Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Do you hear the difference between a 128 and 320 kbps mp3? (test yourself inside!)
- Thread starter profit42
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
I got it wrong. I noticed a slight difference but honestly couldn't tell which one was better. I can tell that my higher bitrate songs sound better than my lower bitrate ones, though. Probably because I'm not used to classical music.
Nice post though.
Nice post though.
ironically, it was a lot easier differentiating on my MBP speakers then it was with my headphones 
regardless, it was pretty close, definitely not the "zomg, it's like, so obvious with my xxx brand gear!"
something else i found that was weird was after i went for round 2 of listening test, it was even harder to tell the difference. after about the 4th time it just all sounded the same to me.
really though, if i had this on as background music while i was working i don't think i would have been able to distinguish the difference even if someone held a gun to my head
regardless, it was pretty close, definitely not the "zomg, it's like, so obvious with my xxx brand gear!" something else i found that was weird was after i went for round 2 of listening test, it was even harder to tell the difference. after about the 4th time it just all sounded the same to me.
really though, if i had this on as background music while i was working i don't think i would have been able to distinguish the difference even if someone held a gun to my head
the sound test
I ve always had my music in 128 in order to save space and being that I did not hear a difference it did not matter. but guess what I did hear a difference, I got 6 out of 6 correct. I heard the 320 much crispier, brighter and clearer than the 128. I said wow, big difference there. I don't know what to do, should I convert all my music to 320? I mean it is probably the double or more in space usage, right? Maybe there will be some cds I will have to have in 320 others won't matter I guess. but guys n gals there is a difference.
I ve always had my music in 128 in order to save space and being that I did not hear a difference it did not matter. but guess what I did hear a difference, I got 6 out of 6 correct. I heard the 320 much crispier, brighter and clearer than the 128. I said wow, big difference there. I don't know what to do, should I convert all my music to 320? I mean it is probably the double or more in space usage, right? Maybe there will be some cds I will have to have in 320 others won't matter I guess. but guys n gals there is a difference.
Easy. I got it first try.
Even 320 isn't that great of a digital quality. Honestly, it's the lowest I can stand.
I rip all my cd's in .wav
Even 320 isn't that great of a digital quality. Honestly, it's the lowest I can stand.
I rip all my cd's in .wav
Attachments
Last edited:
I could tell. Everything sounds a little watery in the 128kbps version. God bless my 320kbps MP3 collection and its near perfect audio quality (although I'm sure with some of you people out there its lossless or nothing).
Wow... just realized, necro-thread.
Wow... just realized, necro-thread.
I could tell the difference... barely.
However, I feel the disparity between the two bit rates becomes much more pronounced if it were to be a piece of music I knew very well. I've done tests like these on my own with my own music, and yeah; there is a massive difference between the two when it's a song you've heard 1000 times.
However, I feel the disparity between the two bit rates becomes much more pronounced if it were to be a piece of music I knew very well. I've done tests like these on my own with my own music, and yeah; there is a massive difference between the two when it's a song you've heard 1000 times.
Pay $25 or so for iTunes Match, let it match all your music, and download all the matches in 256KBit AAC format. Should be better than 320KBit MP3. The rest you have to rip again from your CDs; converting 128KBit to 320KBit with any software doesn't actually improve it.