Have an annoying bug that Apple denies as being a bug.
Bug involves Safari + YouTube (FullScreen mode).
Basically:
1. Run Safari in Mavericks
2. Open YouTube
3. Run any video using the YouTube Full Screen mode
The symptoms varying depending on whether it's
a) Single screen setup
b) Multiple screen setup
I've logged both separately. The latter "multiple screen" has been closed by Apple stating:
23-Aug-2013 08:04 AM Apple Developer Bug Reporting Team :
Engineering has determined that this is not to be fixed.
What the......
Can someone else with a multiple screen confirm this bug?
Summary:
Using iMac with Cinema Display and 10.9 (13A538g).
And now latest update
Primary display is iMac on left (which also shows Dock), and secondary Cinema Display is on right (which does not have a Dock).
Safari is moved to secondary display and a YouTube video is displayed using YouTube's "Full Screen" mode.
It correctly fills the secondary screen, but subsequently causes the Dock on the primary screen to auto hide.
Steps to Reproduce:
1. Use iMac with Cinema Display
2. Ensure Dock is on bottom with no auto hide.
3. Ensure Dock is on Primary Display (iMac) and Dock is not on Secondary Display (Cinema Display)
4. Open Safari Version 7.0 (9537.54.1)
5. Drag Safari onto second display
6. Open
http://www.youtube.com and select any video
7. Press on the bottom right "Full Screen" button which shows the video full screen - this should fill the entire secondary display
8. Immediately as 7. is performed, the Dock on the primary display auto hides
Expected Results:
Follow steps 1 to 7 above
8. The dock should not auto hide when something on the secondary display becomes full screen
My response to the "not to be fixed" was this:
The main reason for logging this was because of inconsistent and unexpected UI behaviour.
This is even more important given two main points:
1. Mavericks differs from Mountain Lion with multiple screen behaviour
2. Mavericks main differential selling point is an improvement to multiple screen behaviour
I point firstly to Apple advertising on Mavericks:
http://www.apple.com/au/osx/preview/?cid=wwa-au-kwg-mac
And one of the key points is "Multiple Displays" - hence why I have made an effort to log this case.
Apple advertising states:
"OS X Mavericks takes full advantage of every display connected to your Mac, giving you even more flexibility to work the way you want. There’s no longer a primary or secondary display — now each has its own menu bar, and the Dock is available on whichever screen you’re working on."
With this advertising the key point is:
1. Primary and secondary are independent for "flexibility" - unlike Mountain Lion
Independent means - that an operation on the secondary should not adversely impact the primary (and visa versa)
I have logged this bug mainly because:
1. This is Mavericks
2. This is a multple display bug
3. This bug breaks the independence noted in advertising
4. Mavericks comes with an updated version of Safari
5. Safari breaks independence with the most used webpage (YouTube) and the most used viewing method (FullScreen)
6. This bug will impact majority of user
7. This bug is always reproducible
And worst of all:
8. Firefox - the competitor browser does NOT break the screen independence
Effectively Apple's own browser is break Apple's advertised functionality
----------
In additional to the multiple screens - using only one screen produces an even worse bug:
Summary:
Using iMac and 10.9 (13A538g) and multiple desktops.
Safari opened at a YouTube video then displayed full screen with YouTube's "Full Screen" mode.
It correctly fills the screen.
Magic Trackpad 3 finger swipe gesture used to change to another desktop.
Dock quickly snaps back on desktop containing YouTube and subsequently cancels the 3 finger swipe gesture
Steps to Reproduce:
1. Use iMac Magic Trackpad (to access gestures)
2. Ensure Dock is on bottom with no auto hide and that at least 2 desktops exist
3. Open Safari Version 7.0 (9537.54.1)
4. Open
http://www.youtube.com and select any video
5. Press on the bottom right "Full Screen" button which shows the video full screen - this fills the entire display and Dock auto hides
6. Swipe on Magic Trackpad with 3 fingers in left motion (which effectively accesses additional desktop)
7. Immediately as 6 is performed, the original desktop snaps back quickly and the dock un-hides, the full screen YouTube is cancelled.
Expected Results:
Follow steps 1 to 6 above.
7. Additional desktop should show and dock should unhide
This occurs in all browsers - Safari and Firefox - so is probably more of a Mavericks UI bug rather than a Safari bug.