I would choose Herschel Little America, it’s not too afordable, but durable as heck.
I beg to differ. I bought the "Apple Store exclusive" Herschel Little America in Jan 2016 and the two main leather straps (with the magnetic clips) have started to break into two pieces. They're literally being held together by the top layer of fabric.
Is there any way that Apple would refund this as it is definitely not wear and tear and a manufacturing defect.