Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Eve devices updated with Matter will continue to work with HomeKit, with no change to the Home app experience, but once a device has been updated to Matter, it cannot be migrated back to HomeKit.
Huh? 🤔
 
  • Like
Reactions: Solver
Yet companies like Nanoleaf say you need to buy all new products with Matter and they can’t update any existing items.

Probably explains the rash of sales to dump older product.
That MAY in fact be true for Nanoleaf. You have no idea exactly what chips they are using, or how much memory space they have available on their chips, or whatever.
The fact that Eve can do this (on SOME of their devices, note not all of them) has zero relevance to whether other companies using other chipsets can do it.
 
No, it's not surprising at all.
The point is that ONLY Apple HW that is 16.2 or later can speak Matter. So, if you upgrade your Eve device to Matter, then don't complain when it stops working in your iOS 16.1 house. (Or, more likely, if you give it to a friend, or move it to the office, or whatever.)
They are trying to point out that if you do not live on the leading edge (do not plan to update your entire Apple ecosystem to 16.2) then you will be very upset after your upgrade your Eve device to Matter and your old Apple products can no longer communicate with it.

That makes sense and is also kind of what I said. Just goes to show how badly worded the original statement was.
 
Not necessarily. A Matter device could just use WiFi instead of Thread for transport.
From my understanding, Hue does that with WiFi to the hub and then Zigbee as transport to end devices. It’s Matter in that control is allowed by multiple ecosystems and not just HomeKit. Still some features unavailable outside the Hue app.
 
IT'S HAPPENING, PEOPLE!!!

Love that Eve is the first to the space here. (besides Apple I guess). They're always pushing the envelope on technology and I love how they're focused on Privacy as well. I'll continue supporting them for a long time.
 
Is there a disadvantage upgrading to Matter?
Answer: "Currently, iPhone users can upgrade selected Eve devices to Matter using the Eve app. Eve-specific, custom functionality will be preserved."

That's from the eve home website.
 
I think it is actually vice versa. Thread is an actual RF protocol like Wifi and Bluetooth, and Matter is a software protocol like TCP/IP. So something may or may not have a Thread radio but may still use the Matter protocol over Wifi or Bluetooth. But if something has a Thread radio it definitely supports Matter.
The latter is not the case. Nanoleaf bulbs support Thread, but the current generation won't support Matter - not enough memory. The next gen models will have Matter support.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CarAnalogy
Whilst I was excited for Matter & what it brings meaning a whole boatload of devices can be seen in the Home app, the realisation now is a bit of disappointment.
Sure I can now buy cameras which can use the Home app, but I'm crippled in that it does not mean Homekit Secure Video compatibility, so looks like there still very few to choose from & I can't see Matter changing that,
 
Ok this is going to be another negative comment but:

If you’ve ever used the eve app, you’ll likely never buy another eve product again. Man it’s bad.
How so? I’ve been very happy with the app their hardware. Eve’s thread enabled hardware has been rock-solid and very reliable. The app is also great for seeing the status of my thread network. I also like their focus on user privacy.
 
So one of the elephants in the room is that Matter does not seem to be compatible with 16.1 as announced, but requires 16.2.
 
Is there a disadvantage upgrading to Matter?
Answer: "Currently, iPhone users can upgrade selected Eve devices to Matter using the Eve app. Eve-specific, custom functionality will be preserved."

That's from the eve home website.

It’s possible that older devices that can’t be upgraded to the newest HomeKit would no longer be able to control these accessories. I have an iPad Air (1st gen) on my wall that’s stuck on iOS 12 that won’t be able to control my home once I update to the new HomeKit architecture. Eve seems to be transitioning to this same architecture which is why it needs iOS 16.2. And that’s why these upgrades are optional.
 
Did anybody else notice the spelling and grammatical errors in the upgrade popup in the post screenshot?
 
  • Like
Reactions: gk_brown
Admittedly I didn't really read up on the whole Matter topic yet and what changes it implies, though even after reading this paragraph 3 times, i have no idea what it aims to tell me.
Seems like the second half of the sentence contradicts the first half, no?
Yeah, confusing. Is Matter a replacement for HomeKit? Is HomeKit deprecated?
 
The smart home has been promised for nearly two decades. This seems like it might finally make it happen. Most of us don't have to do anything, but in a couple of years we'll have it.

Remember all those “house of the future” Looney Tunes from like the 50s? Nothing quite worked right there either. A chilling vision of things to come.
 
No, I believe that matter only uses the thread protocol. For instance, if you have zigbee devices, they cannot be updated to support matter. You might get a zigbee bridge that supports matter however.

AFAIK, at this time, Matter can use Thread or WiFi for transport, and in the case of Thread, is required to use Bluetooth LE for initial setup (perhaps there is no standard way to do that directly via Thread accessible from controlling devices like most smartphones, given that most existing smartphones do not have the hardware to directly speak Thread); whereas there are existing ways to set up new WiFi devices (like having them come up initially as an access point for an SSID with a documented name, such that you temporarily switch you phone to be on that WiFi - or in some cases, the setup app handles that for you). And I gather other IPv6 capable transports such as wired Ethernet or cellular modem are quite possible.

As such, for example Philips Hue uses Zigbee to talk to the bulbs and switches, but has a bridge that speaks both Zigbee and wired Ethernet. What I've heard is that there will be a firmware upgrade for the bridge, that will speak Matter (presumably over the Ethernet side).

So no Matter over bridge-less Zigbee, but since Zigbee requires a coordinator device even for local inter-device communication and requires a bridge for access to the Internet or by non-Zigbee-speaking devices, if the bridge is upgradeable, no big deal except waiting for the upgrade. :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pianoplayah
Remember all those “house of the future” Looney Tunes from like the 50s? Nothing quite worked right there either. A chilling vision of things to come.

What I think is chilling is the lack of ECC RAM and CPUs in IoT devices, along with the lack of a commitment to either a minimum of five years of firmware security updates or preferably open source firmware. Without those, something that works today may randomly glitch or need to be power cycled (unplugged) at some unpredictable future time (what the ECC would help minimize) or be hackable by bad guys (what you need a commitment to security updates for).

Even industrial control (SCADA) devices have security issues due to either lack of firmware updates or the updates not being installed (a serious infrastructure vulnerability if not carefully managed, although I hope at least some of them do have decent ECC hardware). But the number of SCADA devices is tiny compared to the potential number of home automation IoT devices, and I really don't want some adversary where most of the hardware is actually made deciding to do leave a hardware or firmware back door allowing some massive denial of service attacks (or worse, like turn everything on that might be a heavy power draw or hopefully hazardous, while turning everything else off that's on) on both IoT and SCADA devices. That's at least as bad in its own way as the potential of now banned in the US Huawei devices infiltrating comms systems. Fully open source end device and hub firmware might make that preventable, not sure anything less would.
 
Good news: the entire point of Matter is that you won't need proprietary apps. Device manufacturers can stick to making hardware, make it Matter compatible and leave the software to software designers. Apple's Home app has already controlled all Eve devices, now any Matter controller software can do the same. You won't even need to download Eve's app to set up the devices.
Does Matter allow patching devices through a non-vendor app? If not you'd still need them for that.
 
Good news: the entire point of Matter is that you won't need proprietary apps. Device manufacturers can stick to making hardware, make it Matter compatible and leave the software to software designers. Apple's Home app has already controlled all Eve devices, now any Matter controller software can do the same. You won't even need to download Eve's app to set up the devices.
The whole point of Matter is that a device will work with Apple, Amazon, or Google ecosystems. Previous to Matter devices had to be certified with each, and often times there were different versions of a device for each ecosystem. Now hardware manufacturers can release one device that will work on all ecosystems. It has nothing to do with proprietary apps, many manufacturers will still release them.
 
I recall when they were elgato and made some excellent av stuff like tv recorders etc

Not really into all this smart home stuff tbh , feels a bit like big brother taking over

Blip on your social credit score ? , get locked out of your own house …
 
Does Matter allow patching devices through a non-vendor app? If not you'd still need them for that.

I recall that during Matter's development, OTA Firmware Updates were in the Matter specification.

Matter devices are operated via Controllers (i.e. HomePod, Apple TV, Amazon Echo, etc). These Controllers connect the devices to the internet, pool their status (on/off, firmware version, etc) and are able to perform OTA updates.
 
Decent read over at the Verge about this

I just got a bunch more Eve Energy devices in today. I had a mish-mash of Belkin and Eve stuff and I've chosen to consolidate towards the Eve side primary because they are moving forward rather quickly with the Matter implementation. (I do have some Wemo WSP100 devices that need a new home so to speak; separate thread in the buy/sell forums).

When the Eve Energy devices I have are updated to Matter, they will only work in Matter-enabled environments. This means they cannot work in legacy HomeKit environments (prior to iOS 16.2 basically), but they will be able to work in any Matter ecosystem (SamSung SmartThings, Google Home, and of course Apple Home, etc). This is kind of the point of Matter: to have smart home devices that can work seamlessly in any ecosystem. Matter is a sort of universal language these devices will speak, regardless of the ecosystem.

Anyway check out the article.**
If you want to switch to Matter now with Eve devices it's kind of a clunky process and has a few requirements. I'll be fumbling through this over the course of the week. Sometime in early 2023 we can expect the devices to ship with Matter built-in by default.


**Not affiliated with Eve or The Verge whatsoever, merely a home automation hobbiest!
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.