Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

DaBlackMamba

macrumors member
Original poster
Mar 14, 2011
71
19
My FaceID really only works well when the phone is facing me directly. If it’s laying flat on the table in front of me, it won’t work unless I lift it up a little. Is something wrong?

I didn’t upgrade from the 7 plus to move to something inferior. I can live with this for a year but they better put touchID in the screen next year as we knew they definitely wanted to do but couldn’t.
 

aacealo

macrumors member
Oct 15, 2012
34
9
I turned off the attention aware feature on mine because waking up and opening both eyes while looking at a bright screen wasn’t going to work. Same goes for steepish angles. Like... laying flat on the table in front of me. That’s not a particularly unusual case.

All in all the system works okay, but Touch ID was more reliable. Face ID has the convenience advantage. I love that it just attempts to authenticate and fill fields. That makes the experience seamless, but it also needs to be reliable and it currently is not.
 
Last edited:

aacealo

macrumors member
Oct 15, 2012
34
9
Reset FaceID and set it up like you will be unlocking. If you’re not unlocking from eye level, don’t set it up that way.

Works fine for me during the day, but it’s Apple’s job to understand that users may utilize the feature in many ways. The goal of making magical devices that “just work” can’t turn into beautiful devices that punk out more than the feature they replaced. Certain aspects may be more spontaneous, but using the phone in bed in a dark room or lying on a table versus holding the device squared to the eyes are variations that should just work and currently they’re intermittent at best.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DDustiNN

tromboneaholic

Suspended
Jun 9, 2004
3,706
3,024
Clearwater, FL
Works fine for me during the day, but it’s Apple’s job to understand that users may utilize the feature in many ways. The goal of making magical devices that “just work” can’t turn into beautiful devices that punk out more than the feature they replaced. Certain aspects may be more spontaneous, but using the phone in bed in a dark room or lying on a table versus holding the device squared to the eyes are variations that should just work and currently they’re intermittent at best.
I must be lucky. It failed for me once on Friday. I put my passcode in, and FaceID hasn’t failed again. It works in my car mount and on my desk at work. TouchID failed a couple of times on my iPad today though.
 

rkoshack

macrumors regular
Nov 30, 2012
145
54
I would assume it can only work if the camera can see you no?

Turn on the camera app front facing and if your face isn’t in the frame at that angle I would assume face Id won’t work at that angle either
 

nheilweil

macrumors 6502a
Jul 10, 2008
611
153
Redmond, WA
I would assume it can only work if the camera can see you no?

Turn on the camera app front facing and if your face isn’t in the frame at that angle I would assume face Id won’t work at that angle either
Absolutely correct! Turn your front-facing camera on and see how much tilt of the phone (or craning of your neck) you’ll need to get in the shot. FaceID wants at least half my face to determine it’s me.

This is the minimum I need to be in the shot for FaceID to work:

D9764D85-10FC-4DC6-80A4-0C44B2FAE47F.jpeg


Damn I’m good looking!
 

flat five

macrumors 603
Feb 6, 2007
5,580
2,657
newyorkcity
I would assume it can only work if the camera can see you no?

Turn on the camera app front facing and if your face isn’t in the frame at that angle I would assume face Id won’t work at that angle either
it uses a different system than the front facing camera.. the range for faceID is wider than the faceTime lens..

[edit] see picture above my post.. if that was faceID, it would fail but he's saying faceID works when the front camera sees that much..

[edit 2].. i just tried that.. i think you can be a little more outside of the example shown above.. my eyes were just inside the view of the faceTime camera and it unlocked with faceID..

if i tried it with just my eyebrows showing, it failed..

that said, there may be some other factors at play if trying this yourself.. different distances from the phone will likely show variances in how much the selfie cam can see during a successful face scan..
i was doing it while sitting in a chair with my phone on the desk.
 
Last edited:

Rahul katara

macrumors newbie
Nov 8, 2017
3
0
India
My FaceID really only works well when the phone is facing me directly. If it’s laying flat on the table in front of me, it won’t work unless I lift it up a little. Is something wrong?

I didn’t upgrade from the 7 plus to move to something inferior. I can live with this for a year but they better put touchID in the screen next year as we knew they definitely wanted to do but couldn’t.
the only problem is the face ID stopped working after the phone dropped from the head hieght.its camera was still intact and had no issues whatsoever.
So be careful
http://www.thehelicals.com/iphone-x-drop-test-simply-impressive/
 

jettie1767

macrumors 6502a
Oct 29, 2003
587
225
New Jersey, USA
I have this problem as well. I've boxed up my X and went back to my 8 Plus. But, tonight, I decided I will give it another try and see if I can make it work for me.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.