Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Deals: HomePod Returns to $199.99 at Best Buy ($99 Off)
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Correct. In my opinion. Isn’t that what this whole board is? Even the blind tests can change depending on the pool of candidates used for the experiment.
Get it. I got one a few months back. It’s the best speaker system in it’s class. If you are in the Apple ecosystem it’s well worth it.
haha, same with me. I am tempted but do I really need it? Also the idea of someone listening to you at all times is creepy. I know the same could happen with my iPhone.
Can someone who has owned the UE Megaboom 3 give an ojective comparison to HomePod? I don't use Siri enough for that to be of any benefit to me.
Additionally, how does the HomePod know which iphone user is speaking to play music from that persons collection?
Additionally, how does the HomePod know which iphone user is speaking to play music from that persons collection?
They're entirely different devices. The HomePod is, as the name suggests, a home speaker that heavily relies on you having a heavily Apple ecosystem already. You plug it into the wall and ideally never move it. The MegaBoom is a portable bluetooth speaker that plays for ~20ish hours on battery and works equally well with basically any device.
What exactly do you want to compare? If you need a home sound system, get a HomePod or a decent 2.1 setup (definitely go for the 2.1 if you don't need Siri). If you need a portable speaker, the HomePod doens't do that, so look at the MegaBoom or other bluetooth alternatives.
Last edited:
Thank you. I'm sorry for not qualifying a bit better what I am curious to know. I am more curious of the sound quality and the functional differences. For instance, I own two of the UE MB3's and the "Party Up" mode where more than one MB3 has constant skips in the music - single speaker use is great. I would like to ideally use the HomePod as a multiroom speaker system rather than a stereo setup - I would purchase 3 of them to start. Currently, we use the MB3 speakers when we go camping for their portability. We own only Apple devices (iPhone, iPad, Apple Watch, Apple TV, MacBook Air, iMac) so no issue with the compatibility with HomePod.
I bought 2 during the last sale. I love them! But they are not easy to use. Often only one speaker works even though they are paired. Can pause sound from AirPlay such as a movie on iPad with Siri but cannot resume (it will start to play music). Not disappointed at all though they are the best speakers I’ve ever owned. Beautiful looking and they sound great to me as a lay person, not an audiophile. I hope to keep them for a decade or more.
As a multi-room home system, the HomePod is probably fine especially given your all-Apple setup. The bass can be a little lacking depending on the size of your rooms, but playback should be way better than on the MegaBooms (caveat: my HomePod experience is more limited than my UE Megaboom experience).
Soundbars are far worse and less versatile than speakers. The HomePod definitely has plenty room for improvement, but this isn't the right direction.
I currently have a Harmon Kardon Onyx Studio 4. A $350 dumb speaker that sounds fantastic to me. I was thinking of getting another so to pair them. But now, I think instead and for a bit more $$ step up to smart speakers and get two HomPods. One advantage of the onyx is portability / with hours of use on its internal battery... great for BBQ and pool parties and etc. Any idea how the sound would compare, two Onyx 4 vs two HomePods?
Read about the internals. All premium quality and the engineering is both innovative and untouchable at this price. Or even at $400
[automerge]1595278723[/automerge]
You must work for google. Or have ear blockage
[automerge]1595278861[/automerge]
So can the HomePod. I stream whatever I want. I don’t use Siri. Just select the Home source for sound on your phone. Has to be an iPhone tho. It’s that easy.
[automerge]1595279089[/automerge]
Room filling unsurpassed sound for a tabletop speak. The bass alone is incredible.
Last edited:
I picked 1 up on the last sale out of boredom and my "f it" mood at the time. Thought I'd mess with it and return it, blew my mind. I just ordered a 2nd to make a stereo pair. I would not pay $299 for 1 of these but at $199 it's a good buy. I stopped using my sound bar/surround sound for music and am using HomePod exclusively. Blows my expensive sound system out of the water.
Curious to read your stereo pair assessment when you get your 2nd one. For me, the difference was quite dramatic.
I already have a 7.4.4 setup in my main room and a 5.2.2 in my bedroom. I guess it’s pointless for me with a home stereo.
I love my one and I clicked the link to buy my second. I like it much better than my Sonos....the sound was unimpressive. Love the simplicity of the HomePod.