Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Keep in mind that not all of us who want to screenshot or save your photos are trying to steal them to distribute elsewhere. Some of us just like something we see, and want to save a local copy for ourselves because the Internet is ephemeral and the things we find and love there won't be around forever.

I've saved countless photos, archives of web pages and so on because they touched me in some way and I never want to lose the ability to see them. We are slowly losing that as companies put in technological measures to keep us from saving content; look at the hacks necessary to save from Instagram and Snapchat.

Agreed..sometimes it just makes cool wallpaper. I do respect copyrighted material though so I can see both sides. Not a fan of this being added to apps if this removes a function of my phone. I would delete the app if a dev added this to an app.
 
Do you remember TC stating years ago Apple was going to make iOS more open. Apart from the File app, it seems more closed than ever, now this.
 
I think this is probably meant more for apps that have copyrighted material. Would be great for photography apps. The iPhone X display is such high resolution that you can take a screenshot of someone’s photo, crop it, and republish it as your own. As a photographer I hate watermarking things but I’ve also seen my work stolen before. If an app doesn’t have APIs or a web view then this could effectively prevent copying photos because a photo of a display will look far worse when uploaded.

Why take a screenshot when you can browse the app's source to get the original images in their glorious full resolution......
 
Last edited:
Vote with your e-feet, folks. Don't download apps that block screenshots.

If this "feature" is added to an app that I already have, I'll give it a bad review.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tzm41
Cool..

With the inbuilt camera, or anything on the phone, the app can block it in code.. but what if you recording the phone with a separate camera with no cables attached to a phone at all? not attached in any way?

Unless the app in smart enough to "know" i am being recorded by something other than something that is attached/connected.

More likely its probably designed to "assist" with prevention, not meant to be 100%

I mean, websites can easily block you from viewing their source code, but i'm sure there would be ways to get around it.
 
Doesn't entirely matter what it's "meant" for -- it could easily be used to just keep the user controlled and unable to share except through a developer's "official" channels. Shazam, which begs you every time you take a screenshot to instead share and save recognized tracks using its ad-encrusted interface, comes to mind.
Well, if those apps use it and users get upset, tell them and rate the app poorly. They will adjust or fail as a business. I don't see what the problem is here.
 
Well, if those apps use it and users get upset, tell them and rate the app poorly. They will adjust or fail as a business. I don't see what the problem is here.

I don't really this feature as bad added to the app... How many are that concerned with taking screenshots when they just wish to use an app ? If i wanna use Facebook, why would i wanna take a screenshot of it, when someone else can install the same app ?

It would have an effect not being able to share screenshots, recordings etc, but i don't believe the % would be that high
 
Why take a screenshot when you can browse the app's source to get the original images in their glorious full resolution......
Most people dumb enough to steal copyrighted photos to pass off as their own or to use for whatever commercial purpose that they don't have a license to will not go to such lengths. Also with a photo stream on something like Instagram with a bunch of <1MB images it might all just be stored and eventually purged from memory as it runs. Not sure. I know in our app we used an open source caching mechanism because our use case was different and we needed to optimize load time for a slowish server with content that didn't update rapidly. But that was basically a side feature, a front-end for our crappy non-mobile optimized website which I finally redesigned last year after inheriting it a few years before that.
 
I hope Apple doesn't approve this. I should be able to take screenshots on my own device. Like someone else already mentioned, I will delete any app that adds this "feature."
 
I don't really this feature as bad added to the app... How many are that concerned with taking screenshots when they just wish to use an app ? If i wanna use Facebook, why would i wanna take a screenshot of it, when someone else can install the same app ?

It would have an effect not being able to share screenshots, recordings etc, but i don't believe the % would be that high
Social networks want to be protective of their content. They sometimes want to make it more difficult to put their content on another platform. They would rather people link to their platform instead. In your example, someone might screenshot the image and then crop it and post it on Twitter. Instead they would rather that person tweet a link to a FaceBook post so they can sell ad impressions.

I'm not arguing this example is a good idea, but it's a valid example of why a company would implement this.
 
Seriously, guys? Somebody sends you a message with a 4 second timer, and you’ll be ready with your camera and/or second phone to capture that glorious sext forever? :rolleyes:


Upset people: this is for a secure messaging app. The point is to prevent screen captures of sexting not take away your constitutional freedoms. :rolleyes:

MUH FREEDUMS
 
Great, so an app can now keep the device owner from creating screen grabs on the device they own? I certainly hope this is completely user configurable, otherwise it is a complete fail.

I hope Apple has the good sense to block any app using this from the app store.
 
Geez, I wanna see the API that stops you from picking up a camera or another phone and take screen shot :)
 
Geez, I wanna see the API that stops you from picking up a camera or another phone and take screen shot :)
It relies on the cameras that are already all over our cities, watching us whenever we are in public. And at home it turns on the cameras in your computers and tablets to watch what you are doing with your phone. If it sees you reaching for the screenshot combination of buttons, it signals the app to blank out the display. Nothing to it! ;)
 
Apple will not allow this. There is a restrictions PLIST value that blocks screenshots and screen recordings installable via configuration profile. Apple would make an API available that does this on an app level instead of system level if they want to allow it.

Now if Confide wants to allow this only in their app, then it’s no big deal.
 
What a useless and malfeasant piece of crap software. As soon as I encounter a app that uses this technology I make sure to take a extra portion of screenshot with a secondary device and spread them over the internet.

If they go on with this crap jailbreaking might become interesting again.
 
So I can use someone else phone to take a photo or stick my phone on copier. You can't stop people from screen capturing.
Apparently, the company is also coming up with a way to prevent the contents on the screen from being photographed by another camera as well.

https://daringfireball.net/2018/01/screenshield

If I’m reading their application correctly, Confide also has also filed for a patent for a way to identify when you’re using another device to take a photo of your screen.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.