Good news and bad news:
Good news: I found and bought a brand new/sealed 40mm Anchor Gray sport loop on OfferUp for $24.
Bad News: It wasn't 40mm, it wasn't Anchor Gray, and it wasn't an Apple band. It was a fake 42/44mm pure black sport loop band.
The green strip to open the box was still in tact, but upon a closer look, they probably went through the other side of the box very carefully, and sealed it back up. Thankfully, OfferUp was very quick to repond to and approve my claim. As soon as the seller gets the band back, they'll send me a refund. They even sent me a return shipping label, so it'll cost me nothing to return it.
In general, I'm not a big fan of OfferUp. I've
almost been scammed a couple other times, and at least half of the sellers don't respond to my questions or offers.
Here's what I got:
View attachment 949889