For me, the few conveniences that AI could bring to my life do not outweigh the cons that the march of technology are unleashing on the environment, society and individuals. Further, and more importantly, I would argue whether they are conveniences in the long run, I am not a proponent of "cognitive offloading" of small tasks, which I think are beneficial to our learning and psyche, building new pathways of thinking, building various psychological resiliences and opening room for meditative time in your day to day life.
I don't use any of it and have drawn my line with technology. At this point, with the experiences, perspective and knowledge that I have now, I wish I had drawn that line when the smartphone came out, and then again when social media started taking the shape of Facebook and then Instagram. Won't make the same mistake again with this next wave of "innovation", none of which has the best interests of people or the planet in mind, only capital. A life intertwined with capitalism, consumerism and warped views of "productivity" is one I would prefer to distance myself from.
You’ve posted so many excellent points that I’m not sure where to jump in.
I’ve enjoyed reading your viewpoints. I also try to look at technology in the larger context.
I think George Will made a point on a news program at least 20 years ago basically saying how interesting it is that people have so much time-saving technology but the real question is what will they do with that time.
I had my first computer in 1978 and now enjoy my Vision Pro. Needless to say, I love this stuff.
Many of my friends and I are all software engineers. We all love technology.
One friend in particular is of the opinion that life would be better if he didn’t have to do anything that interferes with what he enjoys doing. Even though I love technology, I feel like we are wired to do things for ourselves. I remember Bill Gates once saying he does washes dishes by hand just to enjoy the feeling of accomplishment and the simplicity of the chore. I enjoy detailing my car. I don’t mind cleaning the house. Both give me time to think about things and just relax.
With AI I’ve noticed a break with several of my tech friends. They seem to embrace it whereas I’m pretty cool to all of it. I find it hard to trust answers when hallucinations is a known issue. I hope there are no people who post what a chat bot told them as facts. My grammar is decent enough that I don’t feel the need to check it. I don’t want to summarize a text or email from a friend or anyone else frankly. What if the summary misses the key point? With all that in mind, data centers are now ubiquitous and growing just to support the technology.
When I see people obsess about what someone said on social media while scrolling endlessly on their screen, it gives me pause. It’s not the technology I imagined as a kid. I see a sharp contrast with things like social media and chat bots with older technology like GPS, microwave ovens and yes cell phones. For me, much of the technology was a clear win. It made something better. It had a defined purpose. I just see some of the recent technology as having larger and more obvious downsides.
I’m still optimistic. But where I used to look at technology as the answer, I now feel like reverting to older ways in a targeted manner would be an improvement. I make a point of calling friends or better yet meeting them for a cup of coffee or a bite to eat. To me this is much more satisfying than looking at their trip photos on Facebook. I still write and read my own emails to friends. I don’t use any Meta products.
Apologies for conflating ChatGPT with other more recent technology. I just see the chat bots and AI in general as yet another technology with so many problems and not a clear benefit.