailed. MacOS has been getting sloppy seconds from the iPhone and iPad for some time now, and it only seems to be getting worse. And I don't mean from third-party app developers, but from Apple themselves: apps like Messages and System Settings and Weather are limited to basically the same sh*tty "universal" (aka lowest common denominator) layout they have on the iPad.They are two different platforms and should be treated differently. I'm afraid this is just going to encourage everything to be a low hanging iPad app when the Mac would allow it to be so much better than that constrained platform.
Agreed, for whomever has tried this on a windows notebook, it doesn't work.. First thing I disable on my work notebook. The physics don't work at all... Flipping it all the way back like you said, is the only way it could prove useful.. Still the UI isn't optimized for fingers..And still shown being used by a finger with an outstretched arm. If you want your biceps and triceps to get super ripped from resistance training, this would be one way to do it.
I'm still torn on whether a touch screen Mac is a good idea or not, but if it is, it has to fold all the way back. Which is one of the things I don't like about it.
I agree with this take. I can't see Apple doing a touchscreen Mac anytime soon because it virtually renders the iPad irrelevant. I love the form factor of my Surface Laptop Studio 2.Apple is weird about Pencil support across the board. Which is also one reason I doubt touch screen Macs. They are very protectionist about the iPad since there are in reality so very few things it is uniquely good at. So they add Pencil support as an artificial one.
You might not want to use it, but others will. Wacom, a publicly traded company, had been selling hardware, appealing to this crowd for over 4 decades. Last fiscal year their revenue was € 610 / $ 713 million.But why would you want to? A mobile iOS "app" is a mere shadow of full fledged applications on MacOS. I don't see the point myself unless it was some casual game.
I would not use it for macOS. A combination with a pressure sensitive stylus in Affinity / Photoshop / etc is where this shines. Not when dragging files around or copying folders.Agreed, for whomever has tried this on a windows notebook, it doesn't work.. First thing I disable on my work notebook. The physics don't work at all... Flipping it all the way back like you said, is the only way it could prove useful.. Still the UI isn't optimized for fingers..
..or fold forward, which I prefer:I'm still torn on whether a touch screen Mac is a good idea or not, but if it is, it has to fold all the way back.
..or fold forward, which I prefer:
View attachment 2593721
I've been using the pictured device (Surface Laptop Studio) for the past several years, and I'd say it's durable. I don't treat it any different than my MacBook Pro anyway, and it hasn't had any damage.Better, but I still can't help but think it looks strange and fragile.
And I've used tons of Surfaces which this looks very much like, and it's not fun. The OS is not designed for touch, even though they retconned touch in there so that it is technically now designed for touch.
But it's still too much like good old wince.
You might not want to use it, but others will. Wacom, a publicly traded company, had been selling hardware, appealing to this crowd for over 4 decades. Last fiscal year their revenue was € 610 / $ 713 million.
More affordable than an iPad plus Apple Pencil. It can also be detached and used as a Wacom.I am sure that all 5 people who will buy this will enjoy it.
He was right if we only consider one-hand use and ergonomics is your top priority. So... he was wrong, most of us just use their phone with two hands and we're fine. Using the keyboard with one hand has never been optimal ergonomics anyway.He wasn't wrong about that. The big tell for iPhones getting too big to use one-handed was when they released that corny "reachability" feature that slides the whole display down halfway so you can reach the top.
The best selling iPhones (and among the best selling models ever) are iPhone 6 and 6 Plus followed by 6S and 6S plus. As if everybody was waiting for iPhones to catch up with other phones' size. So yours is just a personal opinion.Another example of SG's correctness. Phablets are a blight.