Just did some testing with it, and TBH it's a pretty garbage app. All channels except premium channels run at 720 30fps with an average bitrate of 3.5mbps and tinny 96kbps stereo audio, even sports channels, which don't look good at all. The only exception to that is premium channels like HBO and Showtime which stream at 720p 60fps with 5.3mbps average bitrate, still the same garbage 96kbps stereo audio though. Even on demand content runs at 720p max. Scrolling in the guide is really laggy and weird as well. And to top it all off, it seems to be doing some weird HDCP re-auth every time you load the guide or one of the different main menu tabs, which can cause a short black screen with some equipment. The only real nice thing about it is the zero sign-on works really well.
Yes. Unfortunately this is the case with most of the TV channel apps on the Apple TV and other streaming boxes. Certain channels have noticeably higher bitrates on their DVRs as well with CBS, NBC, ESPN, CNN, MSNBC, HBO, Showtime looking much better than everything else. It also depends on source quality and special live events.
720p can still look OK on 4K sets but not low bitrate 720p. It now looks as bad as 480p did on 1080p sets.
For me the Spectrum app just can’t replace the DVR for two reasons:
1. 1080i for most channels and 720p for ABC, ESPN and Fox. 720p is just not good enough especially on my LG C8. In fact even on the DVR, Netflix and Amazon 1080p compression puts cable/sat broadcast to shame. It’s about TV goes internet only. You really only need 5 Mbps for good quality H.264 1080p video. Still 1080i is 1080i and it will look much sharper than 720p except with the fastest of content.
I guess this will be impossible until every home in America has access to broadband. Unfortunately there are still too many rural areas still living with late 90s/early 2000s tech and that is unacceptable nearly 20 years later when 200-300 Mbps is becoming the norm in metropolitan areas.
2. Real 5.1 sound. I have an actual amp with great speakers and anything that doesn’t have at 5.1 DD (when it exists of course) is a major deal breaker. This is also why the ATV isn’t good enough for anything but Netflix, Amazon and YouTube. Cable/sat has had standard Dolby Digital 5.1 for well over a decade now. Even at 256-384 kbps it still provides an immersive experience and a must when watching HBO and AMC shows.
iTunes, Netflix and Amazon will NEVER have lossless 18 Mbps Dolby TrueHD/Dolby Atmos, DTS HD Master/DTS:X and that is unacceptable. Once you are used to quality sound you can’t accept mediocre DD+ or worse, 2 channel stereo or 2.1.
Many folks using stuff like Sonos and other sound bars may be happy with DD 5.1/DD+ but that’s only because they haven’t experienced anything better.
I also tried the Spectrum app on my Xbox One X and it’s the same crap. Stereo sound and subpar video quality. It’s fine for avoiding extra DVR fees on a 2nd or 3rd TV but not for primary use.