Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Does your 3GS emit the "15KHz tone"?

  • Yes I hear it.

    Votes: 99 53.5%
  • Nope, can't hear a thing.

    Votes: 86 46.5%

  • Total voters
    185
I can hear it on my phone. It would not really bother me if it just played for a few seconds after lock/unlock/text sounds, but on my phone the noise can be heard while recording and during playback of Voice Memos and Video Recordings.
 
My mom's 3G (which I'm using until I get my 3G S) makes a hissing noise for a few seconds. Weird.
 
You would think that Apple would have to come out with some type of fix for this as it is affecting so many people. I know the original article mentioned it might be software. Hopefully it's a simple fix.
 
SW update

I think we'll see a SW update this week, always happens.

I think since they just pushed out 3.0 to the massed of 2.0 and 3G users, AND they have all the new sales going through the same itunes/activation servers, they don't want to muddle up the interwebs with another SW update, that EVERYONE and their brother will want to DL.

Wait till later this week, we should see something then I think
 
I have noticed a high pitched noise when I have my 3GS plugged into my car stereo. It's generally only when I first plug in my tape adapter to the earbud jack. Kind of weird.
 
I didn't notice until I checked. But when I went into settings and turned lock sounds on, I could hear it, but only with the speaker up to my ear.

Doesn't really bother me, though I would like a fix for it, obviously.
 
OH, wait. I can totally hear it! It's really quiet. I was expecting it to be loud enough to hear, but I have to literally put the speaker in my ear.

It happened after I locked my phone. It played for a few seconds and stopped.

It's more like 4500hz. I have an app called Oscillator that you can use to make sounds and specific frequencies, and 4500hz sounds more like it.

Yeah, I can definitely reproduce the sound every time.

1. Lock phone so that it plays the "lock" sound.
2. Hold phone's button speaker right next to your ear.

It's not that loud, but you should definitely be able to hear it. It's not 15khz.

Thanks for the info! The Oscillator app is awesome for basic testing of ears/speakers.
 
I've heard it from my phone a couple times, and not in the same situations you people have been describing. It is rather high pitched and I have no trouble hearing it from several feet away. I'm 27 and have exceptional hearing so perhaps it's not noticeable to some people.

It hasn't happened frequently enough to bother me yet so I haven't complained. I thought perhaps somehow the SPU got static in it or something, perhaps from the screen's electromagnetic field and that's why it has been inconsistent.

Whatever the case, I hope it can be addressed in software.

Note, after further experimentation I found a number of the SMS notification noises result in the same high pitch whine. I also noticed that a couple of the SMS notifications seem to just echo on for a very long time. This has brought me to the suspicion that the problem is caused by an erroneously programmed reverberation filter in the sound chip. If I'm right, it's definitely fixable by software.
 
I can hear it on mine, but not unless there is zero ambient noise or I hold the phone up to my ear. My guess is that the sound file Apple uses to make the lock noise has an empty void for a few seconds at the end and the compression process mutated it into a high frequency tone. They could probably just fix the sound file in the next OS release to make it go away.
 
I can hear it on mine, but not unless there is zero ambient noise or I hold the phone up to my ear. My guess is that the sound file Apple uses to make the lock noise has an empty void for a few seconds at the end and the compression process mutated it into a high frequency tone. They could probably just fix the sound file in the next OS release to make it go away.

That's the most logical explanation yet. Thanks.
 
I can hear it if I put the speaker to my ear, otherwise I don't notice it. It happens after SMS is received, locking the phone and after closing some apps that have sound. For example, after exiting Paper Toss and the sound fades out the noise can be heard with the speaker to ear, but not after playing Parachute Panic. Oddly, the sound only goes for a few seconds after locking and closing some apps but goes on for about 30 seconds or more after getting an SMS.
 
I'm 42, and I can hear it!

OH, wait. I can totally hear it! It's really quiet. I was expecting it to be loud enough to hear, but I have to literally put the speaker in my ear.

It happened after I locked my phone. It played for a few seconds and stopped.

It's more like 4500hz. I have an app called Oscillator that you can use to make sounds and specific frequencies, and 4500hz sounds more like it.

Yeah, I can definitely reproduce the sound every time.

1. Lock phone so that it plays the "lock" sound.
2. Hold phone's button speaker right next to your ear.

It's not that loud, but you should definitely be able to hear it. It's not 15khz.


I can hear it, it happens every time I lock the phone. It's not that the pitch is so incredibly high, it just very quite. I did NOT notice it until I read the Boy Genius report and tried it myself. I have to hold it up to my ear, even in a quite room. It's not a big deal to me, but if they can correct it via software, that would be great.
 
I can hear it, it happens every time I lock the phone. It's not that the pitch is so incredibly high, it just very quite. I did NOT notice it until I read the Boy Genius report and tried it myself. I have to hold it up to my ear, even in a quite room.
Same... I had to push it against my ear to hear it. Never would have noticed otherwise. What I don't hear won't bother me.
 
My guess is that the sound file Apple uses to make the lock noise has an empty void for a few seconds at the end and the compression process mutated it into a high frequency tone.

Actually, I think the compression processing is being done on-the-fly in certain circumstances. It probably occurs somewhere pretty far down the signal chain, after a fair bit of noise has been accumulated. When this compression is then applied, the noise is, as you say, mutated into the tone we're hearing.
 
I don't hear anything and I'm not over the age of 35 haha... I'll ask my friends tomorrow.

Edit: Nvm I was putting my ear to the wrong speaker, I can hear it too. It's pretty loud when you put it right next to your ear.
 
I have my lock/unlock sounds off, but I turned them on to test. I can report both mine and my wife's 3gs make the sound for a few seconds after locking the phone.
 
My iPhone (the original) sounds like static for a few seconds after it makes any type of sound. I don't think it is limited to the 3G S. It's probably just noise in the signal while the speaker is receiving power.
 
I hear it after taking a picture (for about 3 seconds and then the pitch drops then stops), and after it makes the lock sound when I put it to sleep. Same thing, high pitched for 2½-3 seconds, then gets lower and fades out.

I am the type of person who is bothered by high pitched whines and sounds constantly (had to return three Palm Pilots for the noise), but I can only hear this when the speaker is within eight or so inches of my ear, so I don't care.
 
My iPhone (the original) sounds like static for a few seconds after it makes any type of sound. I don't think it is limited to the 3G S. It's probably just noise in the signal while the speaker is receiving power.

Im using the 3G still and it does it on mine, but rather than a high pitched sound its more like a hissing sound like static
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.