Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Do you like the touchbar?

Do you like the touchbar?

  • Yes

    Votes: 126 55.5%

  • No

    Votes: 101 44.5%
  • Total voters
    227
Zerosopher said:
However, it’s not too bad as long as I can connect to the external keyboard.
Click to expand...

Whilst i get that this is a work-around, this is sold as a premium machine. If i wanted to be plugging in external keyboards just to have something that wasn't objectively worse for my use case, i'd buy some crappy chromebook. Not spend 3x the amount on a high end machine.

Apple's portable keyboards used to be pretty great. My 2015's still is....
 
i love the touchbar, but with bettertouchtools, is like the jailbreak for the iphone, it let you do more customizations
I can't go back to physicals keys (except the esc key)
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: bluespark
ghanwani said:
You have articulated my problem with it. The two things I use those keys for are display brightness and volume. Now I have to look at that bar to do either of those. Additionally, physical function keys require to be depressed before they do anything. If my hand accidentally rests on that area, it does something funny depending on the app I am in, e.g. starting a screen share during a conference call in zoom/Skype when it wasn’t intended, some other funky behavior in word/ppt, etc.

But based on this poll our views are in a minority.
Click to expand...

i quite dislike apple's version of the touchbar, but using BTT its become actually kind of pleasant.

its a super minimalistic setup where all i have showing is a persistent set of spotify controls so i can play/pause/skip music from whatever app i'm in (and not have quicktime or web videos hijack the traditional media controls) . i configured two finger swipes to adjust volume and 3 finger swipes for brightness so now those two tasks are actually the easiest thing ever to work with.
 
dannyyankou said:
I do not, there's some quality content on Youtube now and I think people should be paid for what they put into it. If you use an ad blocker, they're not paid.
Click to expand...

With some ad blockers you can whitelist certain channels, so that 30 sec ad before a 30 sec teaser for the latest superhero movie, you can block, but for the guy who isn't a shill that's reviewing products in depth or showing you how to DIY a keyboard tray under your desk or whatever, he still gets his ad rev.
 
I was pretty excited about it. I am a first time Mac user and saw how it can be used to switch tabs, windows etc and I keep a lot of windows and tabs open and also the bookmarks. BUT after getting it I have found that only applies to safari not chrome. So with chrome it’s useless. It’s pretty and kinda cool but that’s about it.

Not overall impressed either. Pretty sure I’m returning it and getting a dell XPS that is more powerful for about $700 less
 
Pretty happy with it. Much better control over screen brightness and volume. It also gives tiny previews of your slides in PowerPoint which is nice when you are presenting. You can see which slide you are on and what is coming up next.
 
I dislike it very much.

First, I always prefer to have physical keys, and miss the escape key (I configured the touch bar to display it but I would like a physical key much better).
Second, I do not find it useful to have the touch bar adapt to context, as it means that I have to look at it whenever I switch to another program, that uses it differently. Due to this, I configured a fixed touch bar layout.
Third, I sometimes activates commands on it by inadvertence so that it slows me down.
Last, every once in a while it crashes the computer. I do not see why to accept these crashes while I personally do not benefit from the touch bar functionality.

All in all, I see no benefit, even though there are costs induced by it. I will actively avoid it in the future (as of today, it would mean getting a macbook air instead of a macbook pro).
 
  • Like
Reactions: john905r and mouthster
icymountain said:
I dislike it very much.

First, I always prefer to have physical keys, and miss the escape key (I configured the touch bar to display it but I would like a physical key much better).
Second, I do not find it useful to have the touch bar adapt to context, as it means that I have to look at it whenever I switch to another program, that uses it differently. Due to this, I configured a fixed touch bar layout.
Third, I sometimes activates commands on it by inadvertence so that it slows me down.
Last, every once in a while it crashes the computer. I do not see why to accept these crashes while I personally do not benefit from the touch bar functionality.

All in all, I see no benefit, even though there are costs induced by it. I will actively avoid it in the future (as of today, it would mean getting a macbook air instead of a macbook pro).
Click to expand...

Does the MacBook Air not have the problem of crashes caused by the T2 chip? Even though it doesn’t have the TB it does have the T2 chip.
 
When it first launched I didn't use it that much. Now that a lot of apps support it, I really like it. Adobe in particular, has done a really good job adapting the CC apps to use it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jerryk
ghanwani said:
Does the MacBook Air not have the problem of crashes caused by the T2 chip? Even though it doesn’t have the TB it does have the T2 chip.
Click to expand...

Could be. My feeling was that the issue was related to the touch bar as each occurrence started with a freeze of the TB, followed by a freeze of the machine within seconds. But you could be right.
 
Useless. Never used it. This is just my opinion. A hammer looking for a nail. Takes up valuable space that could be used for physical keys. (I NEVER heard ANYONE ever say, "Gee, I will there were lights where the F keys are." Ever.) It is a big negative for me and the fact that I am forced to take it keeps me away from the laptop.
[doublepost=1567216549][/doublepost]
MrRabuf said:
As a software developer who routinely uses function keys, I absolutely hate the touchbar and would love to have regular functions keys again. It's just a gimmick. Not to mention it's a waste for anyone who routinely uses an external keyboard with their MBP.
Click to expand...
You sir, are correct!
 
  • Like
Reactions: mouthster and MrRabuf
I have no problem with it at all and like how it looks and interacting with it. I am not someone who needs to use the function keys often, I could see how it would be bothersome in that case.
Surely they can retain the function keys and Touch Bar somehow.
 
I find it useful for the word suggestions, volume and brightness control. I've added the screen lock button for a quick way to, errr, lock the screen. It didn't take me long to get used to the Esc key.

I'd miss t.
 
I like it, because as a programmer, I can customize many parts of it (by writing custom programs and scripts that interact with BetterTouchTool that on its own offers a great deal of customization).

I wouldn't like it if I had to use the F Keys or ESC frequently, though, and maybe if I had a US keyboard (UK one has an extra key that I use to show and hide my custom touch bar display).
 
CheesePuff said:
I am constantly making accidental taps on the Touch Bar because it takes zero pressure for it to activate unlike a normal key
Click to expand...
I agree, I wish it had haptic feedback and was not quite so sensitive :eek:.
I'm new to the Touch Bar and have not quite figured out what I want to do with it, but I do love the Touch ID function.
 
I've been using MacBooks with the touchbar for 2 years, so far, I have found it useless. I remapped the caps lock to esc so I never touch the thing. I'm even using the goldenchaos preset.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ipponrg and Cape Dave
Qaulity said:
I've been using MacBooks with the touchbar for 2 years, so far, I have found it useless. I remapped the caps lock to esc so I never touch the thing. I'm even using the goldenchaos preset.
Click to expand...
I agree 1000%. Imagine if all the engineering that went into that thing had gone into better cooling? Or more reliable keyboards? Or just about ANYTHING else!
 
Interesting results. I don't own a MBP with a touchbar, but was expecting most to not like it.
 
I wish it floated above the physical keyboard...and that they would bring back the old style of buttons.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ipponrg
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back