Louis Rossmann posted a new video about a T2 failure.... its really making me second guess buying a MBP next Friday
i don't trust louis fully, his whole thing is make apple look bad as possibleBashing Apple is part of Rossmann’s business strategy and I wouldn’t take anything he says for a grain of rice. His overblown sensationalism and way to conceal facts from the viewer are not helping his trustworthiness either.
@jgorman, this is a legitimate concern, but it’s ultimately not different from an SSD controller failing. What we lack is information about actual failures. How likely is T2 to fail compared to a usual enterprise-level SSD controller chip? Until we have clear information in regards to this, it’s just idle speculation. Over the last 7 years, since SSDs became commonplace in Apple laptops, I’ve only seen one or two SSD failures, and none of them were on a T2 equipped machine. It doesn’t say much of course, but my point being that since it’s such a low-frequency event, it’s real impact is negligible.
P.S. as to liquid damage stuff, it’s not a new story. We have such reports regularly, with many upset users even posting pictures of their allegedly liquid damaged logic boards. In most of these cases, liquid damage is clearly visible on the picture, even if the user is adamant it didn’t happen.
it’s ultimately not different from an SSD controller failing.
Don't trust Rossman? Is a Canadian news source that went undercover good enough for ya?Bashing Apple is part of Rossmann’s business strategy and I wouldn’t take anything he says for a grain of rice. His overblown sensationalism and way to conceal facts from the viewer are not helping his trustworthiness either.
@jgorman, this is a legitimate concern, but it’s ultimately not different from an SSD controller failing. What we lack is information about actual failures. How likely is T2 to fail compared to a usual enterprise-level SSD controller chip? Until we have clear information in regards to this, it’s just idle speculation. Over the last 7 years, since SSDs became commonplace in Apple laptops, I’ve only seen one or two SSD failures, and none of them were on a T2 equipped machine. It doesn’t say much of course, but my point being that since it’s such a low-frequency event, it’s real impact is negligible.
P.S. as to liquid damage stuff, it’s not a new story. We have such reports regularly, with many upset users even posting pictures of their allegedly liquid damaged logic boards. In most of these cases, liquid damage is clearly visible on the picture, even if the user is adamant it didn’t happen.
He definitely has made a business of bashing apple and making money, yet with that said most (all?) of his criticisms is based on fact and actual failures from apple.Bashing Apple is part of Rossmann’s business strategy and I wouldn’t take anything he says for a grain of rice. His overblown sensationalism and way to conceal facts from the viewer are not helping his trustworthiness either.
Apple by policy won't repair any laptop with those red-dot moisture indicators activated. That is the real "scandal" of that whole story (which I agree is probably unfair). They are trying to make it more than that, which frankly is something that particular show does all the time.Don't trust Rossman? Is a Canadian news source that went undercover good enough for ya?
Don't trust Rossman? Is a Canadian news source that went undercover good enough for ya?
How else do you make someone credible than by a 3rd-party mentioning you? He was not the only one used for their insight.Lol, you're questioning someone about trusting Rossman by posting a video that takes a MacBook to Rossman that is asking us to trust what he says? I don't follow.
"As you can see.. it shows just about no sign that liquid has ever been here."
I'm not an expert, but the board either shows signs of liquid damage or it doesn't, right? "Just about no sign" of liquid doesn't sound very definitive to me coming from an expert like Rossman. Poor choice of words?
Really?
Yes, really.
I have no rose colored Apple glasses on here. I'm 100% supportive of states passing Right to Repair laws and Apple's machines being more user serviceable.
Rossmann, being a professional, saying a logic board has just about no signs of liquid makes me wonder if he's observing *some potential signs* of liquid damage and glossing over it.
If you look at Rossmann's youTube channel he has examples of boards that did not show on visual inspection, liquid damage. But then when he un-soldered components he found liquid damage underneath components. This makes me question any inspection that did not involve un-soldering components.
Very interesting. It was an honest question on my part + playing a bit of devil's advocate here..
While Rossmann has legitimate reasons to have contempt for Apple and he does a good service by bringing some of Apple's more questionable practices to light, much like a fan who love all things Apple no matter what, his bias against Apple is pretty extreme and predictable.
Linus Tech Tips is more of a happy medium for me.
Difficult to consider LTT as a medium when they inject sponsors left & right.Very interesting. It was an honest question on my part + playing a bit of devil's advocate here..
While Rossmann has legitimate reasons to have contempt for Apple and he does a good service by bringing some of Apple's more questionable practices to light, much like a fan who love all things Apple no matter what, his bias against Apple is pretty extreme and predictable.
Linus Tech Tips is more of a happy medium for me.
Dave2D is much preferred to me as well. I also recommend MobileTechReviews.Dave2D is my middle ground
Yes, I enjoy both of those myself. Lisa does some remarkable, and indepth reviews.Dave2D is much preferred to me as well. I also recommend MobileTechReviews.
How else do you make someone credible than by a 3rd-party mentioning you? He was not the only one used for their insight.
The amount of people just targeting Rossmann and "not seeing the forest" is telling.
Too many people wearing rosy Apple goggles.
No argument, but he does back up his comments with evidence. Say what you will about Rossman, the onus on many of the issues is on Apple.is that Rossman hates Apple and dedicates a serious amount of time badmouthing them, T2 chip discussion aside.
No argument, but he does back up his comments with evidence. Say what you will about Rossman, the onus on many of the issues is on Apple.
They are fighting the right to repair, they are the ones that implemented proprietary technology to prevent independent shops from repairing Apple products.. Apple's cutting corners that resulted in flexgate, or the butterfly keyboard, etc etc.
He's been bad mouthing apple for years, well before the T2 and his points have always been based on apple's quality, or design, or customer support. He's said on many occasiosn that repairing Macs have been good for him. I understand his and other independent repair shops frustration, apple can be very anti-competitive and we see this instance here.He can’t repair the newer machines so he just constantly bad mouths Apple
Yes and no, I agree that his rants have turned into a cottage industry for him, but not for nothing, Apple has and continues to give me plenty of ammunition for those rants.don’t think he does what he does for the “common good.” He does what he does because it gets him clicks