Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
That’s because you aren’t really getting a phone for 50% off. It’s subsidized in the cost of that extra line. Extra lines are pure profit for carriers.

If you don't think you're getting a discount. Next time you need a new line, could you give me the discount?

These are real cost and real discounts. You need to switch carriers every 2 years to realize the discount.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DEMinSoCAL
I still don't understand this. Sales tax should be based on the final price paid, not the claimed value prior to a discount.
I agree, it should, but AT&T doesn't make the rules about how to collect state sales tax. The states do.
 
Does anyone else see the comedy in this?

AT&T is pathetic.
Those are actually the names of all the different Unlimited plans that have existed for the past many years, and that many people are grandfathered on still. Nothing pathetic about it. It's just AT&T being clear which plans the deal is valid on.
 
What irkes me is that you have to be on an Unlimited plan to get it. I don't need unlimited data.

I wouldn't mind adding a line to get my daughter an iPhone 11, but I am still on a 12 gig data plan, which is plenty enough for us. With Rollover data, I usually have around 25 gig a month to use if I needed it.
 
But you are paying the sales tax on all of the device but only paying for half of the device. You are being taxed double what you owe. Where is that extra money going exactly? Merchants don't have to pay sales tax on part of good they discounted. If anything they get to write that off as a loss.
?????????????? I'm assuming you're not American, because this and your previous post show you know nothing about sales tax.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PC_tech
?????????????? I'm assuming you're not American, because this and your previous post show you know nothing about sales tax.

I know US tax. It's pretty simple. You pay the state a percentage of the price of what you are buying. If sales tax is 5% and the item is $100 than you pay $5 in tax or $105 total.

If the manufacturer say this device is $100 and the store sells it for $50 you pay 5% sales tax on what the store is charging you - not what the manufacturer claims it is worth.

So $50 would be $2.50 in tax or $52.50 total. In the USA you do not pay 5% on a hypothetical $100 item and then get $50 removed.

:rolleyes:

If they claim it's half off the phone than they should collect the tax for half a phone . If they claim its off service they should not claim you get the phone for half price... because you didn't.
 
Those are actually the names of all the different Unlimited plans that have existed for the past many years, and that many people are grandfathered on still. Nothing pathetic about it. It's just AT&T being clear which plans the deal is valid on.

lol, I think you just made my point again in an even better way
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.