For me, its not about love, hate, like, dislike, but does the operating system allow me to work the way I want to work, or must I conform to how it wants me to work. Does the non-core extraneous stuff interfere with my day to day activities, or are distracting enough for me to want to change operating systems?
Both Windows 11 and Tahoe largely allow me to work and play the way I want too.
Its the extraneous stuff that gets in the way and spoils the experience:
For Windows its copilot, its advertisements, its MS changing apps like notepad to something I don't want, ruining file explorer. Adding in RECALL where it takes a snapshot of each and every activity. Its finding out that MS has my decryption keys and the government can if they want too get those keys from MS. Updates that microsoft actually tells us to rollback and applying oujt of band hot fixes multiple times within a month
For macOS, the extraneous stuff, is seeing poor contrast in the control center, poor design in the systems settings, spotlight acting differently but not really impacting me
It seems for my experience, and personal opinion that macOS and particularly, Tahoe has a lot more going for it then Windows 11. Coming from (and still working in) windows 11, I'm really happy with how Tahoe is stable, fast doesn't get in my way.
There are people here in MR, that have threatened to leave the mac platform simply because the curvature of the corners is now different and they simply cannot tolerate such horrible decisions. I'm not saying Tahoe is perfect, there's plenty of rough spots, but Apple has dialed in and tightened the UI a lot since the beta, and the current version 26.2 is fast, stable, and no major issues with UI and UX