Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Most of the software had to be paid for. So people have the right to complain there. Pulling the software was a stupid move from Apple.

I can understand when they pull it from the store but not from my purchases.
 
The price of the software was included in the price of the computer. Even the price of "free" upgrades. This is well known, Apple defers revenue.
Eh, nonsense. Macs have not increased in price in the past 10+ years and Mac users used to pay for OS X and it was $129 back in the day. Fast forward today and now OS X is free. It's not included in the price of a Mac.
 
Are the people defending this change of heart the same people who were ok with the original software removals - or is it the other way around? The apologies fly so fast around here that I just can't tell anymore.
Show me where anyone so far is defending Apple? I haven't seen one post. But on the flip side your post along with a few others isn't any better not giving the benefit of the doubt that it could've been just a glitch.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gasu E.
Remember the Xcode disaster from last week because developers did not download from the official App Store? What about having to download an OS from an untrusted source because Apple took down the official link.

They should have just sent a notification to their customers. It's 2015: doesn't cost that much ;-)
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: JackANSI
The article says, "Only one of the apps, Aperture, will continue to be compatible with OS X El Capitan."

Has anyone confirmed with the GM that Aperture works near flawlessly with El Capitan?
 
I think it should be available for as long as the hardware which requires it still runs.
I'm afraid they'll have to keep it forever, or give the customer the possibility to "download-and-archive" for unsupported legacy use.

If you bought software on optical media, you also keep it forever. Who's stopping you from installing Mac OS 9 on a PowerPC G4? Many simply like nostalgia.

If downloading the app and archiving it (using the built-in OS X tool) is the 100% solution to the backup, then that is fine.
So, in the store (and via email) you are informed over the upcoming removal from the Mac App Store (30 days), that gives you the possibility to download and archive.
After that Apple can remove the legacy software from MAS.
 
There, now people can make backups of their software, and perhaps stop complaining when Apple finally takes down the stuff that was largely FREE to begin with.
Oh geez, what exactly is wrong with Apple just leaving the downloads up? Not everyone wants or can use the latest version of all software. Or is it the Apple way to make users keep an HDD full of backups of software?
 
Last edited:
There, now people can make backups of their software, and perhaps stop complaining when Apple finally takes down the stuff that was largely FREE to begin with.

I agree. I understand it somewhat regarding aperture, but what do you care if the rest was removed? You'll never use them anyway.
 
I'm still having trouble updating even though it is on the Purchased tab now. It says item not available and to try later.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JackRoch
Other than the pro apps, how many people are still relying on old versions of software like iPhoto? (Other than people simply not willing to opt in to the newer versions of the software).
I can understand the need to have a sort of legacy support for pro apps.
I don't really see a point in keeping old unsupported legacy software.
On the other hand, I'm guessing Apple could've moved the old software into the classic download-from-a-site model.
 
Silly decision to begin with, especially in relation to iPhoto which I personally much prefer to 'Photos' - it's easier to navigate and use for me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JackANSI
There, now people can make backups of their software, and perhaps stop complaining when Apple finally takes down the stuff that was largely FREE to begin with.
Largely free? Well Aperture was definetly not free and even if it was, it is like someone coming to my house and take a CD he gifted me away just because..... I mean free does not mean you can take it away ..... i still "purchased it" as it states on the recipt the Store sent me (even if it was stated as free of charge i still got a recipt so it is MINE!)

Now that they do not support it is fine by me and it was stated before, but to take it away is another matter, I can still install Windows XP on a old PC (not that i would want to even touch windows) if i want to, sure i know it won't be safe and such but no one will take that possibility away.

Will Aperture work on future OS X? may be not, but i want to be able to redownload and install it on the supported os as much as i want to..... heck i have some G4 iMac still running and with the right software they still serve a purpose.

As of backups, i tought one cool feature of buying from a store like this was the fact that i didn't t need to back it up...

Apparently it was a mistake from Apple, either they took it down by mistake or they mistakenly tought they could get away with it.... as per their 180 turn, apps are back online that must mean something....
 
  • Like
Reactions: Celebion
There, now people can make backups of their software, and perhaps stop complaining when Apple finally takes down the stuff that was largely FREE to begin with.

Almost as arrogant as expecting perpetually hosted legacy software that you likely didn't buy anyway. GIMME GIMME GIMME, right?

This is the kind of arrogance from mac users that is the reason why I distance myself from the mac community... also part of the reason why non-apple 'fanboys' see so many of you as smug.
 
Hard to imagine Apple would willingly remove Aperture already. I stopped using it but I'm sure many people still use it, and paid good money for it.

Decisions or mistakes like this have the power to undermine confidence in the App Store model.
 
  • Like
Reactions: beebarb
Almost as arrogant as expecting perpetually hosted legacy software that you likely didn't buy anyway. GIMME GIMME GIMME, right?

If all those apps were free then that's understandable. But paid apps should always be available no matter what. And if Apple decides to remove them , then they should refund users their money.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LV426
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.