I realise I have been making a rather naive mistake in presenting and discussing my test results so far. My results make more sense to me now.
Because every battery of this type I have ever used before has been a 5V device I have been treating mAh numbers as a measure of battery capacity, which is what the manufacturers do e.g. "26800 mAh" "20100 mAh". However these only express the current and time it can supply
at 5V.
Current x time (mAh) is
not battery capacity. Battery capacity is correctly expressed as watt-hour, or current x voltage x time.
This explains why my Satechi USB power meter records the following to fully charge a flat RavPower:-
20,461 mAh at 5V equals 102 Wh
(this is a correction to initial post, used wrong # from table)
6,700 mAh at 15V (Apple charger) equals 100 Wh
4,950 mAh at 20V (RavPower charger) equals 99 Wh
It also makes sense of the regular USB-A charging compared to the USB-PD:
10-100% used 10130mAh at 5V equals 51 Wh,
plus 10-61% used 5097mAh at 5V equals 25 Wh.
Total delivered by one full RavPower by USB-A equals 76 Wh
0-100% used 4390 mAh at 15V equals 66 Wh with a bit left over, so similar to USB-A result.
The MacBook battery is 39.7 Watt-hour (e.g.
here) compared with 99.16 Watt-hour for the RavPower. With a typical 60% transfer efficiency that means the usable capacity of the RavPower is about 60 watt-hour, 1.5x the MacBook's watt-hour. This is close to the 1.3x you found on the website, and closer to my experience, and about the same as I found with regular USB-A (5V) charging.
I am not sure what voltage the Coconut values are, e.g. the nominal capacity is expressed as 5550 mAh. Comparing this with the 4390 mAh at 15V which it took to charge my 90% health MacBook, the Coconut figures seem consistent with the USB-PD 15V numbers.
I understand why mAh is widely used to express battery capacity, and the manufacturers do it to be able to quote nice big numbers, but it is misleading when different voltages are involved.
Apologies if you were ahead of me in this mAh vs Wh at different voltages issue! Allowing for a bit of experimental error and variability my results all make more sense to me when expressed in terms of Watt-hours.
BTW:-
-The RavPower charged from flat to full in exactly 4 hours using the Apple charger (15V).
-Using the RavPower in USB-PD top up mode yesterday it lasted about 5h45m before being flat. At the end the MacBook was still at 100%. The MacBook had been on continuously (no machine or screen sleep) in that period and in use for most of it including some Photos and Lightroom and Parallels VM work.
- Three more connections of the RavPower without need to reverse the current.
I have edited the above quite a bit since original post.